Javed Ali is smug - Page 2

all the 3 judges are superb ...they are simply simply gr8 ...bombastic :)

extremely talented ...n they r all so sweet ...n i really missed alka yagnik today

I love Javed a singer but is (please excuse my language) a prick when it comes to judging anyone not on his team, he is extremely critical.  Last week he said that Salman was flat but when Azmat is out of tune or mispronounces words, where is his critique?  Also I resent him complimenting both Nitin and Azmat the same, creating a false equivalency.  But I place blame on the other judges for making excuses for Azmat.  

I find JA to be the most objective and fair judge...Professional and true with his guidance-comments..

Originally posted by: Pradarshak

Hey... How about Adnan showing his piano playing talent in the last show for so long. If others don't have the detailed/minute knowledge of Sugam Sangeet is that Javed's fault ? They are there to jugde and point exact faults and ask to do better if needed ( Of course not like Ram Sampat) not just say "wah wah""thoda sur idhar-udhar""sur hila tha""accha Gaya""namasteji"etc. etc.

He proved it again tonight - Friday Sept 23 - Javed was not professional at all.  It is one thing to support and encourage the members of your team but to do so against the talent on others is just untollerable.  To unnecessarily critize a child just because he is on the other team, to put your hands up at the end when Niladri is voted out - insensitive to the core. 

Originally posted by: nkkolas

He proved it again tonight - Friday Sept 23 - Javed was not professional at all.  It is one thing to support and encourage the members of your team but to do so against the talent on others is just untollerable.  To unnecessarily critize a child just because he is on the other team, to put your hands up at the end when Niladri is voted out - insensitive to the core. 

 

Shameful example to set!

 

Sadly only one judge showed any grace today - Adanan Sami encouraged all participants - didn't favor his own team member over others.  He is a good example of a good mentor.

Of the 3 judges, I find Javed the most reasonable one. He is always composed and does not get into unnecessary arguments.

Javed and adnan are my faves! While adnan keeps his comments simple and sweet, javed offers his extensive knowledge of music through the comments that he makes. Kailash goes on for too long about irrelevant things.