Amit Sana and Toshi- wrongly judged?

these guys know their music...they sing songs in a way that do not sound like the originals...they have the capability of adding variations.which is better than Neha Kakkar going oooh and aah at all the wrong places in beedi jaliye le...they always choose tough songs....

are thse guys being judged properly?😕 just wondering....

I agree infact I just said that in a previous post... I thought Toshi was reallly good in comparison to his performances in JJWS... but Vishal said he would have been in danger if he was one point less... It wasnt a bad performance.... I wont say it was the best performance like Himani's but it was much better then Neha's ..

Amit Sana was good I dont know whats going on with marks.. totally confused..

Same here, the judges were clearly not impressed with neha, however gave encouraging comments to toshi, however the marks dont reflect what they say, so yeh am confused also? Toshi should have got more marks, or neha should got less then what ever toshi got.

i totally agree with you on Amit Sana's performance.....what were the judges thinking!!!! they were too tough on him.....he did very well.......anyways cant do anything about it now can we!!!!lol

I think everyone was judged wrong. in my mind Himani, Amit Sana, and Toshi sang well, himani only got 9, 9, 10 , I think her performance was 10, 10 10 and same for toshi.
Amit Sana not way deserve to be shown red flag, neha was worst of all even worst than Sumitra. sur were not there. she should have been eliminated.
comments and marks differs. they gave almost same comments for neha and Sumitra, infact I thought Neha's comments was even worst than Sumitra, but marks... I am not happy with Farah been a bully, announcing before consulting with the other.

My cable went at the exact time when Toshi was about to perform, and came back in the break just after, so haven't seen his performance 😛 But judging by the viewer's comments, I think Toshi gave a good performance, a better one perhaps compared to rest of his earlier performances? I'm glad 😃
The judges need to take their roles more seriously. The mentioned points here add only more flaws to the growing list...

aww im feeling soo bad for Amit sana.. 😭 😭 😭
dis time usne tho baar baar bachgayee he really didnt deserve dt red flag 😡 neha was too bad compared to sumitra

Neha should have been eliminated today no doubt. Only b/c the song was dedicated to Vishal, he couldn't bash her way too much which really is not fair. Amit Sana was not bad at all. Maybe the viewers should be voting on the challengers side as well? They were being totally bias today. Very unfair judgement towards Toshi and Amit.

Hmm-- gud thought. I hope the show officials see the judges are not taking their roles seriously-- and giving whatever marks when they "Feel" like it, according to song choice, whether their eyes were open or not, or based on who the song is dedicated to.
Perhaps a system consisting both the judges marks and audience voting can be employed for the Challengers? They can't be so unfair to peoplw singing well on the show.
btw, I just saw the epi on youtube :D
I just found out Farah had commented to Toshi after his performance, "Red flag dikhane ki zarurat nahi pedege, safe performance thi, not the best."
That means they could have given him a red flag too?? On this performance??

I think Amit sana started the song very well but was completely off in antara and deserved a red flag....

In case of toshi he selected a higher scale (wrong scale) to start the song ... but i believe that he did do justice with that scale to the song.... he could have got little more marks 😊 I specially liked his performance because it was different from his confort zone and he did well...😊