GirlOfFire thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Its a pity that we dont have a regional thread on IF to discuss the current soaps.
One of them is Bojhena se Bojhena - the Bengali version of Iss Pyaar ko Kya Naam Doon? currently playing on Star Jalsa - the Bengali Star channel. Alongside it are a few more Bengali versions of popular Hindi dramas - Tomay Amay Miley (Diya aur Baati Hum), Mone Niye Kachcha Kachi (Yeh Hai Mohabbatein) and Bodhuboron (Saathiya).

Of these four, Not surprisingly - BSB has become the top rated show. Of course, the hero is ASR (in this case - Aranya Singha Roy) and the heroine is Pakhi Ghosh Dasatidar. The show debuted in November of 2013 - if I am not mistaken. And its still running today. How? you ask?

The show began as an almost frame by frame remake of IPKKND. But come the kidnap track - and things started changing.

What bothered me most is that the remake has changed the character of ASR - someone we all loved so much. In the famous bridge scene - he actually slaps Khushi!! I was horrified. Never would the ASR we know have raised his hand to Khushi - he couldn't bear to hurt her.

😭

And then the changes came fast and quick. Krishnendu (Shyam) was "killed off" - only to return in cahoots with Pamela (Lavanya) to try to kill the two of them. The contract marriage saw a public unveiling and I was left wondering if I was watching the same show or not.

And I finally let go trying to make sense of this new show - for that is what it has become.

Am I glad I did? Yes of course. Because in the last few days - the show has begun taking twists and turns that - hmmm... how should I put it ... would satisfy Ms Gul Khan or the fans - depending on how you look at it.

The mom back story is gone - wonder why ASR is so kadoos then?

Dadiji is a no-show.

Harry (NK) has a girlfriend that he is going to marry - who happens to be a cousin of the Gupta sisters.

Akki (Akash) has a much bigger role to play and he does it well!

Anjali found out all by. herself how bad a person Shyam was and publicly had him arrested (yay!! didn't we all want that?) Now she's getting on with her life. Baby bump be damned - who knows what happened to it.

ASR and Pakhi (Khushi) are getting married - yes, its a second marriage

And Krishnendu (Shyam) comes to grovel at his feet and beg forgiveness.

Then he gets shot.

And so does ASR - and falls into the river. So either they'll get a new ASR (though now that the negotiations are complete, the actor is coming back) - or he gets to come back from the dead.

Pakhi (Khushi) of course is devastated. So now... ladies...

Shall we guess how ASR will make his reappearance?

a) amnesia> - favourite device of all writers - they have people with lost memories running rampant in the other shows - why not this one as well?
b) in a coma - oh how many wanted this outcome?
c) in a double role - as ASR - but another ASR altogether - long lost brother maybe?

I'd love to hear how the other languages are handling it. Are there other versions? Let me know, please.

Meantime - enjoy... the new and "improved" IPKKND



Edited by GirlOfFire - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

2.7k

Users

5

Likes

16

Frequent Posters

h-arshi89 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
nice post...u added humor with news about Bengali IPK.
but can I comment here?
coz some days back some one posted that so called ASR of BSB is leaving. I commented there. she replied not to continue the discussion further, as this is IPK forum. but our show got ended long back! so these kind of discussions about IPK dubs and remakes can keep the forum alive (sorry! If it is against IF rules)
I thought the bengali version is good. I read its story in hot star.
ofcourse some of the things are better right! like better akash-payal story, NK finding his lady love.
but I really don't know there are so many loop holes.
no dadi, no past links, return of lavanya in a negative role are really no that interesting.
but arnav slapping khushi...🤢 that's so horrible.
how can he repent that, he can never cause such pain to khushi. it hurts him more than her.
gmsk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Its nice and interesting thread..

As much as i am super duper happy to see the success of ipk remake of Bengali version and the new story line after contract marriage they are showing, I being a very sensitive ipk fan would not have approved some scenes of the remake version and would still prefer the original over anything and everything IF i compare some scenes with BSB.
Audience would love to watch and anticipate ASR being dying track n all but I as a FAN would have broken down if something like this would hve happened in the original show.The thought it self can literally make me shiver..
And original ASR was a World call #$&*& but was not a monster to physically harm khushi in anyways.Again a big reason why i loved original more..
But there is no denying that the other aspects like sham,lavanya n dii tracks in BSB are gripping , would have loved if something like this would have happened in original ipk too BUT again these are secondary stuffs to me..

So i guess for me original ipk was better when it comes to ARSHI track ( minus no proper redemption shown) as COMPARED with other remakes of the show BUT
if i look at other tracks beside arshi then undoubtedly BSB is more interesting..


PS: M soo glad to see your post in IPK forum after such long time :)
Edited by gmsk - 10 years ago
h-arshi89 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
yeah...definitely there were things, that were deliberately neglected in the original show.
its not like abrupt end to the show was the reason.
the time from the end of the kidnapping track to the completion of the show could have been used very intelligently.
they wasted time in showing crying Anjali, most horrible sheetal, arav.
they would have shown a small, sweet and simple redemption track (the apology scene was too small and simple), closing the loop holes like shashi's paralysis etc.
akash-payal track faced the biggest humiliation in the hands of IPK's writers. that bubbly non-sense. akash's character was completely butchered. they would have shown that nicely.
1288765 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
God, this version seems like a complete rip off and I would not be able to handle that crap!! No offence to fans of the show, but honestly calling sh!t like that IPKKND is seriously wrong!! I wouldn't be ab,e to watch a remake anyway without Barun, Sanaya and the rest of the IPK gang, sorry people!!!
sadhnasoumya thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6
Thank god I m not watching any regional version
No one can beat our original ipk

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

1 months ago

#IPKKND/ArShi Poolside Moments/A splishin&splashin’/ I hate you/page 1

A splishin’ and a splashin’! A little bit of pool time is among the unforgettable ones Entangled meetings straight from Kisses to heartbreaks By...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

6 years ago

\\#IPKKND Rewind// "You're mine" / Episode 300 plus

I welcome you with my open heart Because you are my light, my sunshine I don't give a damn of right or wrong With this promise, I"l make you...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

1 years ago

#IPKKND/ Arshi Teri Meri Special/13th Anniversary/ Page 32/2025

Disclaimer : All images and writing belong to Mysticaldivine. Do not use without permission... 12 Years of Teri Meri Kahani 💕 Does she know I...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

3 years ago

#IPKKND/ArShi Poolside Moments/A splishin&splashin’!/NEW post p123

A splishin’ and a splashin’! A little bit of pool time is among the unforgettable ones Entangled meetings straight from Kisses to heartbreaks By...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

4 years ago

ll Power of Love ❤ ll.Decade of IPKKND./And They kissed../pg 27/Feb14

POST 2 I feel your warm gentle touch, laying under stars You help me feel protected, removing my scars Under the sweet night sky rush. this...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".