Yeh Hai Mohabbatein - Is Mohabbat ever enough?

996541 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Yeh Hai Mohabbatein. It began with the mohabbat between a 6 year old child who craved love and a woman who craved to love a child. The show, all about second chance. However it was Ishita and the relationship she shared with the small daughter of her neighbour that really began this story. We saw how a barren woman who was deemed a baanj numerous times was able to become a mother to the child she never gave birth to. How a step mother's love stood out over everything and everyone. How a pure love between a woman who could never have a child and a child who never had a mother fulfilled two people with contentment.

I loved this show for the very reason. Ishita-Raman, KP-DT are the reason people many people watched this show, but there were many people who loved the bond between Ishita and Ruhi. How a woman could become a mother with her love, how a child could give birth to a mother, how I love mattered over everything else. The message that this show had given so beautiful and simple.

And then I got to see today's episode. I know this show isn't what it was and I honestly after the WU was going into the episode only to watch for Raman's feelings in the beginning thinking I would be able to understand him, but it was more than what I thought. It was a great episode for the first few minutes when it focused on Raman and Ishita thanks to KP and DT. But what followed was just unbelievable...

Ishima? Or should I say just Ishita?

She gave her heart to a young girl, mothered her and became the Ishima that was loved by all even the boy who once hated her. She gave them all her everything, she even gave up the baby she had yearned to have in her womb within a split second to save the children that truly made her a mother in its truest sense. She loved them more than the baby that was her dream, she loved them so much that they were the only ones who had the power to let her believe that she was a mother.

Ishita Amma? Or once again just Ishita?

She gave 7 long years of her life to a young teenager. She had lost everything, she had broken apart, she had no wish to live as she believed she was a manhoos person who had taken the life of the very child who had put another life into her, gotten her a second chance and returned happiness into her life. Yet she left it all behind, she tried to smile for this teenager as she believed that she needed a mother. She loved the young girl as if she was her own. She treated her no different than anyone else, and gave her the same love she gave her own children.

Today more than anyone, my heart went out to Ishita, Ruhi and Adi's Ishima, Aliya's Amma. Ishima gave up her everything to the extent of her own child, for these two children while Aliya's Amma continued to live when she had no wish for the sake of the young girl who needed a motherly figure in her life. Ishima-Adi-Ruhi and Ishita Amma-Aliya are define the original message of Yeh Hai Mohabbatein, the latter less than the first, but both are very similar. They both convey the message of the real YHM; that blood relations don't matter.

But today CVs ruined that very message, pretty much murdering it with their own writing as they showed the police station scene. Yes it was to show Raman angry and Ishita in a dilemma on how to choose between to children. However to me, it was the heart wrenching to watch that scene more than the precap to be honest. This woman had given her life to these children. The two year she spent with Adi were dedicated to him and Ruhi while Aliya was her focus for the past seven years. And it took one moment for both the fathers of these children to question her love.

I will make sure my daughter's culprit gets punished. He announced.
I will make sure my son is released. He replied back.

Where is her place? Why wasn't it our son or our daughter? Was Ishima's love not enough to make Adi her son? Was Ishita Amma's love not enough to make Aliya her daughter? Ishita, who loved and will always continue to love children more than herself, was shown the harsh reality, that she didn't share a relationship of blood with these children. She never carried these children, didn't give birth to them, and will always remain the woman who raised them. She tried to fight back and screamed that they are her children, but in vain. No one listened because she wasn't the biological mother. No one would question her love, no one would say a word to her had she given birth to these child.

YHM, the show that said love is above blood relations in one episode completely destroyed the beautiful "nayi soch" that it once portrayed. Today it was proven that no matter what a step mother or a guardian does, she will never be the real parent. She will never be treated like a biological mother or father. She will be questioned, she will need to prove her love, giving her life may never be enough to show that she loves the child as she would love her own child. Maybe a step mother will never become a mother...

Thank you YHM for this lovely message...and thank you for showing that no matter what people do, there are some truths that come up during the worst of times...that sometimes unconditional mohabbat isn't enough...
Edited by smilesforever98 - 9 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

3.7k

Users

10

Likes

121

Frequent Posters

-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Lovely write up, Prabh! Literally have nothing else content wise to add except what a joke this show has made of the concept of motherhood. It's disgusting to think a woman who has born her own children can make motherhood and parenthood a grotesque freak show.

The pre-leap segment was the icing on the cake & today was adding an extra cherry on top. They reduced Shagun to a mere womb, had constant rants on how Ishita is a step-mom and enjoys "being IshiMa", showed the pre-leap pathetic outburst of Raman, had Ishita questioning Adi's mother in jail, and today showed Mani denying Ishita motherhood of Aliya.

LIke you if the precap is just limited to the blame game in Ruhi's death - it's not as bad as questioning her motherhood.

It's actually interesting though b/c in society typically kids are identified by their mothers. This show does it the other way. However I will say outside of today's episodes YHM often has it's characters - Raman, Ishita, Shagun, etc - say my kids & everyone takes it one way or the other. Today it was clearly intentional but this idea of possessiveness over kids is often tossed around lightly and choppily on the show over the last year.

Honestly there is no clear message on motherhood here. Shagun's rights as a mother to Adi & Ruhi have essentially been stripped away to this day and rightfully so. Ishita's actions are regularly questioned. So who or what is a real mother to this show?

The only thing good I have seen post leap about this topic - is prior to the reveal, Raman praised Ishita's 1.5 year long upbringing of Adi. He didn't take Ishita's name, nor did he state Adi's blood mother had a positive impact on Adi...all he said is Adi's deceased mom left a positive mark on Adi through her motherhood.

And the one ray of hope is that relationships are still made of the heart is the kids themselves. Adi still views Ishita as his mother and gives her that place. I am sure Aliya will do the same. Pihu will eventually come around to Ishita but she also did give Shagun a chance to fix her mistake with Adi/Ruhi (even if one hates the character - she is for now a better person than before).

There is no honest end-game to this stuff nor is there a real reason for turning this into a freak-show...🤔

Sorry for the disconnected stuff - but honestly I don't get this show's view on motherhood or their original idea of nature versus nurture (especially now with Pihu in the mix who has Shagun's nurture but Ishita's nature), or if they are trying to uplift or turn people away from the idea of step-mothers. 🤓 Drama ke liye kuch bhi
Edited by -K.13- - 9 years ago
varunike thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
absolutely...
i think we definitely need one break out of Ishitha on this where she questions everybody on this.. she needs to ask them for answers for doubting her everytime..


nitii-76 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
U wrote it down perfect..damn these Cv's...I honestly felt very bad for Ishita..the women who gave immense love to everyone doesn't get what she deserves..the show once we all admired is just being ruined sadly...yet I'm happy that atleast Adi prooves to be a gem..and I fear how Ruhi is gonna behave with ishita..I'm sure this will kill her in real...she can withstand Raman's anger now but not Ruhi's hate for her
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Also it's incredibly sad but in most Desi shows you always see bahu and/or patni parikshas, but YHM outdoes everything and you see motherhood parikshas.

When will Indian TV ever get over this mentality of running women through the deepest of crap to "empower" them? It only belittles men and shackles women. 🤔

As Niddoo pointed out to me...YHM went from a show with a message to a show that took its original message of hope, second chances, and relationships of the heart and turned it into an impetus for drama
Edited by -K.13- - 9 years ago
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
Well, Ishita has no one but herself to blame for this. There are two proverbs in Hindi, "na ghar ke na ghaat ke"..." Dono nao mein pao daloge toh muh ke baal giroge", that depicts Ishita's current condition aptly. Mani and Raman don't give her credit because she didn't want to have the credit. Ishita's indecisive and impulsive actions are her worst enemy just like Raman's impulsive words. Raman doesn't think before he speaks and Ishita doesn't think before she acts, that's why his words and her actions harm them immensely. It's Ishita's actions which make it look like she doesn't below anywhere and the blunder is made in order to fit her everywhere as per the specification of a jagat mata. That's why we see Raman giving her full credit as a mother but mouthing off harsh words realizing she's with someone else. There is nothing to discuss about Mani's pov because his existence in the show is very ridiculously unjustifiable from the very beginning. If there was a Mani who was Ishita's best friend/secret lover or what ever, then Ishita being rejected years after years due to her medical condition doesn't make sense. It either seriously weakens the core concept of the show or severely damages Mani's authenticity as Ishita's knight in shining armor.

Now coming back to the main story...when a thing is available to everyone, that thing belongs to everyone. One can't call it his/her own. Similarly, when a person gives motherly love to everyone, that person belongs to everyone, just like an aayaa or a jagatmata (whichever term you find appropriate). A mother is very different from all these...all of her motherly love is exclusively reserved for her children and she's very selfish too when it comes to her children. That's exactly what Ishita's creator Mrs Manju Kapoor portrayed her so in the novel...that's what made Ishita so special...NOT this Ishita. YHM CVs in order to make this Ishita some sort of daily soapish version of Mother Teresa overlooked the most important fact that this type of portrayal of Ishita killed her substance as a mother. If Manju Kapoor had seen this Ishita ( and Raman too), she surely would've had a heart attack! 😆 And she would have an English proverb as a piece of advice to this Ishita, "charity begins at home".

PS-- I know some (or many) will say Ishita was staying away from her children against her will but that's not true. There are two possible reasons--- 1) she was hurt by Raman's crass words and/or 2) she was in guilt trip due to Ruhi's death. These two reasons can justify her staying away from Raman but in no way can justify her to staying away from her children and depriving them from their rightful motherly love for years.
nitii-76 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
🥱
Edited by nitii - 9 years ago
arooshee thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
Ishita was never a mother...to raman she was an aaya...his kids mom was always shagun...he treated her well bcoz she sacrificed her everything for the kids...the moment she did mistake she was verbally abused and literally kicked out of their lives...like firing an aaya from her job for her mistake and about mani...he considers ishu as third person un their lives...
Edited by arooshee - 9 years ago
-MS- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: nitii


Well u don't like her being the Jagatmata but u also don't agree when she did something out of guilt or for herself or whatever ..😆


When your mother would say she left you out of guilt trip or being jagatmata or for herself or whatever, you certainly would like it...😆
shivangi838 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
true yaar i hated ishu's situation in the ps...torn between 2 men and their children...made 2 feel dat she is NOT their real mother😭😭...i hated it...damn these cvs and their ghatiya soch😡🤢

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan · 4 months ago

Yeh Hai Mohabbatein fame Shireen Mirza announces pregnancy Yeh Hai Mohabbatein fame Shireen Mirza announces pregnancy with husband Hasan Sartaj;...

Expand â–¼
Ye Hai Mohabbatein thumbnail

Posted by: serendipity. · 10 years ago

Y e H ai M ohabbatein CREATIONS GALLERY. Have Signatures/Avis and Icons you want to share? Then post it here right away and get all the likes

Expand â–¼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".