Lie to Truth- Mr. Shaad Aftab Khan aka The Lier

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

JazzyM

@JazzyM

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#11

however, hasn't Shaad been a gentleman so far?

Quote

Anisa

@AnnzSageflower7

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: TheImbecile

Isn't he an army guy obsessed with tracking SK? Minute details like that don't just get side-swept by a person who is a trained observer.

The fact that she knows so much about IM and Aahil is clue enough for him. Forget that, did he forget that she once said I love you Aahil? If it didn't click with him at the beginning when he met Aahil, perhaps when she knows all these minute details about Aahil, gets bothered by his very presence, and wants to push their wedding date within 7 days should be enough.

He may have gotten upset over the fact that she knows this stuff, but honestly how is it possible for him to not connect the dots when his mission entails him to be a trained observer!

Exactly the point!

He doesn't care about her ;

1. her past,

2. her (brief) restlessness about not knowing the past,

3. what she wants (to find her family and er, past? ) ,

4. the way she lives her life on pause just waiting for memories to return (evidenced by her keeping distance from husband)

5. Her pesky dejavu and memories bursting through to present.

All he wants is to marry her, because he loves her .

He's not bothered about her hesitation, the fact that she took so long to decide she would marry him again .

Yes, she did say she loved him , didn't she?

Again somebody else's fault (everything in place to make him look good.)

Btw, when is it proper to get married at the expense of a newly acquainted friend? What kind of a man gets married at the expense of a friend? Ugh.

Let's not even get started with the lies he will tell when the Maulvi asks what her family name is.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Mandy

@MrDarcyfan

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 10 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: JazzyM
however, hasn't Shaad been a gentleman so far?

Does a gentlemen cup a strange girl's face all the time, touch her and hug her constantly when he knows he doesn't even know her real name, leave alone being her husband? They even shot a scene where this so called "gentlemen" did up the blouse hooks of a women he met 2 days before, who was exposing her entire back and stomach to him, coz she though he was her "husband?"Those are the actions of a gentleman? (Just as well they didn't air the scene, or it would be a lot harder to pretend the way he has behaved is "gentlemanly"). He took advantage of her delusion of being his "wife" to continue to get in her personal space. He used to sit on her bed constantly and hold her hand etc. Would a women let a complete stranger do all that? Let's not pretend that she would!

I have said it before and I will say it again, I don't know what the definition of a "gentlemen" is in the mind's of people...but for ME, a gentlemen does not invade a strange women's personal space and take advantage of her memory loss to trap her into staying in his life! He does not close off her missing file, so she has NO option, but to stay trapped with him! In MY book, this is not the definition of a gentleman's actions! REHAN was a gentlemen. Shaad is not! Even Aahil who was shown as a player, didn't come close to Sanam even after she was his wife, until she showed him she wanted him to. So on that score, even he has been more of a gentlemen than Shaad has been with a complete stranger he was lying to.

For TM: No he will NEVER pay for the things he did. They have spent all their time trying to dry clean him and bleach him. Will they let ALL that effort go to waste? 🤢

@Sage: Ani, you have explained away everything Shaad has done. But you forgot to mention one thing. He only let the LIE of being her husband stand, when the doctor told him that regaining her memory may make her forget all that she witnessed in the riots! He feared her forgetting seeing his friend being murdered by SK, THAT is why he continued to act as her husband and had no option but to take her to his house. Coz he was not going to hand her to authorities. So she had to go to his house and then what she did was what he brought on himself. Even THEN he had a chance to tell the truth, but he did not. Not clarifying the truth was HIS decision. (Coz his case was more important to him than the promise he made to his aunt and Father). So anything that comes with it, he should wear. He has had no conscience about trapping a stranger, and even after knowing she had a man in her life, whom she loved (Which he acknowledged to himself in a monologue), he thought he had the right to keep her from him! He deserves to be punished and I am sorry he will not be!

Edited by MrDarcyfan - 10 years ago

Quote

Anisa

@AnnzSageflower7

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#14

HI Mandy!

I haven't explained away his misdeeds. All I'm pointing out is how he will be construed as a misunderstood good guy as per f 32 hints we've been getting.

Maybe if we debate this hard enough , they might feel inspired enough to make Shaad less pale and cowardly and the outright baddie he should be.

If the character was played by a slimy greasy looking guy (like Vikram Shukla of season1) , he'd be a baddie already no?

Edited by sageflower7 - 10 years ago

Quote

Ankudi15

@Ankudi15

Navigator

Posted: 10 years ago

#15

Tthe cvs have been trying to PRETEND since the beginning of his entry that he was led into such circumstances by fate
...WHICH WE CANNOT BUY...due to his continuous lies to her

I have nothing to say about shaad cozi have been ranting about him since past three months

i dont care they show him negative or positive...(coz i know they wont and they
are actuaally mocking and teasing us thru promo)
Gul has a habit of dumbing leads in front of every other character like aahil in front of tanveer ,jannat and aahil in front of shady ,sanam amd aahil in front of witch but the fact is the way everything is executed to connect and believe the happenings and characters reaction to situation is not digestable

Quote

simran_singh_24

@simran_singh_24

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#16

Shaad will never be shown as negative.

He is the poor,honest,dedicated career soldier who got tangled with a big eyed brainless doll and her charms and the ploys of her enemies and the international terrorists.

We see him making choices that are criminal acts and seethe, the Cvs see him as a victim of circumstances. They'll continue to create circumstances and paint other characters darker,cheaper(S2) and wimpier (Ahil,SK) and hormonal(Sanam) to make him come out of this crap as a victim who lost his love & did his best for her.

He was shown in the 4L's patented dargah scene, there's no way he'll be acknowledged as a villain.

Zee & 4L will continue to cheat us with promos.

Quote

Rashmi

@Intuitive

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: LoveSonu2408
same here rashmi...awsm post.u said it all.& i hv also two mind.one time it seems finaly shaad will shw his true colours & keep his lying to jannat & eitherwy i think it will shw the 'mahan' guy is trapped...i really wish ahil shw him his asliyat...lk he gv bk s2-full jj...
as for sanam its time to get her memory bk & my main concern is 4 sanam...wht will she do??i dnt want she accept ahil bcz she is told tht she is sanam...i wnt she feel all the connections & also get her memory...usse ye ahsas hona chahiye ki wo kaisi thi,kya thi,kya maine rakhta hai,usne kya galati ki hai...i dnt want her to be again detective mode...whr she will b used by sk.s2.razia...

pl cv's eid se pehele clear ths memory mess & unite sahil thn whtever twist u wnt 2 shw,jst keep SAHIL TOGETHER to fight with all odds...it is the power of true love ...

Thank You!

Same here-two minds! Lets just what they do!

Aahil should get his Sanam back, not the dumb! I want a slow transformation from Jannat to Sanam.

Quote

Rashmi

@Intuitive

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: sageflower7
Good post!
One thing worries me though. ..

It annoys me that the fact remains that he might just get away with his lie.

See, it was a lie he told to get rid of the angry mob that was after her. He actually walked away from her but she followed him like a lost lamb. She kept insisting that she was the Jannat he claimed and he couldn't explain away his lie to her then.

So he took her to his house, small inconvenience being his wedding was happening that day. He stashed her away in a room and went to get married.

It was Jannat who wandered out and mingled with wedding guests and relatives, acting like she was the Bahu of the house.

Then she changed into fancy clothes of relatives and found the wedding card. She thought her husband was marrying another woman !!!

In full flight she screeched and stopped the wedding, revealing to EVERYONE who had half hearing that SHE WAS HIS WIFE, JANNAT !!

Something he had never wanted to tell anyone. But then she told his whole family and community that she was his wife and he HAD to keep the pretences ...

Poor Shaad.

Then he took her to the doctor. Who said that she needs to be protected from emotional trauma, hence the lie had to be continued. Right?

Then his whole family got killed and he found himself alone in life except for the girl he inadvertently fell in love with. Someone he began to feel he had needed now in his life after that snake bite rescue.

Missing person report cancelled ... (i know the order is the other way but nevermind)

He convinced himself that he was enough for her. And he'd keep her safe and happy.

Then is the pesky problem of her emerging memories. He cleverly dismisses them and she keeps quiet. No initiative on her part to find out about herself. If she doesn't , why should he?

Then Aahil himself appears and subversively brings out MORE memories in her.
And Jannat keeps forgetting whose wife she was anymore. 😉

So he writes a letter explaining his lie: as though he made a small mistake that became a big problem. And she appears to have forgiven him of it. And said yes to marry him. .

He doesn't know that Sanam2 has exchanged her letter with a different one.

See how someone else is to blame for everything?

The lie : rioters fault and propagated by Jannat's drama at wedding. Extra lies were made when she asked for details of marriage in front of people.

The confession of lie : foiled by Sanam2 , as far as he's concerned he confessed.

Only thing he's guilty of himself was closing the missing persons report & not being responsible of taking care of an amnesiac patient with medical care.

And of course falling in love with another man's wife.

Yeah, he'll get away scot free...

Thanks Sage!

It is as if Shaad is a lord and he can do anything on this Earth not asking the other person with whose life he is playing with! They are just blaming others and dumbing down other characters.

Every action of his is not counted. This Season3 doesnt seem for Amara who didnt want to play a madwoman but for whitewashing Shaad and making wrong as right and they forgotten changing morals isn't accepted!🤢

Quote

Rashmi

@Intuitive

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: flora212
You can't blame others for Shaad's lie Sagey! 😆 ^ the fact is he is not only lier but delusional too! He could have easily tell his lies but he didn't! Okay fine he could have keep himself away from herself but he still didn't! He knew that she had someone but he was busy day dreaming! And even if he thinks she read the letter which man on earth can be so dumb that didn't even realise she didn't read the letter! It was so obvious from the reply Jannat gave to Shaddy regarding the letter! And then again he is not even curious to know who she is in real! And Lastly he is so lame and spineless! He is conveying the truth to Jannat through a LETTER? SERIOUSLY A LETTER! OH PLEASE GIVE ME A BREAK! HIS ACTIONS COMPLETELY INDICATES TOWARDS NEGATIVITY!
Oh wait one more thing he decided to tell her the truth (in lame way) only when he proposed her for remarriage and she said yes to it! Isn't it pretty much a calculative move!

It all seems so lame!They seem to take everything as a joke! Every action(ofcousre bad) are just ignored! Then why even make a character and this all can be justified by a letter! Anybody will laugh if we say all this can be excused! He should be jailed and a letter is enough🤢

Quote

Rashmi

@Intuitive

Sparkler

Posted: 10 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: sageflower7

He is not worried about her feelings. . She keeps flying into his arms, frets about his health and when he's hurt. And he's a "tough handsome army guy " What's there not to fall for?

But you're right, he waited till she Said she'd marry him first, then he confessed the lie.

Why, if she said no? What would he have done then?

I mean, how awkward is it when "your wife" has to think whether she wants to remarry you again?

I mean, lots of wives may rethink their options if they had their chance🤣 but here? If she said no, would he have let her go? Or would she have let him, let her go.

The whole situation was silly .

Nothing that this soap shows is even in the inch similar to reality! It's all a fantasy where they can play as they wish! But, the fantasy is too horrible to watch!

And the TRP is the answer! Hope the cvs realise this soon, otherwise this show would be dead, it would already be dead if Kv wasnt there.