Its better for the show to go off air - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

3.7k

Users

6

Likes

7

Frequent Posters

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I feel you.

I feel like for me the depth they have shown with kartik not even one iorta has been shown with naira. And dont get me wrong like i am not against them showing any for her but i think that, its a bit too over done every show has a super bahu who has done everything and back.

For me even in this track Kartik is realistic. He isnt a god. He is a man. You keep praising and running behind another dude. He will get mad. And insecure.

Also especially when everything else in his life is shit. and you are the soul focus.


Naira for me is insensitive. Rather than supporting him. She just suddenly jumped into being a bussiness woman which made no sense. I loved the fact unlike every other bahu on tv +_+ they ddn show her like this initially and what she loved was dance. She was in no hurry to study. she had other dreams and that was ok.

You dont have to fit into one mould. +_+ but nope randomly she designs and one souk made her better at shit then kartik. Manish rather discuss business with her than his son whose a graduate and fellow businessman.

I despise her as of now. Kartik is fine. Like they shouldnt even be together is what i feel when these separations happen.

Naira will always lie +_+

And kartik will always be burned like this

@bold remember separation phase?....for me Naira's depth was shown during initial dance academy track in her determination,during separation phase in her silence, clot track in her being adamant like her original self and when she returned baby Krish to his parents...

Kartik's depth is quite inconsistent for me...being selfless in Naira's love by swapping babies because Naira might die, not caring about abortion papers that had Naira's sign...to jumping from train, signing divorce papers, planning a drama to get Naira (brain clot patient) speak truth, signing abortion papers without her knowledge to questioning her character...

@red that's universal truth...all tracks are based on lies...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago
Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#12

After running the show for 10 years, the cvs have either run out of ideas or they are no longer invested in the show. They have already reached the 10 yrs benchmark and would soon complete 3000 episodes, I guess that's really it for them.

As for the stories, its unfortunate how they haven't fully developed other characters besides Kartik and Naira. Previously, each character had something or the other going, which made it easier for the audience to connect to them even when the focus was not on Akshara Naitik. Ak-Naitik had a strong support system in their friends, Mohit and Varsha. They had bonds with each family member, be it their parents, siblings, or in-laws. I really wish Kartik and Naira had some friends they could share their feelings with. Their siblings are useless or at least that's how they are portrayed.

Ever since the story focused on Kaira, the whole show became about their "love", not even their relationship. This majorly restricted the cvs for now everything has to be from their point of view. The cvs introduce new characters in literally each track to move the story forward because other characters are nothing but props.

After the leap I had hoped they would focus more on Kaira's relationship with their kid, but again a new entry is being introduced.

Don't think the cvs are capable of coming up with something different and fresh, not after the current and upcoming track which is nothing but extremely cliche and regressive.

TeenRose1 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Fari_15

The track made no sense whatsoever. It started off as Kaira working together and probably setting an example for the society, to this forced separation.

Kartik is wrong to have questioned Naira. I understood his insecurity and jealousy because he has always been the saviour for Naira, but when he couldn’t do that, he was shaken to the core. He has every right to despise MK because he did talk shit about Kartik behind his back. What I don’t get is how any of this lead to Kartik even remotely believing that Naira is capable of cheating on him?

However, at the same time, it was really annoying how an ever observant Naira was so clueless to Kartik’s feelings for over a month how. How could she not gauge his discomfort? Being independent does not mean you continue working with a person who insults your husband. MK has done get quite often, for example, the one time when he was like you are busy taking care of your husband. Naira continuing to work for MK despite his repu with Kartik seemed like she was trying to prove a point. Also, no one gets calls at 6 am till midnight from their boss and their employees.

The track was nothing but illogical crap which ruined the essence of Kaira and Kartik’s basic characterisation. Naira continues lying to Kartik, even its for his betterment, MK who apparently never mixed personal and professional work, went out of his way to help Goenkas. Manish’s lack of trust on Kartik’s abilities is astounding. Everyone treating Naira as a superwoman is ridiculous.

The trp has dropped to 1.7. Hope for the actors and bts people sake that the ratings rise after the leap, which doesn’t look promising at all. Naira dying, 5 year kid, and now Kartik’s marriage being fixed with a new entry.

True. Two tracks in the same track. WT?

TeenRose1 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#14

She goes thru another accident, so the possibility of miscarriage this time too. But it didn't develop into fetus so no danger even if she gets badly hit in the stomach?

Edited by TeenRose1 - 6 years ago
TeenRose1 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: AnyaRSingh

I feel you.

I feel like for me the depth they have shown with kartik not even one iorta has been shown with naira. And dont get me wrong like i am not against them showing any for her but i think that, its a bit too over done every show has a super bahu who has done everything and back.

True. I felt exactly the same way. It is all Karthik's POV or atleast looks like that.

For me even in this track Kartik is realistic. He isnt a god. He is a man. You keep praising and running behind another dude. He will get mad. And insecure.

Also especially when everything else in his life is shit. and you are the soul focus.


Naira for me is insensitive. Rather than supporting him. She just suddenly jumped into being a bussiness woman which made no sense. I loved the fact unlike every other bahu on tv +_+ they ddn show her like this initially and what she loved was dance. She was in no hurry to study. she had other dreams and that was ok.

You dont have to fit into one mould. +_+ but nope randomly she designs and one souk made her better at shit then kartik. Manish rather discuss business with her than his son whose a graduate and fellow businessman.

I despise her as of now. Kartik is fine. Like they shouldnt even be together is what i feel when these separations happen.

Naira will always lie +_+

And kartik will always be burned like this

AnnaPearl thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Fari_15

The track made no sense whatsoever. It started off as Kaira working together and probably setting an example for the society, to this forced separation.

Kartik is wrong to have questioned Naira. I understood his insecurity and jealousy because he has always been the saviour for Naira, but when he couldn’t do that, he was shaken to the core. He has every right to despise MK because he did talk shit about Kartik behind his back. What I don’t get is how any of this lead to Kartik even remotely believing that Naira is capable of cheating on him?

However, at the same time, it was really annoying how an ever observant Naira was so clueless to Kartik’s feelings for over a month how. How could she not gauge his discomfort? Being independent does not mean you continue working with a person who insults your husband. MK has done get quite often, for example, the one time when he was like you are busy taking care of your husband. Naira continuing to work for MK despite his repu with Kartik seemed like she was trying to prove a point. Also, no one gets calls at 6 am till midnight from their boss and their employees.

The track was nothing but illogical crap which ruined the essence of Kaira and Kartik’s basic characterisation. Naira continues lying to Kartik, even its for his betterment, MK who apparently never mixed personal and professional work, went out of his way to help Goenkas. Manish’s lack of trust on Kartik’s abilities is astounding. Everyone treating Naira as a superwoman is ridiculous.

The trp has dropped to 1.7. Hope for the actors and bts people sake that the ratings rise after the leap, which doesn’t look promising at all. Naira dying, 5 year kid, and now Kartik’s marriage being fixed with a new entry.


I agree that Karthik is wrong ro question Naira especially because I dont feel that is his character insecurities I didn't really mind.

Yeah whenever I see a a part it is either Naira calling MK, or MK trying to call Naira. It makes me wonder whaf did this guy do before Naira started working for him. To showcase Naira's talents they make it look like the entire work depends on her. Wasn't her boss pretty famous and has a name in the jewellery industry even before Naira came to work for him?

I don't know anything about the upcoming track and I don't want to keep any hopes. If the creatives step up their game and take interest I would love the show to continue otherwise I pray the show goes off air before the creatives damage the characters any further and ruin the name the show earned in the last 10 years.

AnnaPearl thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

@bold for me Naira's depth was shown during initial dance academy track in her determination,during separation phase in her silence, clot track in her being adamant like her original self and when she returned baby Krish to his parents...

Kartik's depth is quite inconsistent for me...being selfless in Naira's love by swapping babies because Naira might die, not caring about abortion papers that had Naira's sign...to jumping from train, signing divorce papers, planning a drama to get Naira (brain clot patient) speak truth, signing abortion papers without her knowledge to questioning her character...

I hope you do not mind me interrupting your conversation. Just ignore what is writtwn below if you do mind.

Like I said in the main post from what I observed Karthik's character is driven from love and justice. Like he couldn't accept Suvarna because he felt that her and his father's affair provoked his mother to suicide. So for him it would be injustice with his mother to see Suvarna as his mother. But he wouldn't have cared for his mother's suicide if he didn't love his mother. Same thing with Shubhams death. If Karthik care for his brother be wouldn't care about him dying and Naira hiding the truth.

I am not justifying Karthik's character or saying he has always been right. I am saying whatever was shown until this track I could see Karthik's character somewhere in it. So whenever he did something wrong he was wrong for me. The jealousy and insecurities I understand because these are caused when you feel you are not enough for your loved one. But doubting Naira I don't understand. Heck I don't think I even blame karthik this time because this because is not even a character flaw of his this time. Rather disinterest on the creatives part.

AnnaPearl thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#18

@Fari_15, I agree Kaira need friends.

I love the time when Karthik had Mishti and Naira had Pungi.

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Aleyamma47

5 months ago

Isn't it better if Kiara gets a better man?

Many of the Abhiara fans in Insta/Twitter still want Abhir to leave Charu and go back to Kiara. But why? Isn't it better if Kiara chooses...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

2 months ago

Imagine FL of the show being reduced to Lusty Trash of the Show

Remember those... Days when Lusty bhabhi dreamt of romancing her jeth ji while romancing her husband? Congratulations!! Female Lead of this...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Dr.RealityCheck

23 days ago

Who should cliff off

Both r equally shameless and if dkp starts ema that downfall of rishta has sealed…

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

3 months ago

Which Child leap serverd better?

Portal is open : As well as your options. Generation 4 just started but you know what's gonna happen in future : Mount Abu hit and miss moments,...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: olsen_124

5 months ago

AbhiMaan OS-Being a better father

It had been 7 years since Rohit's demise.He and Abhira had taken over all the responsibilities of the Poddar House.But in between all of this...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".