Tuesday Ramblings: Ayaana the Puppet - Page 2

Originally posted by: vibha28

I think this is more about deep connection which roshni clearly said when she left that she doesn’t care about relations but about connections, she repeated that again when she died.

For this very reason, it does not make sense to have Kabir bring her back to life, since there is no connection there.

It’s not about who brought her back - for me it would have made no impact if Aman had brought her back because I never believed and still don’t the whole falling in love when one dies concept. That sounds and feels very conditional. So I didn’t care who brought her back, I wanted her back so Aman can then show her he means what he said - the supposed journey of magical love which will confirm connection from Amans end as Roshni’s is already solidified.

Aman bring her back, emphasize not only their connection, but also carries the concept of the story. There is a saying “sometimes, you never know what you have, until you loose it.” And from a few episodes prior the the big laal chand show down, we were pretty much told, it was when Roshni dies, Aman will REALIZE his love for her, not that he would FALL in love with her. So there is no issue about conditional love her.

Regarding kabirs you can’t live without me - is just so Aman suffers nothing to do with roshni. Frankly if he loved her or cared about her then he would have never brought her back to JM, just kept her somewhere else. Kabir is not dumb he has an agenda and it doesn’t feature roshni as a leading lady but him as the king.

It is too cliche and does not love the “connection” theory is Aman and Roshni. And this not the first time the CVs show/indicate deep connections between pairs and then abruptly destroy it.

Ayana coming back with her powers now will be silly given there aren’t any more fights until the end but in the meantime a decent love story with strong foundation is needed.

There doesn’t need to be a fight for Ayaana to have powers. Ayaana already has her powers with or without a fight. But she doesn’t truly know how to use them.

Kabir wants aman to die and what better way than to mess with roshni? We all saw how he was the day he was without her - aman won’t let that happen and eventually roshni will come around too.

The easier way for Kabir, was to leave Roshni dead.

If he misbehaves this time then I won’t support him but until then I am not worried at all. Bring on third or fourth wheel - the story has two people in the end and that’s what matters.

Originally posted by: mkeshav

The connection was only from Roshni’s end and it’s still there in her subconscious as she is under the SJ control due to magic. Aman does not have the saya anymore so he will get it but it will take time. I think when they talk about connection they speak of feelings not a literal connection. I liked the light hearted moments after the heavy crying, the revolving door, name calling, and all that I needed the laugh and happiness and now it’s love story phase and you need a villain to make it a better one. Here the villain is actually helping the brother - it’s his mother he is after not his sister in law lol 😂

I have only watched one show on ITV where the connection was just mind blowing and it never ever broke even when the leads were seperated. The MIL wanted them apart and did everything and nothing worked but the ML kills the FL sister by mistake and he goes to jail and she leaves him for 5 years. They introduced a new male character who loved the FL and when the ML came back his mum instigated him but he said I trust her more than myself am not worried and his mother said what is wrong with you that new guy tells her to jump and she says how high!!! And the ML said it doesn’t matter I trust our love and destiny and she has always been mine and will be mine. He was right too she only thought it that guy as her friend. It was such a breath of fresh air to see that level of trust.

The FL was the same. The MIL created a MU and said he was flirting with other and she goes okay there must be a reason and he will tell me when the time is right I trust him and our love. The MIL was super frustrated and would tell her side kick that I can handle the FL but it’s my bloody son who gets in between and nothing will make him go against his wife. They even had a MU which didn’t get cleared because ML said to the FL that I don’t care I can’t stop loving you. Best show ever but after that I have not seen a show where that level of trust and deep connection was shown.

I realized from some other place you had commented the show that you were talking about was Gathbandan. Watched the entire show and still couldn't recognize that you were talking about it from your description.

Interesting how two people can view the same show with different perspectives.

To me Kabir bringing Roshni makes perfect sense. Kabir couldn’t have made a better move to ensure that his brother remains occupied , so that his path to the throne remains clear. Also Kabir has the measure of Parveen better than everyone else in JM. He has at least an inkling if what she truly desires. Bringing Roshni back also puts a wrench in Parveen’s dreams of being queen. From all the “thaaro-ki-baarish” inner dialogue jaap , I think Ammi Jinn wants her sons to fight and finish each other off. She said while separating them that together they would stand against her. So whatever this next night brings, Parveen it seems, does not want any good for Kabir/Aman.

Aman’s jealousy will makes him focus more on Roshni. He will look for ways to jog her memory. Also like others said, this gives Aman a chance to work for her love, as opposed to it being handed on a platter to him (as would’ve happened if Roshni was awakened by Aman’s kiss or tears). The connection was always from Roshni’s side. Aman has had no inkling of her true nature despite her always showing goodness. Untill Saima & Salma explained things to him, she was always a Tawaif’s daughter and gold digger for him. Connection from hus side is only starting to form.

CVS are always using cliche ways to bring about jealously, closeness, etc.

Aman and Roshni’s connection was never one sided. It was that Roshni realized the connection and accepted it. Aman did d not realize the connection, thus he did not accepted it. Had he listen to Roshni when he threw her out the house, he would have realized it becuase it was always there.