Bad messages in this day and age

nivi.divi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Yeh Rishta... is a good family show with some high moments. Its been around for a while now and we've gotten used to certain characters and relationships.

I don't expect a show like Yeh Rishta... to teach us moral values and whatnot. However, I do know personally that there are many women and families that watch this show. AND there are a few things that bother me a lot:

Naksh is a kid. Not the only kid in the world. Just a kid. He's also not the only boy in the world. The guy is shown to be tooo over clever and 'chalak' to the point that it is disgusting and completing removing the childhood aspect. I understand that some Indian families go gaga over their kid/s, especially when they are boys. Naksh gets waaay to much attention for what he is. His dadi gives him waaay tooo much attention especially. His dadi and Akshara worry way to much about him and all the smallest expectations of him. I absolutely hate the scenes where they look mortified thinking about what Naksh is going to think. If they keep doing this, he will turn out like his father.

Naitik is an overgrown baby. Grow up Naitik!! When you were in coma, your wife did everything, everything that you would normally never do. She went to work (successfully) and handled the house (even more successfully), with a mother in law like Gayatri and a brat son like Naksh. She deserves a lifetime achievement award. Appreciate your wife. Don't git over small things and act like a baby at least now.

Lastly, Akshara, stop worrying so much about your husband and son so much that you start to look constipated. They can handle themselves sometimes. Don't worry about what they will think or do or react.

The scene that got to me the most was the one where Akshara - trying to make the picnic perfect for her son, balancing Naitik's schedule, putting up with her demanding mother in law, coming back from work ------- and ------------ putting up with Naitik's attitude. What ticked me off was she was trying to pacify him like a baby. "Tum jo hukum do" ... "Why don't you sit and rest while I make you a good strong tea". What does Naitik say "Yes, make it strong". 😲

He's not considerate whether she also came back from work, or that she is trying to do something for her son's happiness, or that she has been hovering around you like a fly trying to get your attention.

Naitik simply comes back from work and gets royal treatment. Plus, he gets the weekend off to play video games with this friend and son. Plus, he gets to demand on the spot meals like pizza during weird hours. Plus, he does not have to respect anyone's wishes or time. Akshara is seen running around trying to do it all while eventually finding out that he just does not care about anyone else's wishes or time. But she still goes on. That is not right.

The worst is when she's slammed in between Gayatri and Naitik - both of which most often have different views but communicate their demands through Akshara, pressuring her between a rock and a hard place.

I'm a wife, and I admit, I make tea for my husband after we both come back from work. But - putting up with that all the time is awful. The poor lady is seen running around daily from work to home, and putting up with everyone's expectations - her childish husband, stubborn bratty child, weird mother in law, over anxious mother. Yes, its an accomplishment of many Indian women. Indian families do not need to see this play out on TV - this should not be treated as good behavior or normal.

Last point - Akshara took over Naitik's work responsibilities while he was unwell. Good. But really, when Naitik was fine, did anyone approve of her working. They were watching her every step even she she went out for grocery shopping. Circumstances change and Akshara now goes to work. They appreciate it. But would they have let her go otherwise?

Why does the woman (esp. Indian woman) have to put herself through the fire to prove herself?
Edited by nivi.divi - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

2.3k

Users

7

Likes

44

Frequent Posters

598558 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Trp shows whether its bad or good msg...n no one is perfect...yrkkh is very close to reality ..u can find naitik like husband..naksh like child or g3 like mil..if everything was perfect thn who will watch show n Indian soaps..women sacrifice its common n tht we see in real life too...
nivi.divi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Women sacrifice a lot and that is the reality. But show it in the light of sacrifice and not constantly send messages out that its ok for a woman like Akshara to take crap from everyone without repercussions. There is no learning. It's not ok for that to happen all the time and pretend that its the way it should be.

Ever since Akshara has been in the house, this is the way it has been.

Great that they showed her struggles, because that is reality in India today too for many women.

But show the outcome, show the lesson, show the learning, show that its not nice for him to do that all the time. Show that Akshara will not take that crap all the time.

Real life people like Gayatri and Naitik need to feel guilt, not to be reinforced that their "hukum" on their wife/daughter in law are alright.
NehaAish thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
there arent a better and ideal husband like Naitik who always been there for her and beatuiful portrited on-screen, aruguement is a part of the life for husband and wife and i feel nothing is wrong, they both understand each-other quit well sometimes g3 sounds bit roud but in the end she also loves him a lot that already scene it, and you expecting modern values which show dosent posses...its a adrash show and charcters also..every womens or girl has differenlty values so does akshara
you dont have to put in your life what show is conveying..

loves Yeh Rishta And Naksh
Edited by NehaAish - 12 years ago
Depalii thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
its sound bit attachyar speech, sorry to tel you counted many things of naitik and duggu, g3 but didnt naitik scrifice his life for whom ? that is akshara !! arent akshara take care him coz she loves him alot when the point is come hukum coz you dont do that dosent mean no one do for his hubby pls what are saying wife/mom always worried about his husband/son/daughter no matters where ever they are..its for love not over reacting and same thing akshara does so what you find wrong in it ?/ regarding rajshiri she also a mom so will conveys his love to daughter na..its common thing its typical for women sorry i dont agree this and show is like reality there arent a better show like this hardly any negitivy in it..thats why show running succesfully
Edited by Depalii - 12 years ago
Kriity thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
Disagree !!

well you said all about women and his sacrifice then what about g3 and rajshiri arent they are women ??

story its related to reality so thats happen and duggu is kid not a adult or mature who can act like adult ones, you expecting too much for a kid..

why Akshara have to stop worrying about his husband/wife ?? she is a mom/wife and loves them lot so itsa natural thing for her and they they meant evrything for her..

Naitik-akshara ideal couple and nok-jhok part of the couples life why are you putting hukum -sukum ?? seriously they both never thought about that what are mentioning in it and she is not doing sacrificing anything she doing for her beloved ones, even she likes it the same..other thing naitik never ever said no to him he always try to fullfill his dreams no matters what happen,,didint it ??

I Loved this show just coz of this not for sacrifice and all that
Edited by Kriity - 12 years ago
nivi.divi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Kriity

Disagree !!


well you said all about women and his sacrifice then what about g3 and rajshiri arent they are women ??

story its related to reality so thats happen and duggu is kid not a adult or mature who can act like adult ones, you expecting too much for a kid..

why Akshara have to stop worrying about his husband/wife ?? she is a mom/wife and loves them lot so itsa natural thing for her and they they meant evrything for her..

Naitik-akshara ideal couple and nok-jhok part of the couples life why are you putting hukum -sukum ?? seriously they both never thought about that what are mentioning in it and she is not doing sacrificing anything she doing for her beloved ones, even she likes it the same..other thing naitik never ever said no to him he always try to fullfill his dreams no matters what happen,,didint it ??

I Loved this show just coz of this not for sacrifice and all that



Gayatri/Rajshri are also women and daughter in laws - but they don't necessarily have high-maintenance mother in laws or husbands as Akshara does!!

I want Naksh to act like a kid. Right now he acts too much like a chalak vamp.

I don't want Akshara to stop worrying about them completely. As a wife and mother, you cannot completely be worry free - but she over does it sometimes. Motherhood and wife-hood are one part of you, they should not consume you. Akshara has no individuality because of them.

I'm putting 'hukum'??? Akshara asked Naitik if he had any 'hukum' for her. What did Naitik do, act like a big baby again.

AGAIN - its not about showing reality vs. not showing reality. Its about showing how wrong things are wrong and should be corrected.
avyarima thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
i totaly agree with you. i know they are trying to show reality and i personally love Naksh, but they should tune down a little on Duggu's behaviors. he is a little too much...he gets to me!.

Nitik needs to start thinking about Akshira...since he is not just a husband...he is her lover. he should help her stay relax, he should be her support system and stop being a big baby.

but Akshira should at this point should be worrying about what is right for her family not about what they would think.

if after all this while they dont know that what every she is doing is in their best interest , then they are not worth it.
Nakshian4ver thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
i too agree...it happens in our home too
i mean my mom nly controls everything...bt i try my level best to help her
merely in joint families it happens more where elders(dada,daddi) wil live...

they always over pamper boy kids

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Sakshi-deewan

3 months ago

Age gap n compatibility

Original Akshara n naitik was 2 years apart. Kartik n naira were also 2-4 years apart as per the calculations made before . But since gen 3 ,...

Expand â–¼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Abhirasharma

4 months ago

YRKKH forum members Age is?

Hello, I am Gayatri, a 60 year old mother to two children (one in 30s and another in 20s). I would love to know your age.

Expand â–¼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Mehersudha

3 months ago

MOTHERS DAY 11.5 MOTHERS DAY 11.5

HAPPY MOTHERS DAY Ruhi gives pookie to abheera and says she will stay in goenkas for a month Abheera says you need extra care after delivery I...

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".