tera dyaan kidar hai tera shiv idar hai

AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
😆God i knew kartik would figure out so much more with competition around
I am so sure he will play for keeps now and no more just dipping his toe in the water with naira flirting wise😆

Lol naksh i mean suwarna num 2 is behaving exactly like suwarna 😆 can we gag i bet he will match naira's horoscope with rishab as well...🤣

I cant wait for kartik to to get mad about this oh memory loss track u are my fav track since the whole track where kartik wanted to kill his baby and was forcefully back hugging naira and all like i can't let u go, flinging her suit case around😆

Whoever keeps dressing momo in green when his doing jealous kartik scenes please keep doing it it's adorable😆
I kind of hoped naksh would have said yeah u no it was my baby too THE ONE U STOLE and never explained to me WHY YOU STOLE IT😆

Edited by AnyaRSingh - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

2.8k

Users

8

Likes

15

Frequent Posters

rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
Was there an episode today?
Aslesha99 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4

Team Neutrals

Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: rose2015

Was there an episode today?


No there was no episode today but there is a new promo you can watch it on Instagram.
rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#4
Karthik's character in my eyes has lost all credibility. Though he is still married to Naira that foundation has been crumbled due to his deceptions. Right now he is presenting himself to be someone who he is not so in a way he is still deceiving Naira. I feel she deserves someone who will be sincere and honest with her. I think he has been given too many chances to redeem himself but if he can't be honest with Naira then there is no point in continuing this sham of a marriage. Just telling someone you love them is not enough. You show them each moment with your honesty and integrity. (which Karthik has lost) If Naira goes back to him it will just reinforce the idea that no matter how many mistakes a man makes a dutiful wife's job is to look the other way and forgive again and again. There is no such thing as self respect when it comes to a woman. Walking away takes a lot of courage and that is not something indian tv is ready to show.

I can't support such mentality.




Edited by rose2015 - 6 years ago
CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
I lovedd the promo ..most of all the effect 😎...that pull...his dialogues...her facial expressions with that male version of ashi (don't remember his name 😆)...what I loved the most was him claiming his haq on her...in most effective way...Naksh been put to his place...he was actually letting a guy to romance his married sister?...who didn't choose to leave her husband after knowing truth that also by taking advantage of her memory loss...introducing another random guy (whom they knew during childhood) in Naira's life is brother's way of protecting his sister 😕...why can't the seasonal protective brother in action protect her without another guy in her life to complicate it further?...I can bet this track will be amazing if shown the same way as they showed in promo...
Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago
Ekahriz thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6
Okay, I enjoyed the promo. I really did. But I have a few problems with it too.
Kartik is not remorseful about swapping babies and this track is not given a proper end. By making Naksh say I will do whatever I want for my sister's happiness, the writers are indirectly whitewashing Kartik. He also did whatever he felt, thinking that's where Naira's happiness lies.

Now Naksh is the villain bringing a third person between a married couple. And that's wrong I completely agree. Again portraying him in such a bad light just to make Kartik good, I can't agree with. I liked how Kartik lashed out at Naksh, unlike no one saying anything to Swarna's lack of logic. But, I also expect him to accept his mistake, and say something on the lines,
"Naksh, you are making a mistake. Don't forget she is my wife. By thinking you are doing the right thing, you could end up hurting everyone. Ma learned this the hard way, so did I. I thought I was swapping the babies for Naira's health and happiness and look at how it turned out". This would have earned Kartik more respect and integrity, I feel.

But I know nobody really cares about it. Because people love Kaira and hate everyone who comes in between, but don't have a problem when Kartik is the one who is actually killing off their relationship. Now, Naksh is everyone's enemy because everyone has forgotten and forgiven what Kartik has done. People want to see Naksh being put in his place by an angry Kartik who is reasserting his "rights" over Naira.

I just really really wish to see some positive and mature changes in Kartik in his relationship with Naira. Is this too much to ask for? 😭
Edited by Ekahriz - 6 years ago
Fireiswithinus thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#7
Anyone saying otherwise about kartik not being remorseful. As a family what did everyone do ? Bash him. Naksh didnt gave him a chance to even talk . He almost beat him infront of his own sister who was crumpled.
The thing with " white washing " kartik was also on my mind till i saw the reactions of singhanias and goenkas.
The family is also responsible equally.
He was left alone with two pregnant women . One his wife who said that she will die if something happened to the baby. And other in coma... with a baby. Let me ask anyone pointing out where was the family ? Keerti's own husband ? Keerti ki khudki family kha thi.
I REPEAT WHAT KARTIK DID CANNOT BE EVER JUSTIFIED.
but on the other hand he is punished enough. For the sister who he fought up n down . Almost broke his marriage . She broke relationship with him.
Naira forgot him .
What more could a person go through ??
Matlab kya kya smbhalega ? Naira ki memory loss , ya uska baby mar gya ye ya keerti ki problems or naksh ya family ka gussa.
He did it for her.
Nobody is acknowledging this.
Also behaviour of keerti i hate atmost hate keerti and naksh character now.
Kartik ad naira i loved but i also appreciated other characters.
But now...they just want to be jugdes. I hated how tables for keerti turned...when she wanted them to be together but they didnt...
I also sympathise what happened with her...but they are safe. At the end..she has a baby , a husband and she is not ill.
Where as kartik lost his baby girl whose pain will be forever there. Then he lost his wife who doesnt remember him.
Then he didnt get support from his family and his overprotective brother doesnt want him near because suddenly wo meri bhen h.
Achaaa...where were you bhai when she was thrown out. And insulted...damcing with kartik.
He has lost everything .
And now about lying...what other option does he have ??? Like going back and forcing naira ?
Or forcing her to remember the all bad memories...and maan lo if he does that...and she remember and the clot increases and something happens to her..
Tab everyone will say that how he should havr lied because nothing matters more then a person being alive.
He has no other option.
Also if keerti wants a answer she should confront him . He is devastated. I cant imagine someone i love forgetting me...
Sorry for the rant btw
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: rose2015

Karthik's character in my eyes has lost all credibility. Though he is still married to Naira that foundation has been crumbled due to his deceptions. Right now he is presenting himself to be someone who he is not so in a way he is still deceiving Naira. I feel she deserves someone who will be sincere and honest with her. I think he has been given too many chances to redeem himself but if he can't be honest with Naira then there is no point in continuing this sham of a marriage. Just telling someone you love them is not enough. You show them each moment with your honesty and integrity. (which Karthik has lost) If Naira goes back to him it will just reinforce the idea that no matter how many mistakes a man makes a dutiful wife's job is to look the other way and forgive again and again. There is no such thing as self respect when it comes to a woman. Walking away takes a lot of courage and that is not something indian tv is ready to show.

I can't support such mentality.





I think that the baby stealing was the worst thing he has ever done
Like the fact keerti was in a coma just made it even worse

Kartik rather than having at least a few moments to sort grieve his own daughters loss, and have regret over his actions never does

He just sort of is on his own trip.

He never tried to explain why he did what he did...


What naksh is doing with naira as well makes no sense he is using her to get revenge on kartik...if he cared about her health and well being he wouldnt try to shove another guy on her while she is still legally married to kartik

Like in which world would his sanskaari pati vrata behen be cool with that?

Like for naira as well when she found out what kartik did she never left him, both kartik and naksh are not respecting her choices

her own will as a human

they make choices for her constantly

but at the same time my sicko brain likes it😆🤣

M all for kartik asserting himself with naira and giving naksh a verbal slap...I find naksh's scenes alone incredibly cringey...like unlike suwarna thankfully he doesnt act like a lover type...obsessed fool, naksh just looks like a vengeful asshole, his smiles even seem so creepy😆
he barely glances at keerti because all he wants is revenge on kartik
while kartik in his own books did no wrong so he doesnt care
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

I lovedd the promo ..most of all the effect 😎...that pull...his dialogues...her facial expressions with that male version of ashi (don't remember his name 😆)...what I loved the most was him claiming his haq on her...in most effective way...Naksh been put to his place...he was actually letting a guy to romance his married sister?...who didn't choose to leave her husband after knowing truth that also by taking advantage of her memory loss...introducing another random guy (whom they knew during childhood) in Naira's life is brother's way of protecting his sister 😕...why can't the seasonal protective brother in action protect her without another guy in her life to complicate it further?...I can bet this track will be amazing if shown the same way as they showed in promo...


Male aashi's name is rishab😆 i think
Lol thankfully he isnt as distasteful and touchy as aashi❤️ we can thank god for his small mercies

But its hilarious i wanted to see for the longest time what kartik would do if someone else is in love or into naira😆
Like daily manish...random woman everyone really loves on kartik can we not get the same for naira😆
We had cringey gayu for months
so we deserve this guy mooning over naira, i want kartik livid 😆
I miss angry kartik this one whose always crying is too depressing i think last time angry kartik showed up was when he gave those restraining order papers to manish and dadi


Male suwarna is so cringey, his lines about protecting naira make no sense i bet u ...when naira gets her memory back they will have this scene where they show us the accident and naira pushes kartik aside to get hit because she wanted to protect him coz no matter what he did she still loves him

coz they ddn show us how they got out of the way...
Or if they got knocked...
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Ekahriz

Okay, I enjoyed the promo. I really did. But I have a few problems with it too.

Kartik is not remorseful about swapping babies and this track is not given a proper end. By making Naksh say I will do whatever I want for my sister's happiness, the writers are indirectly whitewashing Kartik. He also did whatever he felt, thinking that's where Naira's happiness lies.

Now Naksh is the villain bringing a third person between a married couple. And that's wrong I completely agree. Again portraying him in such a bad light just to make Kartik good, I can't agree with. I liked how Kartik lashed out at Naksh, unlike no one saying anything to Swarna's lack of logic. But, I also expect him to accept his mistake, and say something on the lines,
"Naksh, you are making a mistake. Don't forget she is my wife. By thinking you are doing the right thing, you could end up hurting everyone. Ma learned this the hard way, so did I. I thought I was swapping the babies for Naira's health and happiness and look at how it turned out". This would have earned Kartik more respect and integrity, I feel.

But I know nobody really cares about it. Because people love Kaira and hate everyone who comes in between, but don't have a problem when Kartik is the one who is actually killing off their relationship. Now, Naksh is everyone's enemy because everyone has forgotten and forgiven what Kartik has done. People want to see Naksh being put in his place by an angry Kartik who is reasserting his "rights" over Naira.

I just really really wish to see some positive and mature changes in Kartik in his relationship with Naira. Is this too much to ask for? 😭


Lol kartik stealing the baby was such a horrible track ew 😆
Nothing on earth justifies that
like he will not live that one down i am sorry
no matter how emotionally traumatized he was at the time
but how do u justify stealing ur comatose sisters baby?

I think kaira both need to grow up

Naira seems immature to me taking the baby and hogging it should he not be with his mom?
She literally grabs krish and runs off...
Naksh nor anyone else thinks about keerti's feelings

while kartik all together forgot what he did because all he cares about is "Protecting naira"

I dont mind kartik not moping around and crying over his loss and being angry and possessive
but i wish they ddn make him such a flake and all about himself
how did he think his fear over losing naira is more important than comatose keerti?
How does he think now that ONLY he can protect naira?
😆
Its more to see that naira doesnt forget him. he subconsciously doesnt want naira to exist not knowing him and not relying on him...
he tried and when she wasnt where he had manipulated for her to be at the time she was suppose to be he was ready to go after her

But i still love him😆 keep doing it😆

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: missFiesty_69

3 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai, 14th Sept '25 Episode Discussion Thread

Welcoming everyone to YRKKH's EDT, 14th September 2025

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: KyaBakwaashi

4 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sep 13, 2025 EDT

Welcome to yrkkh episode discussion thread

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: KyaBakwaashi

5 days ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Sep 12, 2025 EDT

Welcome to yrkkh episode discussion thread

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: WildestDreams

7 months ago

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai CC #9

Welcome to the chat corner of the Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai forum Hello all forum waasis, This Chat Corner is open now and anyone can talk on...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".