One mistake ruined everything…

What if ManiShahi Gooenka didn’t kick out Akshara that day?

What if he investigated Aarohi’s accident like a CID?

What if he had belief ki Meri Akshu Kabhi Galat Nahi Ho Sakti and tried to prove her innocence?

Had this ghatiya buddha not been so heartless that day and used his brains then Akshara, Abhir and Abhimanyu would’ve still been alive.

Abhimanyu would’ve helped Akshara to prove her innocence to Roohi and Goenka’s. Akshara would’ve cared for Roohi like a mother. Abhira would’ve grown to be a prosperous girl with a large family (as she always wished) Abhira, Abhir and Roohi would’ve been loving siblings. Abhira wouldn’t have been stalked by that creepy Yuvraj nor would’ve Akshara died and forced her to marry Armaan. Abhira would’ve never married into that pagal Poddar parivaar (or maybe she still would’ve had an arranged marriage to Armaan like Roohi did following the Gen 1 plot like they were supposed to.

In other words, do kaudi ka ghatiya Buddha ManiShahi is solely to blame for the destruction of his own family. Hope he rots in the deepest pits of hell for ruining the lives of his grandchildren! Scumbag!

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

What if ManiShahi Gooenka didn’t kick out Akshara that day?

What if he investigated Aarohi’s accident like a CID?

What if he had belief ki Meri Akshu Kabhi Galat Nahi Ho Sakti and tried to prove her innocence?

Had this ghatiya buddha not been so heartless that day and used his brains then Akshara, Abhir and Abhimanyu would’ve still been alive.

Abhimanyu would’ve helped Akshara to prove her innocence to Roohi and Goenka’s. Akshara would’ve cared for Roohi like a mother. Abhira would’ve grown to be a prosperous girl with a large family (as she always wished) Abhira, Abhir and Roohi would’ve been loving siblings. Abhira wouldn’t have been stalked by that creepy Yuvraj nor would’ve Akshara died and forced her to marry Armaan. Abhira would’ve never married into that pagal Poddar parivaar (or maybe she still would’ve had an arranged marriage to Armaan like Roohi did following the Gen 1 plot like they were supposed to.

In other words, do kaudi ka ghatiya Buddha ManiShahi is solely to blame for the destruction of his own family. Hope he rots in the deepest pits of hell for ruining the lives of his grandchildren! Scumbag!

Ruhi was so adamant for Akshu to b away….. y did Manyu not talk to ruhi? Y did he just leave ruhi…. How could he just. Leave her….in that state?? …His ruh… his princess… etc etc.., 😃

I mean arohi ki death must have shaken the goenkas…. But Manyu to samjha sakta tha…. And when he is credited to have skills to sanjhyofy ruhi😃😃

Waise bhi… his leaving ruhi in that state was a very selfish decision of his…. But again that’s what Manyu has been!!

And y would Akshu need him to prove her innocence??

I defo don’t support goenkas… they have been shown as pathetic parents/ parent figures….. 😃 they should end in guilt with abhira not forgiving them!!

Originally posted by: India_TV

Ruhi was so adamant for Akshu to b away….. y did Manyu not talk to ruhi? Y did he just leave ruhi…. How could he just. Leave her….in that state?? …His ruh… his princess… etc etc.., 😃

I mean arohi ki death must have shaken the goenkas…. But Manyu to samjha sakta tha…. And when he is credited to have skills to sanjhyofy ruhi😃😃

Waise bhi… his leaving ruhi in that state was a very selfish decision of his…. But again that’s what Manyu has been!!

And y would Akshu need him to prove her innocence??

I defo don’t support goenkas… they have been shown as pathetic parents/ parent figures….. 😃 they should end in guilt with abhira not forgiving them!!

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

Yes, he should not have left Roohi with those toxic Goenka’s who are the sole reason what she is today. He should’ve convinced her that Akshara wasn’t at fault as he knew the truth. If he wanted to live with Akshara then he should’ve taken Roohi with him and raised her also alongside Abhir and Abhira. I know Gooenka’s are immortal but it is unsafe to leave a young girl with elderly great grandparents who can conk off anytime. The so called ‘elders’ should’ve been the ones to raise this point.

He defo wanted to live with Akshu…. Maaaaaa ko bhi chod diya usne to😃😃

but how could he take ruhi along…. Ruhi ko samjha deta na…. Tab jaana hi nahi padta….😃😃 but he chose to not even tell ruhi…. And did not bother to contact her later…. And used to b like…. Meri ruh…. Meri princess…. 😃😃😃 Manish dhongi hai… to Manyu guru nikla Iss mein bhin😃😃…

goenkas never cared for Akshu… that was established at the start of the gen 3…

The main mistake was arohi being careless and giving the bag with car keys to a ziddi ruhi…. Jisne subah se drive karne ko zidd ki Hui thi….

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

What if ManiShahi Gooenka didn’t kick out Akshara that day?

What if he investigated Aarohi’s accident like a CID?

What if he had belief ki Meri Akshu Kabhi Galat Nahi Ho Sakti and tried to prove her innocence?

Had this ghatiya buddha not been so heartless that day and used his brains then Akshara, Abhir and Abhimanyu would’ve still been alive.

Abhimanyu would’ve helped Akshara to prove her innocence to Roohi and Goenka’s. Akshara would’ve cared for Roohi like a mother. Abhira would’ve grown to be a prosperous girl with a large family (as she always wished) Abhira, Abhir and Roohi would’ve been loving siblings. Abhira wouldn’t have been stalked by that creepy Yuvraj nor would’ve Akshara died and forced her to marry Armaan. Abhira would’ve never married into that pagal Poddar parivaar (or maybe she still would’ve had an arranged marriage to Armaan like Roohi did following the Gen 1 plot like they were supposed to.

In other words, do kaudi ka ghatiya Buddha ManiShahi is solely to blame for the destruction of his own family. Hope he rots in the deepest pits of hell for ruining the lives of his grandchildren! Scumbag!

The thing is when Akshu took the blame, I don't think she anticipated the hatred and silence from her own family when she had just lost her husband and was pregnant with another child! She didn't trust her family to spare Ruhi the heartbreak and accusation because she herself had faced the same! And they just ousted her, made her feel unwanted! They never cared to enquire about Abhir, Abhimanyu, Akshu and the other child!

Even today Manish and gang were not present when Abhira came back home after such a difficult time! Be with Ruhi but can't you be present during Abhira's welcoming ceremony? And you preach about treating both of them the same way?

They do everything to enable Ruhi and validate her wrong feelings! Abhira never demanded anything even though she was deprived of everything! They are even hiding truth of Abhir and Abhimanyu! How heartless can they be?

Akshara never wanted to take care of baby ruhi tabhi she accepted her crime warna she would have thought about ruhi before doing this mahan act.Ruhi believed her masi that she never killed her until she heard Akshara accepting her crime to how is ruhi wrong but Akshara right ? By doing this n abandoning ruhi she gave trauma to her for life long..Also Abheera not living with whole family isn't ruhi fault but Akshara only since she did stupidity n it was her own decision to do so as no-one asked her..

Originally posted by: Ajab.Pehchan

What if ManiShahi Gooenka didn’t kick out Akshara that day?

What if he investigated Aarohi’s accident like a CID?

What if he had belief ki Meri Akshu Kabhi Galat Nahi Ho Sakti and tried to prove her innocence?

Had this ghatiya buddha not been so heartless that day and used his brains then Akshara, Abhir and Abhimanyu would’ve still been alive.

Abhimanyu would’ve helped Akshara to prove her innocence to Roohi and Goenka’s. Akshara would’ve cared for Roohi like a mother. Abhira would’ve grown to be a prosperous girl with a large family (as she always wished) Abhira, Abhir and Roohi would’ve been loving siblings. Abhira wouldn’t have been stalked by that creepy Yuvraj nor would’ve Akshara died and forced her to marry Armaan. Abhira would’ve never married into that pagal Poddar parivaar (or maybe she still would’ve had an arranged marriage to Armaan like Roohi did following the Gen 1 plot like they were supposed to.

In other words, do kaudi ka ghatiya Buddha ManiShahi is solely to blame for the destruction of his own family. Hope he rots in the deepest pits of hell for ruining the lives of his grandchildren! Scumbag!

Ok first I am going to be pragmatic - Because HC didn’t extend his contract and channel or production house killed off JS’s ckt, hence closing the door for gen 3, so they showed all this crap to lay base for gen4 story.

Now moving on to what if land.

Keeping fossil man aside, I think they should have killed off Arohi and Abhimanyu’s ckt probably while they were saving Akshara or Abhinav showing Abhimanyu’s unrequited love and dedication for Akshara and how Arohi had also become a meri pyari behena ckt. After that Akshara and Abhinav raise Abhir, Ruhi and Abheera ( waise who is named after Abhimanyu 😀). Ruhi could still be estranged with Akshara because Arohi and Abhimanyu died saving her. But she could have been close to Abhinav thus getting atleast one good loving relation in her childhood. They could have built a similar story thereafter with Ruhi and Armaan falling in love initially but Abheera is married off to Armaan and Ruhi to Rohit. Same deal marriage, Rohit running away, Ruhi pinning for Armaan in light of farzi marriage with Abheera. But the base would have been a little palatable and happyish. Abhir would be alive (killing him was a morbid move 🙁😡) kids would have a decent-ish childhood, there would be some sibling bonding with generous helping of rivalry, kind of love/hate relationship between Ruhi and Abheera rather than what they showed currently.

In my opinion, the whole purpose of this was to show AK Abhimanyu and Abhir lived separately from other two family. But somehow their marriage never happened hence AK remained Abhinav’s wife and not Abhimanyu

If only, Abhimanyu and Abhir died like a day, month or year later then she would be Abhimanyu’s wife and Abhira’s step dad. Then she definitely can’t hide these facts from her even if she wants to

People love to talk about Gen 3 - Very soon mods are gonna regret their decision of allowing the discussion for that Generation