Originally posted by: Stephi
There are a few things that have always puzzled me about Chameli. The first time she showed up and helped Mukta she didn't look like a helpless,troubled woman at all. She was sitting in front of the brothel, smoking a cigarette and fearlessly confronted to those bullies.
Just a few days later completely opposite picture, she was like a hunted beast, helpless,distraught with fear. OK, she had my full sympathy and compassion. In the prison, she said to Meethi that there's no solution for her problem.For a moment I wondered how this is possible. Kadjri was rescued from a brothel for example.
Ok, she still had my sympathy. But then , her daughter was in danger,Naina came to tell her about it but Chameli's behavior confused me a bit..She didn't look like she was particularly upset, she turned her back to her friend and with a mysterious smile on her face she said that nothing will happen to Rani. As if she knew exactly how things will happen.Then Akash came in the prison and she said I trusted Meeti and she failed , but I'm here helpless,what to do, as if it was all Meethi's mistake. For the first time I didn't like it all. The rest we know. She did not want to go with them but also she did not resist that much.And finally my biggest disappointment was the way she said that Rani is Akash's daughter and just a few minutes before she apparently did not want to destroy the happiness of Meethi's family.If so, she could stay silent and not to insist that precisely Meethi should know about her love story with her husband .And particularly her explanation that she got pregnant but still decided not to inform the father of her child because there was a possibility to make some other movie helped me to realize definitely that Chameli is a selfish person who puts her own interests above everything else. So my guess she didn't turn to be negative character, she was always like that.
stephi she was not sacred @ 1st bcoz in brothels women r closely knit & there pimps & oder women r v.protective of them from outsiders.we'd seen so many times in movies (sum1 shud watch talaash & chameli that how these brothels work).so wne chameli helped & saved mkta form those goons then she'd protection from those men who were later on tried 2 harm her.
kajri was rescued form brothel bcoz she was not there from many months/yrs.
the women who spent so many yrs in brothels loose hope.
and that scene where she turned her back on her frnd & smiled thats bcoz she knew that mth will take care of rani v.well & moreover her smile seemed 2 me like sad types not mysterious one.and wen she told aksh abt mth cudn't save rani then she didn't know that it was mkta who betrayed. bcoz she came 2 know from mkta that rani is wid mkta & she thot shes rich so can protect rani more effeciently.
and she told abt rani being akh's daughter bcoz she herself said that u can abuse me but not my daughter as shes ur own blood.bcoz no mother/woman can hear such abuses 4 their kids.
and he rnot telling abt rani 4 movie etc. i can term as selfishness but not basically cheap or -ve bcoz she came 2 mumbai 2 bcum actress so she must'd thot she shud 1st establish her a s actress even if she'd 2 compromise a bit like many oder foolish gals who wanted 2 bcum actress do.
so here my guess was that she was never -ve but it was only done 2 make kash sum true luver & create drama.
i think u'vn't heard such things. bcoz in India its v.common thing which happens that how women fall in pros etc.i'd so many times read such true stories abt pros wen they were rescued from brothels by NGOs .they used 2 think that they can't b rescued & all. even kajri was scared not 2 go wid vishnu wen he tried 2 help her.she asked him 2 leave her there as these ppl r dangerous.bcoz she has fear that they"ll again find her & then her life/honour will b in more danger.
bcoz the way they showed nandini's ckt from the start then she mite b ordinary woman whos jealous & selfish 2 sum extent but never a psycho & -ve like mkta & aksh were/r.its only done 2 add drama 2 get trps.like show 1st chameli as ordinary woman then sudden;y make he r -ve. hadn't we seen such tactics done by CV in oder shows also.
but RG has 4gotten that she can't fool all ppl thatswhy this track is not getting trps much.wenevre she tried 2 show the ckts wat they were not initially whether its abt showing mkta & aksh as sum true luvers who r doing all psyhcopanthi 4 their so-called luv & justifying & glorifying them or now making chameli -ve.