‘Alka isn’t qualified to judge voices’ - Page 2

Aadesh, pls quit, atleast then i can watch the show.

I want Aadesh to quit so as to keep the show going on

Maybe Aadesh will be as surprised to find he said this as he is when his scores are revealed. A standard score of 7 for everyone looks a lot like playing it safe.

I don't like high-pitched voices very much, but I do think Alka can sing, and I don't think that Aadesh's comments deserve to be taken seriously. If they would all talk less and say more, the show would be even better.

And 'dil ko chhooaa, nahin chhooaa,' and its cousins are not really substitutes for constructive, teaching critiques. All of them are guilty of this at different times.

Agree completely. I have never liked her voice or songs ... I like the song Sawariya Sawariya from Swades, so I tolerate her voice in that one. Wish it was sung by Madhushree or Sadhana Sargam...

Also agree that MDs are more capable of judging singers rather than the singers themselves..

Originally posted by: punjini

Actually, I agree with Aadesh about Alka's voice. She really lacks control and is too too high pitched. I've never got complete enjoyment from her songs.

very true said

Originally posted by: vanajaakshi

Maybe Aadesh will be as surprised to find he said this as he is when his scores are revealed. A standard score of 7 for everyone looks a lot like playing it safe.

I don't like high-pitched voices very much, but I do think Alka can sing, and I don't think that Aadesh's comments deserve to be taken seriously. If they would all talk less and say more, the show would be even better.

And 'dil ko chhooaa, nahin chhooaa,' and its cousins are not really substitutes for constructive, teaching critiques. All of them are guilty of this at different times.