WU 29/3/13 Dinner date amidst old memories!!! - Page 8

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Anita - Thanks for the update😊

I have already thanked for the update.

I got sidetracked in my previous post while trying to decipher the JAAN and completely forgot to mention my take on the episode.😆

Singhs wanting to spend some quality time with A before she left Jaitsar was a very understandable.

But they could informed J of their plans.J would have prepared himself to face the situation.

Coming to Ganga - Sometimes she takes too much of liberty.She is just an outsider.They may have given her the background details.No one has actually discussed the relationship they have with Anandi.

Only J had discussed his relationship with A with her.But that still does not give her the right to question A why she is not preparing J's favourite dish.I think she was way out of line when she questioned A on that.

Shiv hugging J is really not needed.Understand he feels bad for J but still there are otherways to convey his empathy.😆But I guess this was to show how different Shiv is when compared with Gauri.

As for the AnSh scene.It was a nice scene.I wish they made it a little more lively.The bunny scene need not have been there.As for J rushing to terrace to witness their interaction is a much needed reality check for J.

He may know that S is the right man for A and he has lost A for ever but he still cannot help feeling the way he does about her.

This is battle between his resolve to move on in life and his desire to cling on to his memories and his weakness for A

I guess this scene was meant to tell what all thing he needs to fight when he is moving on life.

As for the scene with the family and A - This I guess is to make T connect with Anandi.

But I wish they made similar efforts to connect her with grown up Anandi too not just the child Anandi.

Shanky's performance was good and he was bang on with his expressions.

Toral is improving but lot more is needed from her side to make Anandi look convincing.

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Anita - Thanks for the update😊

I have already thanked for the update.

I got sidetracked in my previous post while trying to decipher the JAAN and completely forgot to mention my take on the episode.😆

Singhs wanting to spend some quality time with A before she left Jaitsar was a very understandable.

But they could informed J of their plans.J would have prepared himself to face the situation.

Coming to Ganga - Sometimes she takes too much of liberty.She is just an outsider.They may have given her the background details.No one has actually discussed the relationship they have with Anandi.

Only J had discussed his relationship with A with her.But that still does not give her the right to question A why she is not preparing J's favourite dish.I think she was way out of line when she questioned A on that.

Shiv hugging J is really not needed.Understand he feels bad for J but still there are otherways to convey his empathy.😆But I guess this was to show how different Shiv is when compared with Gauri.

As for the AnSh scene.It was a nice scene.I wish they made it a little more lively.The bunny scene need not have been there.As for J rushing to terrace to witness their interaction is a much needed reality check for J.

He may know that S is the right man for A and he has lost A for ever but he still cannot help feeling the way he does about her.

This is battle between his resolve to move on in life and his desire to cling on to his memories and his weakness for A

I guess this scene was meant to tell what all thing he needs to fight when he is moving on life.

As for the scene with the family and A - This I guess is to make T connect with Anandi.

But I wish they made similar efforts to connect her with grown up Anandi too not just the child Anandi.

Shanky's performance was good and he was bang on with his expressions.

Toral is improving but lot more is needed from her side to make Anandi look convincing.

Originally posted by: vidya0000

I read ur previous post in this w/u. Perfect analysis.
@bold This is an indication to the viewers that anandi is finally and completely moved on. The third person only can raise that question to A. In the singh's family only ganga is an outsider.

Originally posted by: aparnauma

A has moved on as far as J is concerned.But she is part of Singh family.Her place in the family is very much similar to thta of Suguna but it is special because it is a relationship that changed it's nature.Ganga is an outsider.

Ganga still has no right to question A.I do not think anyone has given her the right to question A on her relationship with J.I don't think even J has given Ganga that right to question A.

She may be a friend of J but still she crossed a line here.

Originally posted by: mahi12

but Sugna here would have cooked food for Jagaya hasn't she 😆The family is one they cannot be divided in two parts for Anandi and Jagaya here where both of them are strangers to each other so in my view Ganga only asked from Anandi because she was being considerate to Jagaya here he would join dinner as well but nothing for him and secondly she wanted to know Anandi's reaction about what Jagaya said to Anandi recently has it changed their relation did it affect it because when she came to home , they were being friends , perfectly comfortable in each other's company if Anandi hasn't come to lecture Jagaya , her lecture wouldn't have forced those words out of Jagaya's mouth today i believe Anandi would have cooked his favorite meal so Ganga only wanted to know the recent incident did it change their relation from the one she saw and she was thinking about her dactaar saa nothing for him

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Mahi - I think A would have gotten into trouble if she cooked for him and she would get into trouble if she did not.That is between Singh Parivar and A and how they handle it.DS obviously did not want A to cook for him that too after knowing how J still feels about A.It was right on A's part on not wanting to cook for J.

But the issue here is whether it was right on Ganga's part to question A.

Why should A tell Ganga what her reaction to J's declaration is?Who is Ganga to A?

Ganga has no right to ask the question.

Ganga is an outsider as far as Singh Parivar is concerned and as far as JA relationship equation is concerned.

Originally posted by: aparnauma

A has moved on as far as J is concerned.But she is part of Singh family.Her place in the family is very much similar to thta of Suguna but it is special because it is a relationship that changed it's nature.Ganga is an outsider.

Ganga still has no right to question A.I do not think anyone has given her the right to question A on her relationship with J.I don't think even J has given Ganga that right to question A.

She may be a friend of J but still she crossed a line here.