My two cents - Page 8

Originally posted by: Silveraliax

Disclaimer: I am not saying Abhi was right to tell Akshara to leave.

Can I just say one thing. Yes, show needs drama and trps but why do they keep handling sensitive topics such as, hit and run case, domestic violence, depressions, trauma etc, so poorly?

For example, I think the makers are trying to bring a karma type situation for Abhi and Harsh.

People are even comparing Abhi to Harsh? But what Abhi faced was child abuse and what happened on the funeral day, was a separation because of muitlpe deaths in family.

As a child, Abhi saw Harsh physically abuse his mum, later found out that he had an extra marital affair and had another child, treated people with non medical qualifications (like Manajri and Akshara) less favourably as opposed to people with medical qualifications (like Mahima and Arohi) and also treated his step brother like garbage.

Abhir will find out that Abhi left his mum (cannot add his mum and him because you cannot leave dead twins). Yes, it's not a small thing and Abhir should be mad at Abhi but no way is it comparable to child abuse that was done out of disrespect for the other gender and their status as a housewife.

If makers want Abhi to feel bad for standing agaisnt the father who committed child abuse and domestic violence then what can I say...

A lot of us are saying that they will equate harsh and abhis situation but the viewers are far more intelligent, sensitive and imaginative than the actual creators. I can bet that the makers have forgotten about harsh all together. Vinay Jain is not in YRKKH so they are not even thinking of a parallel situation for sure. If it does come up it’s because they go through these forums for ideas. Sometimes I wish they would do that more since people on here have better and more logical story lines as compared to the actual creatives

Originally posted by: DevilHere

I don't think AkshNav is endgame simply coz HC is a well accepted lead...so unless he wants to leave the show or the TRP is literally in the pit they'll not change the lead pair.

If as people point out since the RS iv that they've changed the couple coz TRP tanked pre leap and AkshNav r endgame HC will bid adieu...Nav family will be introduced (he could very well be a long lost Birla) nd Nav butchering will start....like I said Nav will not remain AA as the main ship...wrna story kaise chlega....if AkshNav go have a happily ever after in kasauli the show ends

There is no way abhira is not end game simply because HC is a much bigger star than jai soni. Also they have a lot of offline audience that loves abhira. Abhinav was appreciated because he seemed like a source of comfort for akshara and abhimanyu needed to have a redemption arc. But there is a reason abhinav is an orphan. YRKKh leads need to have big joint families for both leads. Abhinav May but go away but he will not replace abhimanyu. If HC wants to leave, they will wrap up season 3 since there is no way js will be accepted as the main male lead. People who are liking him are also aware that he will not be in aksharas life forever

Originally posted by: DevilHere

I think I mentioned in my post that Abhi is obviously a walking red flag...nor am I saying he doesn't deserve the gaalis he gets on the forum...all i said here was ki leads hote hi h itv shows mein to be butchered....they do some nice things for each other fall in love, marry nd then starts a vicious cycle of seperation ,angst reunion..i don't have hopes for AkshNav nd while i won't like any person irl to end up with someone like AbhiM...i don't mind Abhira at all....Nav did all that for her nd is therefore hailed...but the minute he turns the lead he will be butchered too ...toh ab AK ko torture nav kre yaa AbhiM kya hi frk padta pure show mein Rona toh hai hi usko....one thing I would like to point out here is that when AbhiM took stand for ak everyone was 🤫😱... unlike nav woh lecture deta h achai ka ....samne wala usko hi do baat suna deta aur phir AK ko uske liye stand lena padta h....give credit where it's due what nav did for her was give her companionship ,care when she needed it, became her support... he's done a lot for AK nd abhir........what abhiM did was help her grow a spine stop being bullied by her sister out of guilt... helping her prioritise herself over anyone especially aroo, I have no idea how u equated AbhiM helping her with her music career and her having a Jam business nd studying law post leap those were her profession while there was a proper track which had abhiM helping her pursue her career

Abhinav will be butchered even if he is not ML if he is not going to be killed off. Looks like they are slowly moving to a abhira reunion. To do this abhinav and arohi need to be out of the way. Arohi is easy, bring out one of her many kaands or show that she tries to interfere in abhirs treatment and she will be out. The only way to get rid of abhinav is to kill him or turn him negative or combine the two, pretend he is dead and then have him come back as a negative character. That gives them another story line too

Originally posted by: DevilHere

It's ITV honestly what can I say.... it's just sad...yrkkh was actually one of the shows that had a very homely feeling....no ott vamps..just normal family having usual problems....but alas..look how they're handling the whole Biological Vs Foster parent issue....DV issue I mean parth should be forgiven coz his mother longs for him 🤦🏻‍♀️

.

IRL I won't relate to Ak even..... It's legit suicidal for two people to go fight with 10 goons that's dumb... people irl may not hand u divorce paper nd ask u to leave but u r gonna be questioned for being so stupid may even strain a lot of relationships.... It's a story nd nav turned out to be literal angel....but just running from ur fam with no money no place to stay is stupid...if she didn't want to live in udaipur needed space...she could've asked her family for the same....they would've made those arrangements...Manish did run to pathankot for her....no family irl would've accepted nav as her husband... they're literal millionaire why would they be happy to see their daughter struggling for basics... they would've atleast extended financial help..

What's with her fear abhiM she can't seperate them completely....it doesn't have to be a choice between biological vs foster both of them can be his father... they're r enough children who r closer to their step fathers....nd if she feels he's incompetent nd shouldn't be a part of abhir life...go to court get a restraining letter...

That' being said everything i said here applies to real life scenario...the ckt ak I sympathise and empathise with coz it's the demand of the story

Oh in real life, an Abhi would have left an Akshara long back when she hid about hit and run case. That was a big no no. Actually in the the first sagai itself because in real life, people rarely fight for others.

And according to others, Akshara would not have settled for a "toxic" Abhi. So real life mein this story would never have occured because it's too absurd.

Akshara not asking for help from goencas is again a plot devise and nothing else no matter how much people try to justify it. It's simply another ITV trick to make the female lead helpless so that the audience feels sorry for her as female leads bechari he ban sakti hain

I don't know why Akshara is paranoid. Abhi has never said that he will take Abhir away from her or Nav, he clearly said mera bhi beta hain and also included Nav so he clearly has no intention of break the family. And Akshara is supposed to be a law student so it doesn't make sense if she fears about custody unless she has skipped family law in her revision. Writing is the problem, it's not consistent but all over the place. One day Abhi is sorry, the other day he is only thinking about himself. One day Akshara is confident, the other day she is freaking out.

Well said both ckts r fictional nd act by the usual standard itv has for leads...nd itv has never been about good consistent writing...so as long as they can keep it interesting it works for me

Originally posted by: jhustju

A lot of us are saying that they will equate harsh and abhis situation but the viewers are far more intelligent, sensitive and imaginative than the actual creators. I can bet that the makers have forgotten about harsh all together. Vinay Jain is not in YRKKH so they are not even thinking of a parallel situation for sure. If it does come up it’s because they go through these forums for ideas. Sometimes I wish they would do that more since people on here have better and more logical story lines as compared to the actual creatives

But its highly insensitive to equate both situations together. Personally, I'd feel offended but silly of me to expect makers to care about the audience who have suffered child abuse.

Same with domestic violence issue, I feel both Manjari and Shefali's situations were handled terribly. Also, the hit and run track was abysmal.

In short, it's best not to compare shows to real life.

Originally posted by: DevilHere

That girl still doesn't show much of her newly grown spine to anyone except for abhiM(not complaining about this mujhe BDA mzza aata in his dhulai...mast ache se nichodo...phatke wagerah lgao... ekdum doodh si safedi needed)...par when it comes to any other character 90 percent of the time muh bnd hi hojata h uska...there was a part of family that disapproved but some supported her too...her husband supported her profession....ak anyways had love marriage with abhi...she married him not the family these things r seen with arrange marriages

The spine was also the day of the reveal only. Yesterday’s episode she was shit scared and it showed. Basically the lack of spine/ confidence is due to lack of support. She knows if abhi wants to take her son she will be the only one fighting for him. The birlas will of course support abhimanyu, the goenkas will also support abhimanyu since they want to see arohi happy. They do not want any connection between abhi and akshara so if abhir stays with akshara, abhi will keep meeting her. They know if it’s the other way they won’t meet that often since the birlas will not entertain akshara. Her husband is not strong enough to fight. He will stand by her but won’t be able to do much. Kairav is a wildcard, he could help akshara but he has way too much attachment and sympathy for arohi. At the end of the day it is akshara alone and abhi with all the support just like it has always been. It was even foreshadowed in last episode, when akshara and abhi both had their breakdowns

Bche koi saman nhi hote h yaar jo koi kisiko bhi Dede for convenience....she said aaj na maine taiyaari ki h studying law...agr bilkul hi serial wale bogus law ki nhi kri h toh... there's hardly any chance judge will favour abhiM in custody...also goenkas r a very disappointing family but isse thode Kam Gaye gujre h...nd if actually h ak ki nazr mein itne Gaye guzre toh kis baat ka lihaaz left right center sbki bjao..

surgery ke baad samne se thik do case

Originally posted by: DevilHere

Bche koi saman nhi hote h yaar jo koi kisiko bhi Dede for convenience....she said aaj na maine taiyaari ki h studying law...agr bilkul hi serial wale bogus law ki nhi kri h toh... there's hardly any chance judge will favour abhiM in custody...also goenkas r a very disappointing family but isse thode Kam Gaye gujre h...nd if actually h ak ki nazr mein itne Gaye guzre toh kis baat ka lihaaz left right center sbki bjao..

surgery ke baad samne se thik do case

The thing is they have made a martyr out of akshara. Self sacrificing and not really standing up for herself. She is only standing up to abhi because she is angry. She has never said anything to her family including arohi and I doubt she will in the future too. She should have shut her family up a long time back. Every time they favored arohi at her expense she should have said something, Including this time when bade papa warned her about not harming arohis future with abhi. She should have said eff you and eff your arohi. If you really think that arohis wedding is more important than my dying son then eff all of you. Give me my fathers money and I will walk away from all your lives.

The reason the custody battle will happen is because it’s the only way that akshara will let her anger towards abhi go. As unreasonable as it seems they will show that abhi is on the brink of wining sole custody and then abhi will give up his rights. There is also a very real possibility that abhi will not sue for custody. It will be manjari or some misunderstandings