Critics Corner

Musical Reality Shows this week : Critical Analysis ( Sept 28-30)

This week's musical shows were two ends of the musical spectrum. While one was a reflection of what true music is all about, the other continued it's trend of sending out mixed signals to the audience.

2007-10-03T17:39:00Z
SRGMP, after a long time, presented an outstanding extravaganza of music and singing, blending into a near perfect show. Devoid of any drama, it was a tribute to the geniuses who have given so much to the audience over the years. Friday saw a round of gazals and semi classical, presided by two doyens of music scene, Jagjit Singh and Pt Jasraj, both of whom filled the atmosphere with awe and delight with their respective recitals . Later, the contestants not only lifted their own performance beyond the realm of ordinary, each of them giving one enthralling performance after another, but they even managed to lift the show altogether to the highest level. No enforced drama, no unbecoming antics by anyone which the show had previously been notorious for, it stood out for its purity and superlative music. The same went for the Saturday episode, which though was more of a promotion for Farah Khan and Shahrukh Khan’s upcoming film Om Shanti Om, but that did not take away anything from the extraordinary musical evening.
If anything, the energy radiated by the effervescent Farah Khan and the stellar performances by the top three only added to the brilliance of this episode.
This week SRGMP saw the elimination of the powerhouse talent Poonam, but at this stage, with each contestant capable of beating the other on his/her day, it was accepted with the humility it deserved by everyone. The race has heated up, and probably after a long time in any reality show, the finals are going to be fought by contestants who deserve to be there in all respects.
Amul Star Voice of India, on the other hand, continues with it’s confusing antics. The Wild card is over, the confusion as to how many and what way is not. The audience started with knowing four to be selected, four became five ( veto power of the judges? Please!) and then it finally came to six. Even more alarming was the way the esteemed mentors were reacting.
Abhijit’s outburst at this stage, about a Prithvi contestant not being deserving enough to be in the Bemisaal 12, let alone top 5, ( suspiciously pointing at Ishmeet who cried heartbreakingly even after being declared safe, ) was not only humiliating and rude to say the least, but also indicative to the immense dissatisfaction plaguing this reality show. All the contestants, without exception, have a perpetual bewildered look on their faces – probably wondering why they are where they are in the first place. The final selection of the Wild Card entries is supposed to be a 50-50 decision, yet none of the judges were seen giving any marks to any of the WC contestants ! So is it that the marks given by other four judges in the first Wild Card round would be taken into account? Or would the current panel of judges give the marks later? Talk about confusion compounded!
This show has every ingredient to make it a successful one - eye catching sets, a warm host, brilliant contestants, at least 10 of whom can beat anyone on their day, and some great singing. Yet the show is plunging down, both in esteem and the TRP with each passing day, all thanks to a baffling elimination process where the voting pattern does not even reflect the sentiment of the masses, and the ensuing format, or rather, the lack of it. Even the presence of the brilliant trio Shankar-Eshaan-Lloyd on Friday or the Saawariya team on Saturday did little to brighten the strangely gloomy atmosphere, though the scintillating performances by young Ranbir and Sonam did lift the spirits. The performance of all the participants was another highlight of the show. What is notable here is the team spirit showed by them. Every now and then they have set aside their inevitable rivalry, and performed background vocals for each other ( watch out for the outstanding background vocals by Abhaas, Priyani and Harshit in Arshpreet’s Aa-ja-ve-mahi). The camadiere showed by them is worth a watch in itself.

Will the reentry of two (or is it three now? Confusion confusion!) through wild card save this reality show or help it’s way up the charts once more? With SRGMP finale round the corner and Indian Idol already over, Star Voice of India still can fancy some chances, provided it immediately finds ways to iron away the multiple lines of confusion and give the audience what it really tunes in to watch – good music.

Author: Minnie Gupta
Note: The views expressed are solely of the author. For any information, please contact the author.

Previous Next

24 Likes

Shah Rukh Khan Farah Khan Jagjit Singh Shankar Sonam


Comments (14)

View all
urber
urber 2007-10-04T07:53:26Z SRGMP rocks.. can't wait for the grand finale!!
me2kool
me2kool 2007-10-04T06:04:10Z srgn rox........n raja is rajaaaaaa!!!...dard e discoooooooooooooooo!!!!
Mistyy
Mistyy 2007-10-03T20:08:28Z So true..SRGMP rocks..it is the best!! hopefully..we will see more and more amazing performances in days to come!
Tani91
Tani91 2007-10-03T17:37:42Z totally agreed ..SRGMP was so awesome on both days.heopfuly they continue it and have no more drama
Rinkalp90
Rinkalp90 2007-10-03T16:14:57Z last week SRGMP was mindblowing... hopefully we will see more amazing perfermances in next two weeks.
Herman_4u
Herman_4u 2007-10-03T15:53:19Z voi isn't well organized show, i felt that since the beginning. thank god ,ppl finally realized it.
paulnarula
paulnarula 2007-10-03T13:24:53Z You are righ on target with your observations. Friday's srgmp was fabulous and SVOI continues to confuse despite having excellent singers. The wild card was peculiar. the different judges picked 4 of 7, regular judges added a 5th so we had another selection round of 5 of the 7 plus Sumitra (who did not sing), with public voting. Does not make a lot of sense.
kubare
kubare 2007-10-03T12:17:48Z SVOI is really a pain..instead of concentratriog on singing..it drama all the way....adn if that wasn't enough ...we now have the wild card entry...after those contestants were voted out by the public themsleves...now the same public wants them back...odd...

The only worth whiel watching show is SRGMP....it truly has the best talent in the world as singers for sure....and the are more talented then all the Indian Idol and SVOI contestants put togehter....

Hats off to SRGMP....
Bhaskar.T
Bhaskar.T 2007-10-03T11:18:04Z SRGMP Friday episode was the best in any of the reality shows of this season. It showed what a good musical show should be.

SVOI.... nothing to say. A show that has NO format, NO logic, NO rules. The producer can do anything any moment and you'll find the show taking a new course. Till date no reality show has been more frustrating and irritating as SVOI. The only Yes it has is the quality singers.

Rest everything... just disgusting!!!
Anuradha
Anuradha 2007-10-03T11:03:33Z On what aspects are you comparing these shows?? Forget about singing, judgment - What is needed for any show or serial is the format.. Could you please tell me what is the format of SVOI? Because till now I have never understood!! I would appreciate if you can explain most of the format as we are still in confused state!!

Thank You!!
see more
TOP