Naira won't return to Kartik's life-Naksh

CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
Naksh is behaving exactly like Suwarna post leap...he is deciding for Naira the way Suwarna was deciding for Kartik...she lost her son had panic attacks yet her obsession wasn't justifiable it looked unhealthy...similarly now Naksh is behaving same way...According to him whether Naira regains her memory or not he won't let Kartik be a part of her life...he won't let Kartik come near Naira...who is he to decide for Naira??...she lost her memory but didn't lose her right to decide for herself...Suwarna use to chant same monologues...She won't let Naira return to Kartik's life...she was the vamp...and Naksh the protective brother (according to fewer section)...who is protecting his baby sister from deceiving villain Kartik who has wrong intentions...right?...c'mon...Kartik is not the ONLY one responsible for Naira's state (strictly my POV)...Naksh and Keerti after giving her shock left her on her own...without being there for her...to console her...Kartik wasn't allowed to meet her...atleast he tried...person with mental trauma isn't left alone...but they all left her alone...Kartik's action of swapping babies can never ever be justified...but whatever Naksh is doing because of grudge and hatred isn't appearing care or protectiveness...his scenes are mood spoiler...Kartik was wrong but that doesn't make Naksh's wrong actions right...
Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

2.2k

Users

5

Likes

17

Frequent Posters

Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
Tbh, I think there is literally no point in discussing what's right and what's wrong. because at the end of the day, the cvs white-wash each character in a one scene.
- Dadi stole the muksh or something so that Kaira could have a baby boy. At the end of it, no one said anything to her and when Naitik did, he was asked to talk respectfully to Dadi by Kartik himself. Naira left the house as a result and after their "milan", no one even talked about her Dadi was the root cause of the problems between Kaira and everything she had said and made Naira do ( I might be wrong because I didn't watch the show back then. Have watched a few episodes here and there).

- Swarna. Need I even say more? Hated Naira for almost 2.5 years. Got Kaira divorced by hiding about Naira's accident, deleting her phone calls, not telling Kartik she asked for the divorce just so he was spared of the decision. She finds out about Naira's clot, one scene of her crying, and in the next she is doing Naira's kanyadaan.

- Kartik during separation. Threw mud at Naira, physically hurt her (during engagement), verbally said so many things, yet one scene of asking for forgiveness. and he's back to being the most romantic and caring partner.

- Chachu, was ready to kill Akhil in one scene, next scene he's part of the big happy family.

- Kartik again for baby swapping. Does anyone, besides Naksh, even remember what went down before the memory loss? Dk about forgiveness, but at least once ask him why he did what he did. There's no point in even mentioning the fact that Kaira's baby died but there wasn't one scene of the family mourning her death or acknowledging the fact that Kartik held his baby girl moments before she was declared dead.
I know the track has ended, but I still wish there is a scene where Kartik is shown thinking about where their lives would have been had their baby not died. He can then confide in Manish about how hard everything has been, from losing his baby, to now being a stranger for Naira.
I am loving the past three episodes, but I still feel the baby track wasn't given a proper closure. And by baby I don't mean Kartik swapping them, but Kaira's baby dying.

- Naksh. He's being shown as an asshole right now, but when things get cleared, he would be back to being the non-existent brother and would embrace Kartik as if nothing ever happened.

I feel like I have deviated from the topic, but my whole point was, it's better for us (I am assuming you are a Kaira fan as well and watch the show mainly for them) to enjoy the Kaira scenes and their lovestory, rather than focusing on Naksh. At the end of the day, he's totally irrelevant to this story line until and unless he does something drastic to keep Kaira away like how Swarna had an accident. We all know his threats mean nothing to Kartik and even Naira won't listen to him with or without her memory, so why even care about what he's saying.

He's coming across as a jealous brother who's just avenging what Kartik did to him by doing the same with Kartik, snatching one thing that means the world to him.

Idk about you, I am too involved in Kaira scenes and the lover girl Naira to give two hoots about Naksh or Keerti.

Valentine episodes are coming next week and I can't wait. So hoping we get a romantic dream sequence and other cutsey scenes.
Ajscinesonadar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
To all this Dadi said it all, kaira's relationship they have been writing further also they will.
So whatever naksh says no one goingt to give two hoots.
Even devyani Dadi seemed pissed with him. Let him dance on Bhai ka dard.
Kaira are already having their time though naira unknown to fact she is having feelings for her own husband. But yea it's cute to watch.
AnyaRSingh thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

Naksh is behaving exactly like Suwarna post leap...he is deciding for Naira the way Suwarna was deciding for Kartik...she lost her son had panic attacks yet her obsession wasn't justifiable it looked unhealthy...similarly now Naksh is behaving same way...According to him whether Naira regains her memory or not he won't let Kartik be a part of her life...he won't let Kartik come near Naira...who is he to decide for Naira??...she lost her memory but didn't lose her right to decide for herself...Suwarna use to chant same monologues...She won't let Naira return to Kartik's life...she was the vamp...and Naksh the protective brother (according to fewer section)...who is protecting his baby sister from deceiving villain Kartik who has wrong intentions...right?...c'mon...Kartik is not the ONLY one responsible for Naira's state (strictly my POV)...Naksh and Keerti after giving her shock left her on her own...without being there for her...to console her...Kartik wasn't allowed to meet her...atleast he tried...person with mental trauma isn't left alone...but they all left her alone...Kartik's action of swapping babies can never ever be justified...but whatever Naksh is doing because of grudge and hatred isn't appearing care or protectiveness...his scenes are mood spoiler...Kartik was wrong but that doesn't make Naksh's wrong actions right...



You know with suwarna i think one person she should have also apologized to was kartik, for thinking he was incapable of making his own decisions and just doing shit for him. Did she ever really apologize for trying to make him marry aashi? or even shoving her own choices down his throat. But at the same time kartik is also to blame back then to a certain point for failing as a husband and not protecting naira and both these two egg plants suffered the consequences with naira because of them getting the blood clot

I always thought that naksh should have at that point opened his mouth or even before that and thought about his sisters self respect but all he cared about was himself, and if hs dad was around or not.

Even naitik and the rest of the singhania's lack what it takes to protect someone as naive as naira.
Sure they all spoke up when she chose to divorce him right but what was their argument stick to this man who humiliates and abuses u? And is an alcoholic?
U loved him that's enough no matter how he treats u abuse is ok in the name of love?

The divorce flipped kartik like i cannot even imagine...He went from extreme hatred and acting like a broken tape recorder with his tumhare vajese arguments, to a guy who would do anything desperately to bring naira back into his life.
He stopped clinging to his fake moms palu and started thinking for himself right
and he was the only human able to tell her enough now and get her to to calm her shit down

Similarly i think with naksh the only person to calm him down will be naira telling him explicitly

Like i know what kartik did isnt really wrong coz he had his reasons right, but what i find annoying is that nobody is giving him consequences the way naira had them, he walked into singhania house with zero remorse of even a second look at keerti after she said she doesnt wana see him again, all to take naira away.

And what stopped him was his selfish fear of her hating him. He would rather she live memory less but not hating him. Is he not doing the same as naksh by making that choice for her. For in a way lying to her again, by showing up and being super controlling and manipulating everything?

He doesnt care his family already forgave him the singhania dadi's dont give a shit all they want is naira gone even keerti and he is living ok worrying now about valentines day?

Its very strange honestly

Like the tracks are too messy when we should have a leap logically there is no leap and they just had like 4 leaps that were not even needed.

A leap inserts excitement into the story

For me i feel with everything happening its too soon, naira lost her memory two days later she falls in love with kartik all over again, while he stalks and stares at her
Like if ur husband lied to u all the time, tried to kill ur kid without ur permission forged ur signiture on shit, fought with u bro and demanded he stay out of ur lives and ddn look the way momo did would u be ok with it??

He is so manipulative and controlling, i feel that eventually some dude will show up after he tells naira he doesnt like her, and then he will lose his shit. Because naira is not doing what he wants, after all that will always be his biggest trigger naira not under his control


Dow dont get me wrong i love this track😆 i just love debating it

shortysalem thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
I find it all crazy. First of all, I don't understand how Naksh and the Singhanias can just take charge of Nairas well being and her life. She is married to Karthik and not Naksh. Naksh needs to leave Naira alone. She is more than capable to make her own decisions in life when it comes to Karthik. Doesn't the husband have a say over his wife before the brother. The last time I checked when a girl gets married her husbands family becomes her new family. The Goenkas have more rights over Naira but yet they are not allowed to even have their daughter in law come home.
What Naksh is doing to Naira is no different than Karthik. They both are lying to her but Naksh is doing it out of hatred. Naira would regain her memory completely if she was told the entire truth. I understand why Kartik is using a different name because the Singhanias are not letting him no where near his wife whereas he all rights to be with her.
Now the writers are going to bring in another third wheel knowing Naira is still a married woman. Did they all forget the fact that Naira is still a married woman. She has a mind of her own. Wake up people...
They always leave one track incomplete and start another.
They should have kept Naira and Kartik together instead of splitting them up again. They both needed to grieve the loss of their baby and everything that has happened. They needed to deal with it first. But it was completely bypassed. Not happy with a third wheel coming between the two love birds. Naksh needs to get a life and leave his sister to her own life with Kartik her husband and the love of her life.


Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: madhuvan

3 months ago

Is Maira being made trouble maker for her future sister Naira?

Getting a feeling this time Legacy FL child will ne negative itself rather than the side or 3rd angle. Maira is too much of trouble maker. This...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shahsb_26

3 months ago

Maira Naira Daksh Naksh - - Makes sense?

not my idea... Bass instagram par dekha and thoda sensible laga... https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==

https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ87FNNTech/?igsh=MXBxNXBwMXBsZ2pqaw==
Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: BangBang_Shilpa

2 months ago

What happened to Naksh & Kirti

They perhaps had a son named Krish. Were they ever shown in Gen 3 or later? Naksh would be grandfather by now, and where's Varsha and Jasmeet?...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

8 months ago

Naksh vs Kairav vs Abhir

Though I might don't ask this question but still I wanna know.. Naksh was described ax a real brother of his sister and a real paraller lead vs...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

2 months ago

Abhira's future life?

Thank You, Shukrana.

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".