zandu37 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
I do not think there has been any show on Indian television that even attempts to look at the subtle nuances of stepfather-son insecurities and the Oedipus complex that Addu is presently going through. As per Freud's psychoanalytical theory all young boys (esp in the 4-7 age group) have a latent but strong possessiveness for their mothers and resent their fathers getting too close to their mothers. For Addu its a triple whammy as Mohan is also a step father who has suddenly come between him and his mother plus he has also completely won over Nanhi's affection and attention as well. So obviously when young Addu sees two of the most important women in his life showing a distinct fondness for Mohan, his subconscious insecurities are bound to surface. This has to be treated very very carefully by MM as this can either lead to Addu becoming overdependent on Megha ( to grow up as a cry baby mama's boy) or intensely hating Mohan (to grow up as a rebel father hater). According to Freud the affiliation and bonding with the same sex parent can lead to the resolution of the Oedipus complex and that's where Mohan needs to work hard and be extra sensitive and careful.

I do hope NBT takes the opportunity to explore, unravel and resolve the subtle nuances of father - son bonding which can be so endearing. The other interesting bit which one saw developing in the last episode is that the current behaviour of Addu is reminiscent of Mohan's own behaviour with his father when he was young. Possibly Mr Bhatnagar Sr did not have the patience or time (despite being a biological father) to resolve his son's insecurities which is why Mohan grew up as a rebel father hater. So while tackling the Addu issue, Mohan will be forced to introspect his own childhood and analyze the situation from a father's perspective which he never would have done before. It could possibly lead to some sort of catharsis and resolution of his own relationship with his father which has deteriorated over the years. It would be lovely if NBT could show Oedipus Addu not only resolving his own insecurities but also bridging the gap between Mohan and his father and in turn create a healthy father - son relationship across 3 generations.

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.3k

Users

10

Likes

47

Frequent Posters

Reena4kunal thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
Hey very nice post..well connected and analysed👏
sitamma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

I am Addu'''.I am so unhappy with everyone now'


I don't remember my papa much..these days..but he was the best..And I hate that I have to call that lallu Spiderman as papa.

Initially it was just Nanhi who was friends with him..I don't know what she sees in him..ucch!! Spiderman..He is no Spiderman..He is a monkey man'!!! Ever since he came, Nanhi spends as much as possible with him only'.and he is good to her only'Chavanni is such a nice name..but he calls me piddy..which is a yuckee name..and in spite of me telling him repeatedly not to call me that he does that only..I hate it''

And then suddenly what happened to mummy? She also started becoming friends with Nanhi's stupid Spiderman.!! And for a while I was glad that Manav uncle was going to be my new papa..he used to care for me..more than he cared for Nanhi'..

But then again this Spiderman came jutting in and mummy decided to marry him'I have never liked that and I will never like it as well'Though mummy promised me that she loves me more than she loves Spiderman..i don't believe it..Because whenever I fight with Spiderman, she scolds me and not him'..

And why are they holding hands and touching each other? I hate to see him touching my mummy'

And mummy is lying when she says Spiderman loves me also..I know he does not love me at all'.he is so loving to Nanhi..but to me..he has never hugged me, has always irritated me calling me piddy, he makes faces at me'..and acts as if I am troubling him..when in fact he is the one who troubles me'

And I only broke the Dahi handi..not him..he carried me on his shoulders..it was because he wanted to break the handi himself he climbed up to do that..but I beat him to that and broke the handi myself..!!!!!

I hate Spiderman..Nanhi's Spiderman..And he is never my Spiderman..he loves only Nanhi and mummy'And I hate him for that..


This is Addu's version of what he feels about Spiderman as of now..

rest asap..

Edited by sitamma - 14 years ago
Senpoo thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Very well written with details well captured on an area which is mostly unexplored! Yes, Mohan will have to move ahead carefully with lot of patience and ofcourse in his own style, so that Addu gets attached to him! May be Mohan cool style might require to be continued 'cos Addu too has that and might like to be inspired by Mohan! Boys are boys! And who wudn't like to be cool like Mohan 😉
And If Mohan realizes the stand of his and Sr. Bhatnagar, then that wud be the best way to get thru the hearts of Induji as well! How much Mohan's mommy wud be happy to see her son trying to patch up her hubby! What else wud a mother want! 😊
sumiswap thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Very nice post. And very nicely analysed. Mohan Addu track has a lot of potential to resolve a lot of issues that Mohan himself has with his dad and this track also has a lot of potential to get some of our old NBT charm back. I am already loving the chemistry between Mohan and Addu. But they should not side line Nanhi at this moment like they did with Addu earlier. That would be criminal!
adoremevirgo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
very well written post...yes...it cud work for mohan too...while trying to become a ideal papa for addu who shows the same kind of misgivings towards him as he himself showed to his dad can convert him too...

as u said he will get the opportunity to see from a father's perspective...i am looking forward to this mysterious mr. bhatnagar...
Moner_Radio thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
@ zandu :
very well written post. even i said the same some days back. and i'm waiting to see how they handle this immensely potential track. coz if handled well, it might even provide solutions to real life cases too.
Reena4kunal thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sitamma

I am Addu'''.I am so unhappy with everyone now'


I don't remember my papa much..these days..but he was the best..And I hate that I have to call that lallu Spiderman as papa.

Initially it was just Nanhi who was friends with him..I don't know what she sees in him..ucch!! Spiderman..He is no Spiderman..He is a monkey man'!!! Ever since he came, Nanhi spends as much as possible with him only'.and he is good to her only'Chavanni is such a nice name..but he calls me piddy..which is a yuckee name..and in spite of me telling him repeatedly not to call me that he does that only..I hate it''

And then suddenly what happened to mummy? She also started becoming friends with Nanhi's stupid Spiderman.!! And for a while I was glad that Manav uncle was going to be my new papa..he used to care for me..more than he cared for Nanhi'..

But then again this Spiderman came jutting in and mummy decided to marry him'I have never liked that and I will never like it as well'Though mummy promised me that she loves me more than she loves Spiderman..i don't believe it..Because whenever I fight with Spiderman, she scolds me and not him'..

And why are they holding hands and touching each other? I hate to see him touching my mummy'

And mummy is lying when she says Spiderman loves me also..I know he does not love me at all'.he is so loving to Nanhi..but to me..he has never hugged me, has always irritated me calling me piddy, he makes faces at me'..and acts as if I am troubling him..when in fact he is the one who troubles me'

And I only broke the Dahi handi..not him..he carried me on his shoulders..it was because he wanted to break the handi himself he climbed up to do that..but I beat him to that and broke the handi myself..!!!!!

I hate Spiderman..Nanhi's Spiderman..And he is never my Spiderman..he loves only Nanhi and mummy'And I hate him for that..


This is Addu's version of what he feels about Spiderman as of now..

rest asap..

Hahaha thoroughly enjoyable.Almost cud see and hear Addu speaking this out :)
kkkphile thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
your posts are always interesting and perceptive. always look forward to them :)
sitamma thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
Mohan's perspective of his relationship with Addu as of now.


Hai...Mein Mohan Batnagar.!!!!

My life is perfect these days...well near to perfect.Piddy and Riddima are preventing from making it perfect..

Riddima ka baath tho phir bhi teek hai. We have moved the papers for divorce..and Megha understands about it and has forgiven me..It is just a formality and signing of papers now..Still I wish it would be over soon so that I can be completely at peace.

But this Piddy na,sach mein I don't know what to do about him... He is a real handful..I never thought he will be so difficult to handle.!!!

Right from the beginning I have not been able to get along with this piddy... He is so rude..and impolite...

He damaged my bike seat so badly and could not even apologize.

While we were at the farm house..he blackmailed me like anything..such a small kid ..and black mail well, I felt like slapping him..but held my peace because others were also there.

And when Manav was here, he was so rude to me...he refused my gifts and ridiculed me in front of everyone.

And I was the one who took him to see jalak, I was the one who offered to give him a lift ..He got down from the bike without telling me..and then when I finally found him and saved him from those boys, instead of thanking me he was rude to me..

And I feel he is a spoiled brat ...though I don't want to hurt Megha's sentiments by telling her so..But this Piddy is becoming more and more horrible with each passing day..

I am reminded of my days with my father during my childhood..I hate to remember it..But eh Piddy na...he makes me remember it!!

Why can't he be like Nanhi? I sometimes wonder whether he is really Megha's son ? On second thoughts he resembles Megha a lot..Mirchi madam was also like this initially...

But this Piddy...I wish I could throw him into a dust bin.!!!!

On a serious note, I think I should make more serious effort to win him over..Though it is so difficult to do so...Mohan Batnagar..chalo..eh hai tera naya mission..patao piddy..oops..patao Addu

Mohan beta, tera band bajnewala hai.!!!!

And Mr Batnagar...don't you dare to come into my thoughts like you did the other day when Piddy..oops..Addu did that drama with the food..!!!

Next comes what we think about how Mohan should handle Addu.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".