Whoes Fault?

Hey everyone,

With the ongoing track the people are divided into two groups, One who supports Kartik and other who doesnt support Kartik but are against Naira's drastic step. The question I want to ask is why is Naira wrong coz she did not fight back, she left everyone and without considering about everyone else, coz Kartik has the right to know about Karirav as he is his blood, coz she always runs away as she cant face questions,

Not justifying that she did not thought about others, what would had happened if she told everyone what Kartik asked her, dadi would have told the same thing rather her thinking about woman working out and making career would had got more stronger, and what punishment would they give, what would had happened if Naira actually told that she is pregnant, what was the guarantee their would not be doubts in anyone's mind,

Naira ran away coz she dint wanted her child to face humiliation, dint wanted anyone to have doubts, is their any guarantee that Goenka's would have not asked for DNA, when Dadi and Manish could go for sex determination the could have gone for DNA, It was not just Naira a wife who had face it a mother too, Alas Naira did come back when she heard only communication of Kartik and Mihir, thereto Kartik did not apologize to Mihir rather he shouted at Mihir where Mihir wasnt even at fault,

the fact is Kartik is playing Victim is not right very conveniently he said i am at fault but Naira at a bigger fault but the fact is its coz of Kartik Naira did so, she was only wrong not to think of rest of her family...

Exactly my point... If Kartik could ask Naira such disgusting question I'm 100% sure he would have doubts about Nairas child now he has a connection with Kairav and mihir has also put forward the truth so he is accepting Kairav without a doubt. The only reason he was guilty of asking such degrading question was because Naira was dead and plz dont justify that it was a second of doubt in his mind he has been jealous insecure and snapping at Naira since she starting working so much for understanding and supportive husband. Let's not even go to the Goenkas they are the reason Kaira separate one way or another and Dadi will be the 1st one to flame Kartiks doubts and Singhanyas have they ever been there for Naira cuz I for one don't remember hell I've see them shower more affection on Vedika in these few weeks than they did on Naira in the 3 years. Their daughter gets insulted thrown out of the house in front of them did a single one of them bat an eyelash so I can connect with their so called love and heart ache. And Kartik during Akshara accident anyone one would have thought he did we as an viewer also thought he did he was drunk doesn't remember anything so Naira accusing him was not unrealistic but still at the end Naira had to follow him like a puppy and apologise and then hiding Mansis truth Naira had all the right to angry but again at the end Naira had to apologise every single time it's Naira who is wrong and Kartik becomes victim even when he took away the her only chance to see her dead child. I'm sorry I'm sick of Kartik becoming the victim all the bloody time and Naira has become so pathetic after falling in love with Kartik. I liked her better when she didn't give Kartik any importance.

Originally posted by: manisha11

Hey everyone,

With the ongoing track the people are divided into two groups, One who supports Kartik and other who doesnt support Kartik but are against Naira's drastic step. The question I want to ask is why is Naira wrong coz she did not fight back, she left everyone and without considering about everyone else, coz Kartik has the right to know about Karirav as he is his blood, coz she always runs away as she cant face questions,

Not justifying that she did not thought about others, what would had happened if she told everyone what Kartik asked her, dadi would have told the same thing rather her thinking about woman working out and making career would had got more stronger, and what punishment would they give, what would had happened if Naira actually told that she is pregnant, what was the guarantee their would not be doubts in anyone's mind,

Naira ran away coz she dint wanted her child to face humiliation, dint wanted anyone to have doubts, is their any guarantee that Goenka's would have not asked for DNA, when Dadi and Manish could go for sex determination the could have gone for DNA, It was not just Naira a wife who had face it a mother too, Alas Naira did come back when she heard only communication of Kartik and Mihir, thereto Kartik did not apologize to Mihir rather he shouted at Mihir where Mihir wasnt even at fault,

the fact is Kartik is playing Victim is not right very conveniently he said i am at fault but Naira at a bigger fault but the fact is its coz of Kartik Naira did so, she was only wrong not to think of rest of her family...

True... Even I didn't like the way he said that.....

Originally posted by: shahz

Exactly my point... If Kartik could ask Naira such disgusting question I'm 100% sure he would have doubts about Nairas child now he has a connection with Kairav and mihir has also put forward the truth so he is accepting Kairav without a doubt. The only reason he was guilty of asking such degrading question was because Naira was dead and plz dont justify that it was a second of doubt in his mind he has been jealous insecure and snapping at Naira since she starting working so much for understanding and supportive husband. Let's not even go to the Goenkas they are the reason Kaira separate one way or another and Dadi will be the 1st one to flame Kartiks doubts and Singhanyas have they ever been there for Naira cuz I for one don't remember hell I've see them shower more affection on Vedika in these few weeks than they did on Naira in the 3 years. Their daughter gets insulted thrown out of the house in front of them did a single one of them bat an eyelash so I can connect with their so called love and heart ache. And Kartik during Akshara accident anyone one would have thought he did we as an viewer also thought he did he was drunk doesn't remember anything so Naira accusing him was not unrealistic but still at the end Naira had to follow him like a puppy and apologise and then hiding Mansis truth Naira had all the right to angry but again at the end Naira had to apologise every single time it's Naira who is wrong and Kartik becomes victim even when he took away the her only chance to see her dead child. I'm sorry I'm sick of Kartik becoming the victim all the bloody time and Naira has become so pathetic after falling in love with Kartik. I liked her better when she didn't give Kartik any importance.

Woah, I feel the same way. I am so done with Naira apologising to Kartik for everything whether it's her fault or not.

And in today's episode, when dadi said "you should have come to me", I literally was laughing out loud. She was the one to flame Kartik's insecurities in the beginning. And more than taking Naira's side, I can totally imagine Dadi for being the one to ask for a DNA test for the child or trying to get it down without Kaira knowing just like you said.

The only problem I have with Naira is she ran away letting everyone think she died. She could have gone back to her house and be strong and refuse to engage with Kartik no matter what. She could have just told him that she is pregnant, and that's it. If he wants he can accept the child and they could have spent the time separately with the kid. And if he doesn't accept the kid, she could have let it be and don't give a damn.

And Kartik could realise that he was wrong and fall on her feet for forgiveness. I don't even know whether Naira should still forgive in the situation I mentioned.

But writers love Kartik and they want a separation and a child to make things more emotionally intense. So when Kartik thinks she is dead because of his fault and his pining away his life, it would be heartbreaking for the audience. And when he gets to know Naira is alive with his kid, it got more intense like how they wanted.

They are ruining characters so badly. And I don't we can blame the writers a lot for this. They keep creating these kinds of content because the audience keeps consuming it. Once the audience rejects it, they will not have any option other than mending their ways.

Bollywood has been showing significant improvement in recent years in terms of content, acting, quality and whatnot. Even the web series content is brilliant these days, especially. But Indian television is just getting more and more regressive. I have heard some of the 90's shows have been way ahead of time like Astivta or Tara or Buniyaad.

The only thing going for Yeh Rishta is Mohsin and Shivangi. I actually feel sad for them, their talent is really wasted here.

Couldn't agree more . Well said.

I guess the writer is more attached to the character of Kartik. She always justifies him & creates sympathy no matter how wrong he is!!

This time too they will make Naira cry & apologize .

Today I dint liked Naksh's reaction. I expected somewhat from him as a brother. He was right in saying that if Kartik wronged her still the full family was there she could have gone to them. But I also wanted him to ask Kartik "How dare he asked his sister such question? "

Naira is wrong of course but Kartik's fault is no less. He is the root culprit of this mess.

I posted some days back want to see strong Naira. Enough of her rona dhona. More is yet to come in the form of Vedika.

Originally posted by: Ekahriz

Woah, I feel the same way. I am so done with Naira apologising to Kartik for everything whether it's her fault or not.

And in today's episode, when dadi said "you should have come to me", I literally was laughing out loud. She was the one to flame Kartik's insecurities in the beginning. And more than taking Naira's side, I can totally imagine Dadi for being the one to ask for a DNA test for the child or trying to get it down without Kaira knowing just like you said.

The only problem I have with Naira is she ran away letting everyone think she died. She could have gone back to her house and be strong and refuse to engage with Kartik no matter what. She could have just told him that she is pregnant, and that's it. If he wants he can accept the child and they could have spent the time separately with the kid. And if he doesn't accept the kid, she could have let it be and don't give a damn.

And Kartik could realise that he was wrong and fall on her feet for forgiveness. I don't even know whether Naira should still forgive in the situation I mentioned.

But writers love Kartik and they want a separation and a child to make things more emotionally intense. So when Kartik thinks she is dead because of his fault and his pining away his life, it would be heartbreaking for the audience. And when he gets to know Naira is alive with his kid, it got more intense like how they wanted.

They are ruining characters so badly. And I don't we can blame the writers a lot for this. They keep creating these kinds of content because the audience keeps consuming it. Once the audience rejects it, they will not have any option other than mending their ways.

Bollywood has been showing significant improvement in recent years in terms of content, acting, quality and whatnot. Even the web series content is brilliant these days, especially. But Indian television is just getting more and more regressive. I have heard some of the 90's shows have been way ahead of time like Astivta or Tara or Buniyaad.

The only thing going for Yeh Rishta is Mohsin and Shivangi. I actually feel sad for them, their talent is really wasted here.

Astitiva as in the one that aired on zee tv? Yep that show was actually not only progressive and ahead of it's time, but it was shocking in that it also portrayed a similar track to something that I had eheard of in the news quite a few years ago but never expected indian tv to show such a thing, and that was the track of a girl who had been kidnapped as a baby growing up and coming across her real father who is the male lead and accidentally developing feelings for him (obviously they didn't go down the route of showing any romantic relationship between the two) but they simply showed that the girl developed feelings for her father without the either of the two of them knowing they are actually father-daughter, the male lead dis-encouraging her from having any feelings for him when he found out given that he was her father's age and it would be wrong, but eventually they get to know their blood relation, but I can't remember much of the show anymore apart from this track and when he cheated the female lead simran in the earlier part of the show for that kiran girl. So yes that was quite shocking to know ITV could be so risky.

All of you are so right.. but the fact is every time a girl is questioned for everything, why not a guy, if the writers wanna show they should show the insecurities Naira felt which led her and even stopped her from coming back,

They are both so faulty,.if they were a real life couple there’s no way they would be together .they would have long ago been divorced...their marriage and whole relationship is just not strong enough ....that’s why for every problem that arises they separate..probably because both of them as individuals are problematic. Karthik had mother father issues growing up ...remember how he used to hate his father and swarna...and Naira ..well she ran away from her parents before ,.and teenagers who run away generally have issues...she did not come from a poverty stricken household where her parents abused her..but she still left them and ran away... so she’s also faulty. But generally most of the leads on ITV shows are problematic ...that’s why there is so much drama in their lives lol...😂

I feel this who’s to be blamed discussion is quite in the past now. It’s been more than 2 months, lol.

Anyways, in my opinion, Kartik was wrong to have asked the question but what Naira did was worse. I quite agree with what Kartik has said over the last 2 episodes. Whatever the issues was, it was between Kartik and Naira. She shouldn’t have gotten the child involved and now that she did, she should open her mouth and tell the family that she stayed away because she was afraid Kartik might question his paternity.

I am more annoyed at the fact that she cried throughout the episode. At least Kartik is accepting his mistake and sharing his opinion.

Naira isn’t even doing that right now.