The Dirty Picture vs Heroine - Page 2

Agreed. Heroine trailer was NOT as gripping as TDP.

exactly even fashion's trailer was much better...here its all kareena only...there are much better actors than kareena like Govind NAmdeo, and Shahana Goswami and they get nothing in the trailer. and i guess this is the reason the trailer has got the mixed response. but i think it will get better in the NEXT TRAILER HOPEFULLY !

Originally posted by: Nitu_TheTwisted

exactly even fashion's trailer was much better...here its all kareena only...there are much better actors than kareena like Govind NAmdeo, and Shahana Goswami and they get nothing in the trailer. and i guess this is the reason the trailer has got the mixed response. but i think it will get better in the NEXT TRAILER HOPEFULLY !

its really funny that Youtube has been mocked everyday on websites for its cliched presentations and video layouts. If a movie premiere comes out on YouTube, people get really annoyed ' kya yaar eski paas paise nahi to youtube par release kar di movie' examples - striker and Johnny mera naam.

Well sure, you can then overlook youtube, but twitter trended with Kareena thrice this month.

Originally posted by: desigal90

ANd not necesarrily Eraser. Even today if Saat Khoon Maaf had released with THAT EXACT trailer, it would have flopped.

Its too dark for audiences. Its nothing about audiences being more open. Nothing's changed in that regard.

Wrap an actress up in a white saari in a dark trailer, and the masses will still turn the other way.

Originally posted by: desigal90

Agreed. Heroine trailer was NOT as gripping as TDP.

No arguments there.

TDP was very cleverly packaged and clearly outlined what to expect in the film. And like you said, introduced each principle character very clearly - Vidya, Naseeudin, Tushar, Emran.

Heroine's trailer is just KAREENA KAREENA KAREENA.

There is no introduction to Arjun, Randeep, Shahana Goswami, Mughda.

Its just Kareena Kapoor.

You're looking at it from the point of view of a Kareena fan,so the trailer attracts you,because you're happy to see just Kareena and nobody else in the trailer.But for others,the trailer just gives away the whole story of the film,which in turn gives them a Deja Vu of The Dirty Picture.If for example,only the trailer of TDP would have released,no one would compare both the films,because the trailer of TDP was packed in such a way that the story of the film wasn't revealed at all.Now that people have seen the film,especially the downfall of Silk,people think the trailer of Heroine bears resemblence to TDP,especially the concluding part,from where Kareena starts freaking out.I remember during TDP release,many people felt the conclusion of TDP was a lot like Fashion.

The thing I feel is wrong with the movie is,Madhur is trying to project Kareena as the Heroine in the same way he has projected Priyanka in Fashion or Milan has projected Vidya in TDP.Not all Heroines are so in your face,isn't it?If Madhur wouldn't have included those fiery dialogues like the one during the press meet or the ek randi ke chaar yaar one,and give a new dimension to the character of Kareena,it would be better.

Originally posted by: Nitu_TheTwisted

these are just speculations...

what we usually see, we react on those...when a film flops we take it like it had to flop. but sometimes films of the same genre can work well too.

SKM was itself a bad movie and Vishal himself admitted it...when people entered the hall they wanted to see something out of the box but what they saw was one woman killing her seven husbands..people were expecting a twist...also SKM never had a great musical score too...if i am wrong that how did Kaminey work wasn't it dark too...it had blockbuster music as well, shahid kapoor the flop actor, his career got a relief from this one.

IF SKM's WOM had been Good people have defintely turned up for it like KAHAANI,

and yeah coming to heroine i don't think anyone was expecting a dark and grim trailer...UTV motion pictures can't risk it again...but the trailer could have been better since mostly MADHUR'S movie trailers comes out the best of the year. Fashion's was really amazing

Originally posted by: .SB.

You're looking at it from the point of view of a Kareena fan,so the trailer attracts you,because you're happy to see just Kareena and nobody else in the trailer.But for others,the trailer just gives away the whole story of the film,which in turn gives them a Deja Vu of The Dirty Picture.If for example,only the trailer of TDP would have released,no one would compare both the films,because the trailer of TDP was packed in such a way that the story of the film wasn't revealed at all.Now that people have seen the film,especially the downfall of Silk,people think the trailer of Heroine bears resemblence to TDP,especially the concluding part,from where Kareena starts freaking out.I remember during TDP release,many people felt the conclusion of TDP was a lot like Fashion.

The thing I feel is wrong with the movie is,Madhur is trying to project Kareena as the Heroine in the same way he has projected Priyanka in Fashion or Milan has projected Vidya in TDP.Not all Heroines are so in your face,isn't it?If Madhur wouldn't have included those fiery dialogues like the one during the press meet or the ek randi ke chaar yaar one,and give a new dimension to the character of Kareena,it would be better.

Originally posted by: desigal90

But forget how the film itself was. I'm talking about the opening. The first day.

I mean, people barely bothered to go in and give the film a chance. It was a select sector that was pulled towards the dark, gritty theme.

The masses just ignored it. That's why the opening was so low. I'm not even talking about the content itself.