Was it an ufair desicion? - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

95

Views

8.8k

Users

60

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

Who-I-Used-2-Be thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: sonali.19281

hormones huh???😆didnt quite think it;ll boil down to this...well i dont really have to hots for bakhtiyar as a man..but his dancing definitely made my hormones jump...kiddin...you are right everyone is entitled to their opinion..i am not denouncing all the ppl who think the judgement was fair...why should they do it to us..quite a shame...my poor hormones were looking for chaitanya on the dance floor tho'😆lol

Ha ha ha..Your reply is gold..Loved the humor..
I too don't find Bakhtyar 'hawt' and all but that guy can work wonders with his dancing skills..As far is Chaitanya is concerned, he is my personal favorite in the boys' team and like you , I too was looking for him on the dance floor and missed his presence and watching him dance in the finale..But certainly those are not the reasons why I found the decision unfair..:-) That's a totally different thing..

Originally posted by: nkapoor

they weren't unfair, these people know their job, these people aren't sum biased idiots!

You think they weren't unfair while I believe they were quite unfair..Each to his own..Fair enough? 😊 While I don't think Malaika and Saroj ji are idiots, ( can't say the same about Chunky though..;-) ) they did come across as biased against Bakhtyar that particular day..
Edited by simplyvivacious - 17 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#72

Originally posted by: simplyvivacious

You think they weren't unfair while I believe they were quite unfair..Each to his own..Fair enough? 😊 While I don't think Malaika and Saroj ji are idiots, ( can't say the same about Chunky though..;-) )🤣they did come across as biased against Bakhtyar that particular day..



I haven't watched it still....but going by all I've seen in the posts so far...I'll say this much....the decision may not have been fair....as it appears now that it wasn't...but still the boys shouldn't have walked out....they just undermined their overall dignity with that....so that even if they did indeed deserve to win, now no one will grant them even a moral victory, given the way things ended....hmmm, I guess emotions sure were running high in the finale....
Neelu.RoX thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#73
Okay, Lets just give it up, The girls WON! And they showed, they deserved it!! They were smart with their points and played it safe! And they had very good dancers! And they acted dignified and as a team, the boys cant even do that.

And for People who support the boys, the only justified reason that you guys can claim is that the "Judges were Biased" !! Justify it with another reason why the boys should of won, then I'll believe you..
Edited by Neelu.RoX - 17 years ago
ammmu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#74
Hmmm... I've never posted in this forum, but I've been following ZND since the first episode, and I wanted to just post my views here..
Two main things that I just felt were... hmmm. I felt Bakhtiyaar should have won in the 1st and 4th round. Not because I'm deeming him as the 'Best Dancer' or something, but I truly felt he deserved to win.. the 1st Round was a close call, but I thought it was pretty clear that he was better than Ashita for me in the 4th round. I dunno... Ashita's expressions are always the same, it's that same smile and she some of her steps seemed fumbled to me. I like Ashita very much, but I'm just comparing the two of them in terms of dance. Did their walking out justify anything? Considering they had a small child, Amey on their team, plus it was the Grand Finale, Chaitanya wasnt there either (which, by the way, I was feeling so bad about... really wanted Chaitanya to be there!), then of course, no way... their behaviour in the Jhoom Barabar Jhoom round was just inexcusable and I felt so horrible for Amey right then... he did his dance and was the most mature. But I did feel that not all of the judgements were very fair. What has happened has happened now, and one can't dwell on the past too much, but that's just how I felt... undoubtedly, both teams did really well, but that's how I feel about the Finale. I'm sure the Boys will be feeling bad about what they did, but I did understand what Gaurav said, and appreciated him for being fully honest. Though the 'no motivation' part didnt make much sense to me, but what he said before, about him not knowing if what they were feeling was mature or right, I felt that was really honest and a good thing... but anyways... congratulations to the Girls and all the best to all for the future! 😊
Additi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#75
im soo glad that the girls won..
thats all i have wanted...really..
buh i didnt want them to win THIS way...
like u guys get wat i mean?
AnuPurva thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#76

Originally posted by: shubangiatrerox

all u saying boys dint get motivation thatsy dey did this
i bet if boys beated fairly dey must create drama i observed them so unsporty
dey hav ego poblem ayaaaar

I did not feel that boys had ego problem... The judgement was not fair at all. In the first round we all know that Bakktiyaar was much better than karishma. But they gave wrong judgement. What Ali did, was absolutely right. He was knowing they will win 300 pts. But due to wrong judgement they lost 300 pts. Later they did not had much option to bet higher... 2nd round girls were better. In 4th round Bakhtiyar was again better, we all should consider that he was replacing for Chaitanya who was badly sick.. He put so much energy in the dance... I dont say about wining of girls. They deserves but how boys got treated badly by judges, was something un tolarable.. They dont have any rights to say such bad words to boys..
What boys did, was very less. They could have shown more worse than that. But they were quite..
I think it was most desent way to protest... I feel the battle was between judge (sp Maliaka and then other two) and boys.. Girls were good but boys should have not treated like this.. Thats all...
Edited by purva_j - 17 years ago
Additi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#77
am i the only one who cant read comments???
RagMasta thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

Hi friends....i hv always been a silent member but today i just cudnt resist myself from voicing my opinion. this is entirely my personal opinion and i dont mean to offend anyone.

i hv followed the show from the very first episode and have not missed a single episode.
i always felt boys were fab in terms of concept and in most cases dances too. bakhtiyar is no doubt the best among boys and even overall he is one of the best along with mouni and ishita.
in the mega final....both girls and boys proved to be innovative. both the teams brought a uniqueness to the show...and the final episode was seeming to be a perfect ending to a wonderful dance show like zara nachke dikha.
i am not a very gud judge of dancing....but even then some things were clear to me. in the shadow dance the girls were without any doubt better than boys.
in the face off round i felt bakhtiyar was really really gud and it was one of his best performance but somehow i felt ishita had an edge over him and i felt that she wud win. only in the tashan round i was not sure whether karishma deservered to win or not although she was not bad at all.
the main problem was with the boys. they were not playing according to any strategy. they were overconfident and smug. they as saroj khan said was onlly depending upon bakhtiyar. he is best no doubt but that day girls were better than him.
who told the boys to bet 300 points in every other round. obviously wen they lost 300 in the very first round it was quite a blow for them which is very natural but they themselves r to blame for it.
in simple words i can say that it was not bakhtiyar's day, and it was wrong decision by the team to depend on just one person.
and what they did in the final round was totally wrong. in a competition one has to lose and every team shud learn to accept defeat gracefully. every competitor believes that he has given his best but maybe the opponent team was better and one shud learn to accept that.
the boys did not hv the right to spoil the effort of everyone including the girls, boys themselves and judges that was put in the last 3 months.
malaika, saroj khan and chunky noone has any personal enmity with boys, maybe in their eyes girls were better and they judged accordingly.
i think if boys played to strategy they had a chance of winning.
betting 300, 160, 250 points was just stupid thing to do. as if even before the performances the boys had alrealy decided that the girls wont be able to beat bakhtiyar. in a competition the very first thing every team shud keep in mind that they must NEVER underestimate the opponent team.
also i think at the very beginning boys made a major mistake. they won the toss and then gave the girls to dance first. as a result the judges were getting the impression the boys were repeating the dance steps which was very obvious in the shadow dance.
it had a psychological effect on the judges and so i felt the wise decision wud hv been the boys to dance first.
anyway, at the end of the day i must say that boys must learn to accept defeat and shud not decide in advance that girls can never win over them.

well said...i completly agree with u😊
MimiLulu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#79
I don't think Bakthyar was better then Karishma in the Tashan round. Karishma was EQUALLY as good as him. Bakthyar is a good dancer but he is very heavy on his feet. Look, I took Ballet for like a year and first thing they make you notice when you start dancing is how NOT to be heavy on your feet cause that just ruins the whole dance. You have to be very light when you dance and Bakthyar doesn't do that.

I think it was a very fair decision. The girls were always much better then the boys in every round except JBJs which was the boys forte, no doubt. All through the game, all the boys did was experiment and that too in mostly western songs. And please dont tell me the girls did only Indian......Ballet is not Indian, the Nach song was not Indian, Mouni's bollywood Item number or wedding song was not Indian, and I can put a bazillion other examples.

For the Finale, the girls played fairly, used their intelligence, were a TEAM, and gave excellent performances.

Zara Hatke Round without a doubt the girls were better and go watch the Face-Off Round again. Look at Ashita's engery level, her expressions, her grace, her elegence, her STEPS and then come comment on who was better. Stop with all the judges being biased. Just because you dont agree with them don't make them bias. There were many times, the girls deserved to win but they didn't yet they never complained. The most recent was Karishma and Ashita's breathless dance against Baktyar and Chaitanya's table dance which was a STRAIGHT copy from NB4. Yet the boys won, the girls didn't agree with the decision but they never complained. The boys, whenever they lost, complained.

Better example, Mouni Vs. Chaitanya. Mouni performs flawlessly, Malika says she thinks its the best performance so far....instead of getting more motivated to do even better, the Chaitanya performs and then says how his motivation level went down because of Malika's comment? Shouldn't he be more motivated to do better??? Nope. That has always been the case with the boys.


I started watching this show supporting the boys but after three weeks, I couldn't help but support the girls. Their performances were always GREAT, their team spirit was always fantastic, they were always more intelligent in decision making, and not to mention, they didn't cause any drama which is quite surprising cause girls are known to cause drama.


The girls won fair and square. If you don't agree with that, too bad. No matter of how much venting you do wont change the fact that the girls are probably enjoying themselves in Egypt at the moment.
Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: aditi123_78

Hi friends....i hv always been a silent member but today i just cudnt resist myself from voicing my opinion. this is entirely my personal opinion and i dont mean to offend anyone.

i hv followed the show from the very first episode and have not missed a single episode.
i always felt boys were fab in terms of concept and in most cases dances too. bakhtiyar is no doubt the best among boys and even overall he is one of the best along with mouni and ishita.
in the mega final....both girls and boys proved to be innovative. both the teams brought a uniqueness to the show...and the final episode was seeming to be a perfect ending to a wonderful dance show like zara nachke dikha.
i am not a very gud judge of dancing....but even then some things were clear to me. in the shadow dance the girls were without any doubt better than boys.
in the face off round i felt bakhtiyar was really really gud and it was one of his best performance but somehow i felt ishita had an edge over him and i felt that she wud win. only in the tashan round i was not sure whether karishma deservered to win or not although she was not bad at all.
the main problem was with the boys. they were not playing according to any strategy. they were overconfident and smug. they as saroj khan said was onlly depending upon bakhtiyar. he is best no doubt but that day girls were better than him.
who told the boys to bet 300 points in every other round. obviously wen they lost 300 in the very first round it was quite a blow for them which is very natural but they themselves r to blame for it.
in simple words i can say that it was not bakhtiyar's day, and it was wrong decision by the team to depend on just one person.
and what they did in the final round was totally wrong. in a competition one has to lose and every team shud learn to accept defeat gracefully. every competitor believes that he has given his best but maybe the opponent team was better and one shud learn to accept that.
the boys did not hv the right to spoil the effort of everyone including the girls, boys themselves and judges that was put in the last 3 months.
malaika, saroj khan and chunky noone has any personal enmity with boys, maybe in their eyes girls were better and they judged accordingly.
i think if boys played to strategy they had a chance of winning.
betting 300, 160, 250 points was just stupid thing to do. as if even before the performances the boys had alrealy decided that the girls wont be able to beat bakhtiyar. in a competition the very first thing every team shud keep in mind that they must NEVER underestimate the opponent team.
also i think at the very beginning boys made a major mistake. they won the toss and then gave the girls to dance first. as a result the judges were getting the impression the boys were repeating the dance steps which was very obvious in the shadow dance.
it had a psychological effect on the judges and so i felt the wise decision wud hv been the boys to dance first.
anyway, at the end of the day i must say that boys must learn to accept defeat and shud not decide in advance that girls can never win over them.



I agree with each and every letter in your post!!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".