nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
1.comedy fiction ya comedy reality show.

All actors r asked to over act like melodrama or do acting in reality show which is irritating viewers. d show is comedy not d characters .they r not comedian of reality show.
so some negative reactions r coming.
1. dolly is asked to imitate serial bahu with overacting to create laugh. Director should realise the difference between comedy fiction and reality comedy show. In the story she is affected by serial bahu. so should behave like her . but she is doing mockery which is not at all expected .she should not jibe on bahu. she should behave exactly like TV bahuye n and some other character can act like she is acting now to tease her or mock her so that fun is created .

2. Chintu is a smart guy ..still he has given some action like a stupid person . He is not a comedian he is protagonist . yes foolish behaviour creates comedy . but it should be given to extra character (like Radhe in HD) not to protagonist . protagonist should speak like a common person for example . Sahil in sarabhai vs sarabhai Sahil creates lot of comedy with his natural dialogue delivery

3. Repetition of one particular act or thoughtor behaviour do creates comedy. but there should be some verity in repetition to avoid boring for e.g Maya Sarabhai repeatedly accuse her bahu monisha for her middle class behaviour in same style . but each time with different examples.
Even in aggj that scientist jamai forgets something repeatedly but each time that something is different . so its create lough without bore feeling.

conclusion : All the characters (except one or two)in comedy fiction should generate comedy . but they should not be comedian . In fiction dialogues r very powerful to create comedy.
"Ye jo hai jindag' or sarabhai vs sarabhai r good comedy show Director should study them. Theme is nice to create comedy. Even Characteristic of each character is well define to create comedy
Jagdamba has this sense that she is not comedian ans she has to create comedy while acting as nanisaas and chief of the family. so without loosing this bearing she does it .
Edited by nutan7 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

1.3k

Users

5

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

Ranjinikishan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: nutan7

All actors r asked to over act like melodrama or do acting in reality show which is irritating viewers. d show is comedy not d characters .they r not comedian of reality show.
so some negative reactions r coming.
1. dolly is asked to imitate serial bahu with overacting to create laugh. Director should realise the difference between comedy fiction and reality comedy show. In the story she is affected by serial bahu. so should behave like her . but she is doing mockery which is not at all expected .she should not jibe on bahu. she should behave exactly like TV bahuye n and some other character can act like she is acting now to tease her or mock her so that fun is created .

2. Chintu is a smart guy ..still he has given some action like a stupid person . He is not a comedian he is protagonist . yes foolish behaviour creates comedy . but it should be given to extra character (like Radhe in HD) not to protagonist . protagonist should speak like a common person for example . Sahil in sarabhai vs sarabhai Sahil creates lot of comedy with his natural dialogue delivery

3. Repetition of one particular act or thoughtor behaviour do creates comedy. but there should be some verity in repetition to avoid boring for e.g Maya Sarabhai repeatedly accuse her bahu monisha for her middle class behaviour in same style . but each time with different examples.
Even in aggj that scientist jamai forgets something repeatedly but each time that something is different . so its create lough without bore feeling.

conclusion : All the characters (except one or two)in comedy fiction should generate comedy . but they should not be comedian . In fiction dialogues r very powerful to create comedy.
"Ye jo hai jindag' or sarabhai vs sarabhai r good comedy show Director should study them. Theme is nice to create comedy. Even Characteristic of each character is well define to create comedy
Jagdamba has this sense that she is not comedian ans she has to create comedy while acting as nanisaas and chief of the family. so without loosing this bearing she does it .


@bold: 2. yes chintoo is a smart guy.. what makes u to think that he is acting like a stupid person?? ofcourse he is a protagonist but he is not acting like comedian just his scenes are funny.. he never showed foolish behavior till now.. he is acting like a common person & thinks like a common person unlike others in the show

designersaini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
agree with u di...Sarabhai v/s Sarabhai was an epic comedy show...its each n every min was worth watching...n its still one f my fav...in Aggj everyone should keep a check on their scenes while enacting all d scenes looks like a overdose of overacting...even Sumit bhi apni awaaj kitna dabakar nikalta hai n im not liking dat...aur gharwalo ki to baat hi mat karo...dat dolly is serial ki bahu ka overdose...n kaunsi bahu aisi acting karti hai...she is like all d time itraing...n dolli's papa pata nahi har waqt kuch bhulte rehte hain n her mother is always 'aapse kuch nahi hoga'..
I know its all upon director but he should really check d other comedy shows like S v/s S...no overdose f comedy...it had sensible comedy
Ranjinikishan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: designersaini

agree with u di...Sarabhai v/s Sarabhai was an epic comedy show...its each n every min was worth watching...n its still one f my fav...in Aggj everyone should keep a check on their scenes while enacting all d scenes looks like a overdose of overacting...even Sumit bhi apni awaaj kitna dabakar nikalta hai n im not liking dat...aur gharwalo ki to baat hi mat karo...dat dolly is serial ki bahu ka overdose...n kaunsi bahu aisi acting karti hai...she is like all d time itraing...n dolli's papa pata nahi har waqt kuch bhulte rehte hain n her mother is always 'aapse kuch nahi hoga'..
I know its all upon director but he should really check d other comedy shows like S v/s S...no overdose f comedy...it had sensible comedy


@red: not all seema..u should say rest of the star cast specially dolly & lolly..they are killing the show with their weird expressions & over acting.

@blue: mere kayal se acc. to situation sumit voice change kiya hai purposely aur ye zaroori bi hai..kyu ki naani ko yakeen dilanata chintoo ko..so nothing wrong in it

about dolly completely agreed..she will ruin the show with her over acting if director dont control




ShivIka..Ketaki thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Ranjinikishan



@red: not all seema..u should say rest of the star cast specially dolly & lolly..they are killing the show with their weird expressions & over acting.

@blue: mere kayal se acc. to situation sumit voice change kiya hai purposely aur ye zaroori bi hai..kyu ki naani ko yakeen dilanata chintoo ko..so nothing wrong in it

about dolly completely agreed..she will ruin the show with her over acting if director dont control





haa seema di me bhi rajni dise agree hu sumit ne awaj toh aise isiliye nikali hogi q ki situation waisi h jab wo dollyke sath hota h chintoo tab wo awaj waise nhi nikalte jab wo humse bat karte h like pehle episode me ya fri ke episode me wo bilkul normal bat karte h. shayad uss situation me unko waise awaj nikalneko kaha gya hoga...

dolly aur lolly ke bareme toh bathi nhi karni mereko... har situation me over acting aur mujhe sachhi bolti hu dolly ke costume bhi pasand nhi aaye pata nhi q par nahi aaye... director ne in sab batonka khayal rakhna chahiye...hopes so koi sudhar aa jaye..
nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: designersaini

agree with u di...Sarabhai v/s Sarabhai was an epic comedy show...its each n every min was worth watching...n its still one f my fav...in Aggj everyone should keep a check on their scenes while enacting all d scenes looks like a overdose of overacting...even Sumit bhi apni awaaj kitna dabakar nikalta hai n im not liking dat...aur gharwalo ki to baat hi mat karo...dat dolly is serial ki bahu ka overdose...n kaunsi bahu aisi acting karti hai...she is like all d time itraing...n dolli's papa pata nahi har waqt kuch bhulte rehte hain n her mother is always 'aapse kuch nahi hoga'..
I know its all upon director but he should really check d other comedy shows like S v/s S...no overdose f comedy...it had sensible comedy


yupeee e e e

seema same pinch for sarabhai. I watched it on net after HD ends. best show. even better that HD. but HD is my favourite
I am told that overacting is channels demand actors r helpless .the PH thinks that overacting creates comedy .😆 😆 😆
BTW todays episode was good. some improvement .
but doosaronse khana banake lena is repetition

nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Ranjinikishan


@red: not all seema..u should say rest of the star cast specially dolly & lolly..they are killing the show with their weird expressions & over acting.

@blue: mere kayal se acc. to situation sumit voice change kiya hai purposely aur ye zaroori bi hai..kyu ki naani ko yakeen dilanata chintoo ko..dabakar bolanese yakin aa jata hai? 😆 uskeliye to confidencese bat karni padati hai . 😉so nothing wrong in it

about dolly completely agreed..she will ruin the show with her over acting if director dont control




designersaini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: nutan7



yupeee e e e

seema same pinch for sarabhai. I watched it on net after HD ends. best show. even better that HD. but HD is my favourite
I am told that overacting is channels demand actors r helpless .the PH thinks that overacting creates comedy .😆😆😆
BTW todays episode was good. some improvement .
but doosaronse khana banake lena is repetition

yup di...HD to my fav too..
Overacting se but comedy achchi nahi hoti dis direction should learn
waise me too loved 2day's epi...first 5 se aaj ka bst tha...n start hi mast hua aaj to
Ranjinikishan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

haa aata hai yakeen..when he presses the imp. words naturally naani par kuch asar padtahai..mere kayaal se iss show mei end tak ye sab chalti rahegi..confidence itna jaldi kaha aata hai..naani end tak shak karte rahegi aur chintoo jhoot bolte rahega aur jugadu karte rahega..kahani aakir ye dono ka beech mei hai😉
nutan7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: designersaini

agree with u di...Sarabhai v/s Sarabhai was an epic comedy show...its each n every min was worth watching...n its still one f my fav...in Aggj everyone should keep a check on their scenes while enacting all d scenes looks like a overdose of overacting...even Sumit bhi apni awaaj kitna dabakar nikalta hai n im not liking dat...aur gharwalo ki to baat hi mat karo...dat dolly is serial ki bahu ka overdose...n kaunsi bahu aisi acting karti hai...she is like all d time itraing...n dolli's papa pata nahi har waqt kuch bhulte rehte hain n her mother is always 'aapse kuch nahi hoga'..
I know its all upon director but he should really check d other comedy shows like S v/s S...no overdose f comedy...it had sensible comedy

yupee same here 1.Sarabhai is my favourite .
2. Sometime Sumit aawaj dabakar nikata hai some time i smell papy kaur in his voice and speak very loudly. no necessity to cry

any way his appearance is enjoyable. I am happy with his return . many time he is gud . original sumit .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".