Was Hum Tum a better movie than HDDCS?

 Rani was great in Hum Tum and this movie started her domination in Bollywood during 2004.  It is like her signature role.  And Saif got a National award.  HDDCS was pretentious and artificial with the two leads.  What do you think?

Dono bkwas films.

HDDCS is romantic melodrama while HT is a proper romcom, two different genres and hence cannot be compared. Both excellent movies😍

Aish be like - fir aa gaya 

Of course Yes, I can still watch Hum Tum 100 times, But I'm done with HDDCS

Originally posted by: fazgostoso

 Rani was great in Hum Tum and this movie started her domination in Bollywood during 2004.  It is like her signature role.  And Saif got a National award.  HDDCS was pretentious and artificial with the two leads.  What do you think?

Everyone know why Saif got a national award for this movie ! 😂 nothing to be proud of that. 
He was better than salman, that I agree. But national award was a joke on that day. They stripped it from Mammootty. 

Why are you so interested in discussing Aishwarya's old films

Neither was a bad movie.  Neither was a great movie.  Neither was an original movie.  I would pick the one that Hum Tum was a remake of, When Harry Met Sally, over all of them.  

Originally posted by: priya185

Why are you so interested in discussing Aishwarya's old films

I am discussing Rani’s old movie to.  I like Rani so I am discussing her. 

Originally posted by: NathuPaapi

Aish be like - fir aa gaya 

Inko ek thread mein bahurani lover bol diya tha toh ab Rani fan bann ne ka natak kr rhe h