PLAYERS ( All Reviews Here ) - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

156

Views

18.7k

Users

46

Likes

86

Frequent Posters

DB_reloaded thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
twiiter goin gaga over players esp abhisekh
bigb has gone mad praising it left ri8 corner...>>>
fly2me thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Ehhh...Still debating on if i should go see it or not.
BlackStar. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13
Is this the official players review thread?
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

User Reviews
Critic Review
Players
By Taran Adarsh, 6 Jan 2012, 08:48 hrs IST
It's a given that hi-voltage action thrillers enthrall and electrify viewers no end. The existing inclination within the industry is to opt for remakes [of South Indian films specifically], though Abbas-Mustan have continuously, in their three decade career, tilted towards western thrillers to be specific. PLAYERS, their latest offering, is the official remake of THE ITALIAN JOB. But it's not a scene to scene adaptation of the classic that was attempted twice in the West. The core conception remains the same, but the screenplay is amended significantly to suit the Indian sensibilities.

A recreation or adaptation always leads to comparisons with the original work. And Abbas-Mustan will have to pass this acid test, since THE ITALIAN JOB is no regular film. Made twice in Hollywood [first in 1969 and then in 2003], THE ITALIAN JOB is a heist film with a variation. Like I pointed out earlier, PLAYERS is an altered version of THE ITALIAN JOB, catering more to the desi sensibilities. It's about a gang of skillful, stylish and sharp players who join hands to carry out a heist. Prepare yourself for a masala film with ample twists and turns, stunning and gorgeous locales, stylized stunts and adrenaline-pumping chases, lots of style and attitude and of course, the mandatory songs and comic sequences... In that respect, PLAYERS is in a completely different zone when one draws parallels with THE ITALIAN JOB.

One more clarification! When the promos of PLAYERS came on air, a lot of people felt that it seemed like an updated version of DHOOM. But let's spell this out at the very onset: There's no similitude between PLAYERS and DHOOM, apart from the fact that both belong to the action genre. DHOOM revolved around the cops-robbers face off, while the characters in PLAYERS are all thieves.

Adventure movies made in Bollywood, by and large, stress on modish imageries, while the actual concept takes a backseat. That's precisely the trouble with PLAYERS. While a one-page synopsis of the film would evoke euphoric and ecstatic reactions, it's the screenplay, with a running time of almost 2.45 hours [20 reels], that lacks the power to keep you enthralled and enchanted. In short, PLAYERS has style and attitude, but what it lacks is soul and spirit!

PLAYERS is about a team of skilled and sharp group of people -- Charlie [Abhishek Bachchan], Ronnie [Bobby Deol], Spider [Neil Nitin Mukesh], Riya [Bipasha Basu], Bilal [Sikander Kher] and Sunny [Omi Vaidya] -- who rob the gold bullion from Russia successfully. But one of them double crosses the players and the team sets out, with Naina [Sonam Kapoor] also included in their task now, to retrieve the booty and also settle scores.

First things first! PLAYERS is an escapist fare, packed with ingredients that are considered mandatory in a Bollywood film. So if you are under the impression that Abbas-Mustan may have shunned the commercial trappings since it is an official adaptation of THE ITALIAN JOB, you're mistaken. PLAYERS doesn't imagine itself to be cinema that educates, enlightens or mollifies an academician. Furthermore, Abbas-Mustan's movies are never simplistic by nature. There are twists at the start, twists in the middle and twists towards the finale and just when you think that the movie's about to conclude, the director duo usually toss yet another twist in your face, leaving you startled for a minute or two. PLAYERS stays true to their style, but the twists here aren't the type that shock, amaze or astonish. One of the twists -- about the double crosser -- does catch you by surprise, but the remaining ones don't and that's where the screenplay falters.

It's a screenplay of convenience. The manner in which the gang sets out to execute the heist in Russia seems like a cakewalk or child's play, which is so damn difficult to absorb. Common guys, you are talking of robbing a nation's assets in broad daylight and the convenience with which things fall into place makes the entire heist phony and fake. Ditto towards the finale, when the chase ensues. Though the train robbery [in the first hour] and the chase sequence [climax] leave you awe-struck, the approach with which the gang sets out to achieve the goal is what appears counterfeit. In fact, given the genre of the film [a hi-octane thriller], one would've expected the writers to integrate a dash of realism in the plot for the goings-on to look plausible and credible, but the haphazard screenplay and the excessive length only dilutes the impact generated by some wonderful moments that PLAYERS has to offer.

It is accepted that Abbas-Mustan are forward-thinking directors. Not only do they opt for varied plots for their films, but also think out of the box when it comes to execution of the written material. Irrespective of how their films are received at the ticket window, you cannot turn a blind eye to the fact that they never pursue the trodden trail. But it's the screenplay that lets them down this time. Since a large part of the movie involves action and chase sequences [Allan Amin], the amalgamation of thrills and daredevil stunts keeps you on the edge. Also, the scale of the film is overwhelming. Filmed at the panoramic locales of Russia, Netherlands, New Zealand and of course, India, the DoP [Ravi Yadav] bestows the film with an international look. In fact, it's an incredibly good looking film!

Pritam's music is, to put it bluntly, a minus point. One misses a captivating soundtrack here. The music is deficient of the dynamism and passion that one witnessed in Pritam's preceding works in this variety [DHOOM, DHOOM 2 and RACE].

ZAMEEN was the first movie wherein Abhishek Bachchan's characteristic macho style was detected by the spectators. Movies like DHOOM, DUS, BLUFFMASTER and last year's DUM MAARO DUM strengthened his image further. The actor flaunts his popular style and attitude with panache in PLAYERS. Bobby Deol is wasted. Seriously, why is he sidelined in the plot? Bipasha enacts the role of a con artiste with super confidence. She looks fab and emotes with conviction. It's an image transformation for Sonam in PLAYERS. She has never done a full-on glamorous role before and PLAYERS should change the perception. However, the rawness, as an actor, shows in a variety of scenes.

Neil Nitin Mukesh is entrusted with a challenging role, but he lacks the charisma and skill to carry off the part with dexterity. Sikander Kher has an insignificant role. As for Omi Vaidya, the less said the better. He irritates and hams incessantly. Vinod Khanna is not in his element either. Johny Lever is hilarious as the car dealer. Aftab Shivdasani appears in a cameo.

On the whole, PLAYERS rides mainly on the clout of its credible director duo [Abbas-Mustan], daredevil stunts and stunning visuals. But, most importantly, it is deficient of a captivating screenplay. Also, the film could have done with judicious trimming for an enhanced impact. I for one went in with colossal expectations, but came out feeling downcast and disheartened.
Edited by you2 - 13 years ago
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#15


1 3

Hindi, Action, Thriller, 2012, Color




Synopsis

Charlie Masceranhas (Abhishek Bachchan) is a chartered accountant by day and a master-thief by night. With the help of his hero and role model, Victor Dada (Vinod Khanna), who is in jail, Charlie assembles a team of 'player's to steal a large consignment of gold from a moving Russian train...


Upperstall Review

There is a particular sequence of events in this film that encapsulates everything this 'Abbas-Mustan style action-thriller' stands for. So our kewl gang of players must steal tons of gold from a moving Russian train. Charlie (Abhishek), born leader that he is, masterminds this effort: He uses a mask and impersonates the Russian head-of-security, prior to the train journey. Needless to say, the real chief has been gotten rid of. A paper bag on his unconscious face should do the trick. None of the 100-odd soldiers display any more than a baby goat's level of intelligence - convinced that their chief is standing amongst them and inspecting the preparations. Sir Imposter even manages to relay the safe code back to HQ until he is routinely interrupted by his Superior - the chief of the chief, I'm guessing. This chap fails to demonstrate the evolution of the human mind too, and gives the go-ahead. Mission accomplished, then. All Charlie has to do is continue impersonating the chief. Right? But, wait. We forget. This is no ordinary film. It is titled Players. And 'Players' are cool, like that. It cannot possibly be so simple. So let's FOOL the audience, embarrass the critics and think one step ahead (and subsequently, two behind) - let's bring Charlie back to HQ, out of his mask so that the TEAM can pull off a laughably-contrived painfully-planned heist sequence with the train(s) in motion. Dhoom 2, EAT DIRT!

Further - just when you think you know what's next, when you think you've pinned them smart alec writers - they stun you with a twist so daft that Don 2 might genuinely be the best heist film of the last 28 days. Rather than get into an analysis of a blatant commercially-crafted explosion of wealth, let's just do away with the 'masala' excuse for once and come to terms with an inescapable fact:

This was meant for the single-screen audiences? Maybe.

This was for the masses, aam-junta, whatever they're called? Maybe.

This was a style ride meant to entertain you, not test you? Maybe.

But here's the thing - films like Players, Ajnabee, Humraaz and Don 2 aren't dumbed down on purpose. Don't flatter yourselves. They're dumbed down because most writers and filmmakers aren't tuned into the real world anymore, They simply can't think outside of the cringe-inducing mediocrity that we see on screen. It is not so much about their intentions as it is about their storytelling caliber these days. It is also time to finally ask some questions: Are they even capable of making a genuinely engaging action, thriller or horror film anymore? Are they equipped with the intelligence to do so?

It is almost impossible to forgive this director-duo for consistently churning out 'thrillers' so ridiculously dated and delusional that they're fast approaching the action-equivalent of Ramsay Brothers. Not to mention their astounding ability of continuously picking out a questionable (putting it mildly) ensemble cast, passing them off as clueless pawns in a game, time and again. Forensic students, detectives and criminology experts might lose the will to live if they're ever exposed to an Abbas-Mustan product. The filmmakers must remember, at all times, that their content is being released in the age of Sherlock, Lost, Castle, Dexter, House and Prison Break. Increasingly so, even the aam-junta they're aiming at aren't strangers to names like this anymore thanks to the unlimited potential of a thing called the Internet.

Also, what is very obvious is the fact that the filmmakers have remade The Italian Job specifically for an audience that has watched the Hollywood versions - blatantly evident from the million incorporated twists that use the original plot as nothing but red herrings. What? The Italian Job says that the gold is supposed to be stolen with a single-con that involves an elaborate traffic plan, an explosion and 3 cars waiting below? Well, let's fool em. Let's put off a double con and expose THAT traffic plan as a fake instead! (Why? Because we can't be predictable while 'remaking' a film, right?)

What it results in, though, is an enormously-contrived, poorly-acted, badly-cut, shabbily-filmed mess of gigantic proportions.

A few lesser important facts have been learned from this remake of a remake, though:

- Sonam Kapoor is yet to display natural signs of gene-inheritance.
- The editor is the star of the film, more so when an inevitable railway-track diversion is delayed (and intercut with shots of Bobby Deol's urgent face - evidently enacting the title character in The Tree Of Life) to a point where he/she is forced to use the same shots twice over. In slow-motion.
- Abhishek Bachchan is preparing for yet another inconsequential role in Dhoom-3.
- Abhishek, at one point, is speaking in Bobby Deol's voice - a lethal combination that could sleeperhold most cinephiles into instant submission.
- Neil Nitin Mukesh tried hard to salvage his ham-and-bacon act by repeatedly watching videos of SRK's death scene in Baazigar.
- Bipasha Basu shows considerably more talent when she acts from the face down.
- Tom And Jerry Sound effects used to signify funny moments or the creases on Johnny Lever's face, are back in fashion.

Recently, I came across an initiative called the Jameson Empire Awards - a competition that encourages amateur filmmakers from all over the world to recreate their favorite film in one minute. Most of the submissions involve the easiest possible way - an effective spoof of the trailers with amusing yet resourceful nursery-level production design. Safe to say, now, that Players could be an unintentionally brilliant selection (and favourite) in the 167-minute category.

- Reel Reptile

668201 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
As far as i saw its getting good reviews frm people...

And looks like Taran Adarsh was not paid this time😆 naya saal ka shuruat acchi nahii hai😛
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#17
Movie Review: Players
Reviewed By: Daily Bhaskar.com | Last Updated 02:44(06/01/12)
Movie Name:Players
Critic Rating:
Viewer Rating:
Click here to vote
18
Click here to vote
3
Star Cast:Abhishek Bachchan, Sonam Kapoor, Bobby Deol, Bipasha Basu, Neil Nitin Mukesh, Omi Vaidya, Sikander Kher, Johny Lever and Vinod Khanna.
Director:Abbas Burmawalla and Mustan Burmawalla.
Producer:Burmawala Partners.
Music Directer:Pritam Chakraborty.
Genre:Action/Thriller.
Story

Story: Charlie (Abhishek Bachchan) is planning a major robbery of gold worth crore which is being transferred from Russia to Romania. In order to accomplish his task, he seeks the help of his role Victor Dada (Vinod Khanna). The duo has a common aim of building an educational institution in their hometown, catering to children of all status. Victor Dada puts forward five names such as Ronnie (Bobby Deol), Riya (Bipasha Basu), Spider (Neil Nitin Mukesh), Bilal (Sikander Kher) and Sunny (Omi Vaidya) who have mastered in their respective arts. Charlie ropes them in for the burglary and eventually succeeds in their task. Victor's daughter Naina (Sonam Kapoor) knows the art of hacking and also, gives her bit of help. But, hell breaks loose when one of them turns out to be traitor and flees away with the entire gold. Now, who is this traitor and whether the dream of Victor and Charlie to put up a school will be fulfilled by defeating the traitor is rest of the story.

Story Treatment: Touted to be an official remake of Italian Job, Players however, cries out a difference as the story is served with a desi tadka. Also, new dimensions in terms of characterization have been added. Like Vinod Khanna plays a passive player unlike the original character of Italian Job who leads the actual robbery. Also, Players is technologically well-advanced than original Hollywood flick although, original is rich in terms of content. But, the flipside is the length of the film and performances which leaves an intelligent direction in dilemma. The lack of energy in the actors barring Bipasha and Neil leaves on yawning at most of the times.

Star Cast: Abhishek Bachchan reminds of Dhoom series with no set demarcation in his acting as he gets to switch lanes between good and bad guy. Bipasha Basu leaves a mark with some apt expressions and confidence in her voice. Sonam Kapoor finds it hard to act and looks fake at some points. Neil Nitin Mukesh is outstanding and surprises with oodles of style in his body language and dialogues. Bobby Deol is mute spectator most of the times. Sikander Kher and Omi Vaidya are strictly ok. Vinod Khanna is excellent in his small but pivotal role. Johny Lever as a car mechanic induces pleasant light moments in the film.

Direction: Abbas-Mustan as director duo rock but at times succumbs to the poor screenplay and dialogue writing by Rohit Jugraj and Sudip Sharma. The betrayal in love and swapping the partners brings back the memories of Race, Abbas-Mustan's last release. Nevertheless, full marks to the robbery sequence with high-end technology worth giving a watch. But again, as mentioned earlier, dragged screenplay and low enthusiasm takes away the charm.

Music/ Cinematography/ Dialogues/Editing: Music doesn't ring the bell at all. The background music in the climax during run and chase sequence doesn't sync with the style which looks bizarre. Cinematography is 'A' class complementing everything from capturing locations to robbery. Dialogues are impactless and further ruin the efforts put in by the actors. Editing could have been crisper.

3 Ups and 3 Downs: Direction by Abbas-Mustan, Cinematography and edgy plotline are the strong points. Music, dialogues, performances besides Bips and Neil are the weak points.

On the whole, Players is not flawless but can be given a shot for once.

IHeartDeepika thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18
Really happy for Neil and Abhishek! :)
IHeartDeepika thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#19
Players
By Taran Adarsh, 6 Jan 2012, 08:48 hrs IST
It's a given that hi-voltage action thrillers enthrall and electrify viewers no end. The existing inclination within the industry is to opt for remakes [of South Indian films specifically], though Abbas-Mustan have continuously, in their three decade career, tilted towards western thrillers to be specific. PLAYERS, their latest offering, is the official remake of THE ITALIAN JOB. But it's not a scene to scene adaptation of the classic that was attempted twice in the West. The core conception remains the same, but the screenplay is amended significantly to suit the Indian sensibilities.

A recreation or adaptation always leads to comparisons with the original work. And Abbas-Mustan will have to pass this acid test, since THE ITALIAN JOB is no regular film. Made twice in Hollywood [first in 1969 and then in 2003], THE ITALIAN JOB is a heist film with a variation. Like I pointed out earlier, PLAYERS is an altered version of THE ITALIAN JOB, catering more to the desi sensibilities. It's about a gang of skillful, stylish and sharp players who join hands to carry out a heist. Prepare yourself for a masala film with ample twists and turns, stunning and gorgeous locales, stylized stunts and adrenaline-pumping chases, lots of style and attitude and of course, the mandatory songs and comic sequences... In that respect, PLAYERS is in a completely different zone when one draws parallels with THE ITALIAN JOB.

One more clarification! When the promos of PLAYERS came on air, a lot of people felt that it seemed like an updated version of DHOOM. But let's spell this out at the very onset: There's no similitude between PLAYERS and DHOOM, apart from the fact that both belong to the action genre. DHOOM revolved around the cops-robbers face off, while the characters in PLAYERS are all thieves.

Adventure movies made in Bollywood, by and large, stress on modish imageries, while the actual concept takes a backseat. That's precisely the trouble with PLAYERS. While a one-page synopsis of the film would evoke euphoric and ecstatic reactions, it's the screenplay, with a running time of almost 2.45 hours [20 reels], that lacks the power to keep you enthralled and enchanted. In short, PLAYERS has style and attitude, but what it lacks is soul and spirit!

PLAYERS is about a team of skilled and sharp group of people -- Charlie [Abhishek Bachchan], Ronnie [Bobby Deol], Spider [Neil Nitin Mukesh], Riya [Bipasha Basu], Bilal [Sikander Kher] and Sunny [Omi Vaidya] -- who rob the gold bullion from Russia successfully. But one of them double crosses the players and the team sets out, with Naina [Sonam Kapoor] also included in their task now, to retrieve the booty and also settle scores.

First things first! PLAYERS is an escapist fare, packed with ingredients that are considered mandatory in a Bollywood film. So if you are under the impression that Abbas-Mustan may have shunned the commercial trappings since it is an official adaptation of THE ITALIAN JOB, you're mistaken. PLAYERS doesn't imagine itself to be cinema that educates, enlightens or mollifies an academician. Furthermore, Abbas-Mustan's movies are never simplistic by nature. There are twists at the start, twists in the middle and twists towards the finale and just when you think that the movie's about to conclude, the director duo usually toss yet another twist in your face, leaving you startled for a minute or two. PLAYERS stays true to their style, but the twists here aren't the type that shock, amaze or astonish. One of the twists -- about the double crosser -- does catch you by surprise, but the remaining ones don't and that's where the screenplay falters.

It's a screenplay of convenience. The manner in which the gang sets out to execute the heist in Russia seems like a cakewalk or child's play, which is so damn difficult to absorb. Common guys, you are talking of robbing a nation's assets in broad daylight and the convenience with which things fall into place makes the entire heist phony and fake. Ditto towards the finale, when the chase ensues. Though the train robbery [in the first hour] and the chase sequence [climax] leave you awe-struck, the approach with which the gang sets out to achieve the goal is what appears counterfeit. In fact, given the genre of the film [a hi-octane thriller], one would've expected the writers to integrate a dash of realism in the plot for the goings-on to look plausible and credible, but the haphazard screenplay and the excessive length only dilutes the impact generated by some wonderful moments that PLAYERS has to offer.

It is accepted that Abbas-Mustan are forward-thinking directors. Not only do they opt for varied plots for their films, but also think out of the box when it comes to execution of the written material. Irrespective of how their films are received at the ticket window, you cannot turn a blind eye to the fact that they never pursue the trodden trail. But it's the screenplay that lets them down this time. Since a large part of the movie involves action and chase sequences [Allan Amin], the amalgamation of thrills and daredevil stunts keeps you on the edge. Also, the scale of the film is overwhelming. Filmed at the panoramic locales of Russia, Netherlands, New Zealand and of course, India, the DoP [Ravi Yadav] bestows the film with an international look. In fact, it's an incredibly good looking film!

Pritam's music is, to put it bluntly, a minus point. One misses a captivating soundtrack here. The music is deficient of the dynamism and passion that one witnessed in Pritam's preceding works in this variety [DHOOM, DHOOM 2 and RACE].

ZAMEEN was the first movie wherein Abhishek Bachchan's characteristic macho style was detected by the spectators. Movies like DHOOM, DUS, BLUFFMASTER and last year's DUM MAARO DUM strengthened his image further. The actor flaunts his popular style and attitude with panache in PLAYERS. Bobby Deol is wasted. Seriously, why is he sidelined in the plot? Bipasha enacts the role of a con artiste with super confidence. She looks fab and emotes with conviction. It's an image transformation for Sonam in PLAYERS. She has never done a full-on glamorous role before and PLAYERS should change the perception. However, the rawness, as an actor, shows in a variety of scenes.

Neil Nitin Mukesh is entrusted with a challenging role, but he lacks the charisma and skill to carry off the part with dexterity. Sikander Kher has an insignificant role. As for Omi Vaidya, the less said the better. He irritates and hams incessantly. Vinod Khanna is not in his element either. Johny Lever is hilarious as the car dealer. Aftab Shivdasani appears in a cameo.

On the whole, PLAYERS rides mainly on the clout of its credible director duo [Abbas-Mustan], daredevil stunts and stunning visuals. But, most importantly, it is deficient of a captivating screenplay. Also, the film could have done with judicious trimming for an enhanced impact. I for one went in with colossal expectations, but came out feeling downcast and disheartened.
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#20
Film marred by bad performances?

Barring Bips all are star kids...what do they care?

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 1 months ago

https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682

https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 22 days ago

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972624019976515864

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972624019976515864
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 22 days ago

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972622901443752106

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1972622901443752106
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

Movie has released worldwide 12th September and will release in India too...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 1 months ago

https://x.com/varindersingh24/status/1955662282345808161 https://x.com/aavishhkar/status/1967618349535518917

https://x.com/varindersingh24/status/1955662282345808161
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".