Tia n her thinking | Indian Idol 6

mihali

@mimz7

Goldie

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

Tia is pretty n all but tht doesn't mean the audience shud drag her sooo far in the competition tht more deserving candidates go out b4 her like Karmakar girl (poor girl studied music but still failed wit such a great voice) , Bengali girl, Shahi....unfair!

Seroiusly i'm not bashing her but deserving shud stay for a longer peroid of time

In this article she says she didn't get sympathy votes she got BEAUTY/PRETTY LOOKING votes...........few performances of her were alright, otherwise each had something lacking

To top it all she is an untrained singer but a TRAINED dancer so why not give an audition at DID rather than Indian Indol.....jis cheese mein training nahi hai usme jana par jis me training hai aur confident hai ke mein aage tak ja sakte hoon usme particpate nahi kar na......wat kinda common sense/straight forward thinking is tht???!!! Please Explain!!!!! Just cuz her friends said to try out at II5 she goes n gives it a try......uske friends bhi uski tarah "naive" hai

3

Reply

Quote

533680

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Agree with mihali completely. Tia was the weakest singer of this season.

Reply

Quote

533680

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: SlumGOD
Bas bhi kijiye ab.

jab log shivam aur rakesh ka band bajana nahin thakte to tia ka band bajane mein kya problem hain...😛

1

Reply

Quote

503804

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: pari100

jab log shivam aur rakesh ka band bajana nahin thakte to tia ka band bajane mein kya problem hain...😛

The difference is Tia is eliminated...shivam and rakesh are still in the competition.
I don't see any posts about Yashraj/Shashi/Naushad/Arpita etc then why Tia?

1

Reply

Quote

533680

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: crystalline23

The difference is Tia is eliminated...shivam and rakesh are still in the competition.
I don't see any posts about Yashraj/Shashi/Naushad/Arpita etc then why Tia?

so wt if she is eliminated...there is no such rule in IF dat if a contestant is eliminated u can nt create threads rgd him/her...

y tia bcoz she was the one due to whom deserving contestants like shashi, naushad and arpita got eliminated...

Edited by pari100 - 13 years ago

Reply

Quote

503804

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: pari100

so wt if she is eliminated...there is no such rule in IF dat if a contestant is eliminated u can nt create threads rgd him/her...

y tia bcoz she was the one due to whom deserving contestants like shashi, naushad and arpita got eliminated...

I am not saying dont create threads, all I am saying is what is the use of discussing how she got votes, if she was deserving or not.....
Haan par woh eliminate ho chuki what is the point of being upset about how she got votes....Yes i agree she was not a good singer but she did get votes probably for singing or for other reasons.....there are still singers in the top 5 who dont deserve to be there😕

Edited by crystalline23 - 13 years ago

4

Reply

Quote

mihali

@mimz7

Goldie

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

ok but my main point of tia is tht she is trained in dancing toh y did she audition for Indian Idol 5 instead she shu'dve gone to some dance like DID or DPL where her actual talent wud've been appreciated..... Wat's so smart in doing something ur not trained in where u can get better in something tht ur trained in already

Reply

Quote

324284

Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: mihali7
ok but my main point of tia is tht she is trained in dancing toh y did she audition for Indian Idol 5 instead she shu'dve gone to some dance like DID or DPL where her actual talent wud've been appreciated..... Wat's so smart in doing something ur not trained in where u can get better in something tht ur trained in already

You should ask Judging Panel whey they selected her for Gala. She didnt get through audition round based on public voting. I agree that there were better singers who got eliminated before her but what the point of creating this topic after her elimination

Edited by SlumGOD - 13 years ago

Reply

Quote