Originally posted by: coldbrew
Aloo's silence is anything but dignified. Courage, to me, is someone who can confront their truth and behavior, accept their privilege and shortcomings and know where they stand in the grand scheme of things. Being tone deaf and putting your family up for shameful, petty "open letters" when they're all in the same house is pretentious and bratty. It shows how she can't even wait for it do subside and wants it all back NOW. All while they're sitting in their posh mansions completely removed from where the rest of the world is. Simply can't buy Aloo's "courage" here.
The "texture of grief" post was regarding Rishi Kapoor's death. In all this hubbub, people have forgotten that he died somewhat prematurely in a very painful kind of cancer. By all accounts, Alia is pretty close to the family and her fiance was devastated at losing his father. There was a world before June 14th you know- as much as I am saddened by what happened that day- people are allowed their own private grief.
Also I dont think Mahesh Bhatt is criminally culpable at all in any way- if anything he has faced baseless insinuations about himself on national news for which I hope the Bhatts do sue for defamation. But even leaving that aside if you disagree, why should Alia face online bullying and trolling on his account? How is that tone deaf to call it out even subtly? Shaheen has struggled with mental health herself and has been an open advocate for anti bullying since a very long time. Her point is valid- you cant avenge someone's death and the alleged bullying they went through by bullying someone else. This way the cycle will never end! And sitting in a mansion doesnt inure you from pain and anxiety. How do you know she hasnt been affected by what happened or maybe her role in it indirectly through KJO's shenanigans?
comment:
p_commentcount