Who is better HR or Anu Malik - Page 8

thanx sweety!!
btw guyz HR fan club has been moved to MUSIC CORNER!!!!
😳 😊

I think so far anu malik is way better than HR in terms of original music.
So far HR has given a few good compositions....e.g. Lagan lagi in tere naam. Anu malik, on the other hand has surprised me time and again with his compositions in Refugee, LoC, asoka, Kareeb and Border, all movies have songs that are beautiful lyrically as well as from compositional point of view.
In terms of copying...HR has a few blatant copies...but very few. His songs are mostly, multiple songs mixed...while AM is bad in copying.

Mukesh

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Not really. L-P used to have more then a 100 movies a year in the 80s. And they were quite original😉

LP probably was the  busiest director...I think Piyare Lal is still alive..together doing 100 movies like 500 songs in a year...thats awsome and without any copying...I think it will be worthwhile to see how they did that..LP was my favorite MD..

Originally posted by: coolsaints11

People have seen both HR and Anu Malik on musical shows..Who you think is better HR or Anu Malik..as far as

1.Originality of their composition is concerned...

Border was a bigger musical hit than HR has any till now

Originally posted by: coolsaints11

2.Personality is concerned....

Let us see HR in one year of SRGMP has caused more irritation than two years of AM in Indian Idol, so I would prefer AM here

Originally posted by: coolsaints11

3.Singing ability is concerned..

As much as I dislike HR's nasal singing style, he is far better than AM(and HR won the best singer award this year. so I dont think this is even in question

Originally posted by: coolsaints11

4.any thing else which make one better than another...😃

HR is a better marketer than AM, AM is more open mouth put foot, HR has had more hits/releases than AM.

But I prefer AM

Originally posted by: sareg

Let us see HR in one year of SRGMP has caused more irritation than two years of AM in Indian Idol, so I would prefer AM here

This was funny... 😆

It's almost comical to compare the nasal whine of "music" HR has lifted from the Middle East with Anu Malik. See Below for my point .....

List of only Some of AM's Movies

Cheers

jsw

HR and AM are different genres of music directors. Though I hate HR, i will say he is better than Anu.

ANU MALIK

Composer-turned-singer

Judge on Indian Idol

Known to be brash and rude with contestants

Had differences with Farah and Sonu over contestants

He used shayari to describe the performance but never praised contestants

Promised to give some contestants a break in Bollywood



HIMESH RESHAMMIYA

Composer-turned-singer

Judge on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa

Boasted about and promoted only his protg Vinit

Never had any arguments with co-judges

He was vociferous in his praise for Vinit resulting in his protg's over-confidence

Vinit has sung for Himesh in the film Rocky

ANU MALIK EVEN HAD A PROB WID HIMESH.........BECOZ OF DA NU 'HUMKE DEEWANA KAR GAYE' TRACK WHICH WAS COMPOSED BY HIMESHji...........

Originally posted by: ash_schwarzen

ANU MALIK

Composer-turned-singer

Judge on Indian Idol

Known to be brash and rude with contestants

Had differences with Farah and Sonu over contestants

He used shayari to describe the performance but never praised contestants

Promised to give some contestants a break in Bollywood



HIMESH RESHAMMIYA

Composer-turned-singer

Judge on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa

Boasted about and promoted only his protg Vinit

Never had any arguments with co-judges

He was vociferous in his praise for Vinit resulting in his protg's over-confidence

Vinit has sung for Himesh in the film Rocky

ANU MALIK EVEN HAD A PROB WID HIMESH.........BECOZ OF DA NU 'HUMKE DEEWANA KAR GAYE' TRACK WHICH WAS COMPOSED BY HIMESHji...........

Yeah i read about it recently.  Apparently Anu wanted to cancel it's contract with T series since they didn't tell him another composer was going to chip in with him in the album. 

yo yo both are pain in assssssssssssssssssssssssss 😆 😆 😆