Feedback on Comments by Members. READ NOW! - Page 2

Ok thanks for your response DramaholicVibes but my only question is regarding this bit "so please don't judge what we are saying with such little evidence"....i dont get that...i didnt pass a judgement i just said what i felt when u said that "we're not your friends and we find find it funny when people go around saying "please listen to your friends".." Was that the little evidence ur referring to? Edited by ~srk_abhi_apu~ - 15 years ago

Originally posted by: jenny1000

Don't close FS down, that's our only way of communication with PD.

I agree DB, please don't close FS down

Also, I would like to bring it to your notice that members who are offering honest feedback and criticize/ point out the flaws in FS are labeled as "people spreading negativity"......is that not a snide remark against us?  We are giving honest feedback because PD asked for it, then why isn't it taken in the right spirit by everyone?

EDIT:

We have had this issue before - just because some of us don't believe in praising the show or the creative all the time irrespective of the quality n substance that is offered to us, a very poor picture of us painted to the neutral viewer with disparaging comments....
Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Kavya_KraZQueen

I agree DB, please don't close FS down

Also, I would like to bring it to your notice that members who are offering honest feedback and criticize/ point out the flaws in FS are labeled as "people spreading negativity"......is that not a snide remark against us?  We are giving honest feedback because PD asked for it, then why isn't it taken in the right spirit by everyone?

EDIT:

We have had this issue before - just because some of us don't believe in praising the show or the creative all the time irrespective of the quality n substance that is offered to us, a very poor picture of us painted to the neutral viewer with disparaging comments....

I agree with Kavs👏 Please take this into matter..😳

ummm deres sumthing i wanted 2 post in da other thread but since its locked i decided 2 post it here .... if da mods feel its inappropriate den i apologise n dey r free 2 edit it !!!! Edited by missing Vmars - 15 years ago

Originally posted by: missing Vmars

ummm deres sumthing i wanted 2 post in da other thread but since its locked i decided 2 post it here .... if da mods feel its inappropriate den i apologise n dey r free 2 edit it !!!!

 

neways am sure everyone's aware dat am more of an SG fan ( pretty evident from my avi n my siggie ) ... its not dat i dont like MN .. but am not really counted as dere fan as such ... so if am irritated by dis point i can imagine how da MN fans must b feeling !!!!

 

dis is sumthing i have been noticing for quite sum time at da FS thread ...... apparently one member who by her own admission is all positive abt dis current track n has mentioned abt other members spreading negativity at da FS thread ..... has ( quite a number of times ) .. blamed da MN fans for sugesting ideas 2 PD n hence r responsible for da mess up in da MN track

 

my point is .... is dere really a point 2 dis ...... n more so repeatedly posting da same thing ?????

 

for one even if MN fans did suggest sum ideas ...... wasnt da reasponsibility of incorporating it , executing it more on PD ... neways dats beside da point .... y keep rubbing dis point time n again ... if dey r soooo positive towards da current track ....... den y b sooo hostile towards fellow MN fans ..... rnt dey spreading negativity in da FS THREAD ... by bringing up dis point all da time !!!!

 

so if u really r serious abt spreading positivty in da forum ... den try n extend da same courtesy 2 ur fellow MN fans as well

 

 

also i have a question for dem ... dey have also suggested a couple of scenes .... so if dose scenes do get incorporated n end up mucking da story ..... so sud da rest of us gang up on dem n continuing 2 BLAME DEM for suggesting such scenes in da first place .... n keep posting it time n again !!!!

 

u post sumthing once ... u make a point ... quoting da same thing time n again really doesnt serve a purpose ....

 

 

Well said Kanz 👏 👏 👏

Thannks DB for the feedback...

The only thing i would like to tell the "POSITIVE" people is that ...We all love the show..!!And we all care for it...if we didnt ...we wouldn't bother coming to this forum....It is we viewers who watch the show...and we are SUPPOSED to give a HONEST feedback....If something goes wrong in the show its is our onus to let PD know about it...so that she can understand where shez going wrong ...The BEST example of WHY we had to go into CRITICISM is the TRPs chart....did you see it??? its down to 0.8 ..now tell me ....WHO'S in the majority?

Anyway , Its not about the majority ...we respect your THOUGHTS ..and we EXPECT the same from you....dont claim our FEEDBACK ..to be NEGATIVE...if PD didnt like our feedback..let her deal with us...and she has done it BEAUTIFULLY...! 😊

@  who said  that  we didn't give r honest opinions ?????????????...in the +ve thread ....????????? +ve doesn't mean +ve review ... it means right attitude ... we made r complains ... but without any usage of words " pissing , sucking , Jack Ass."

@ Reads r post mods of +ve thread ... read them and c for urself that as u said among fairies , candles , and ribbons whether we were lying or giving honest opinions ....

@ we even invited u all to join us but without sucking and pissing words .....

 that's why Pd used  the word frustrated ...

@ and ambi sure i know trp is going down ... never said the show  hit on the right spot only that i don't have to c accident happening before it happens ...i.e i choose to c the silver lining instead of  darkness......u have right of ur opinions right ... but v don't have  right to b positive ??/

 @   complain post was also made  regarding Mayur  track ...

@ we countered that post and made the +ve view post .... nothing to do with future thread ...........however it got such a good response that it ended up countering the Jack Pot future thread itself ...

 
Edited by SanaSarwar - 15 years ago

Originally posted by: DramaholicVibes

... Infact you are the guests and we are the hosts kind of thing😆

 

 "I did not like how you presented Ranvijay today," Is Allowed, but comments such as "Ranvijay sucks, the dude can't act" are not allowed. Hope you see the difference, and yes this is a forum, everyone has a freedom to speech, but everyone reading needs to understand that their is a very faint line between Critizem and Bashing, and one should revise and re-read what they post on the forum.

 

 

Points raised by LadyMCbeth

 

--> How can I freely offer my criticism w/o the fear of being labeled as a perpetual negativity propagator?

You can say what you truely feel about the episode or current storyline, but in a way which avoids foul language and you yourself do not mean to intend harm to others. 

See. single comments like "i felt like puking, the episode was so rubbish" is clased as Spam and indirect bashing. , 

Like i said before, we will always have some people who will not agree with your opinions, but thats their choice. we all need to accept each others opinions and if there is something you do not like, over look it and don't respond or pay attention to it. See nobody will get hurt by your comment "today's episode was not up to mark", but if you posted "Mayur Suck, i don't even know why the creatives have kept them there" or "Sajan is so boring, i hate their couple" bla bla, that will be offensive and hurting.

 

REMEMBER -  Any Bashing towards any member, person from creative team(PD), Development Team, Actor or Charecter will not be tolerated.

 

NOTE = IF THE FUTURE SCENES THREAD IS CAUSING SUCH A PROBLEM, PLEASE LET ME KNOW AND I WILL CLOSE IT ONCE AND FOR ALL.. I'M SURE ALL WILL BE HAPPY THEN. 😃 ?

 

Future Questions or Complaints, Please PM me..

 

- MJHT Development Team

thanku so much for ur response on our comments.that is exactly what i was trying to explain in my previous posts...

n i hope ppl will will try n follow it including me too.fingers crossed.

have a good day all😳

Originally posted by: SanaSarwar

@  who said  that  we didn't give r honest opinions ?????????????...in the +ve thread ....????????? +ve doesn't mean +ve review ... it means right attitude ... we made r complains ... but without any usage of words " pissing , sucking , Jack Ass."

@ Reads r post mods of +ve thread ... read them and c for urself that as u said among fairies , candles , and ribbons whether we were lying or giving honest opinions ....

@ we even invited u all to join us but without sucking and pissing words .....

 that's why Pd used  the word frustrated ...

@ and ambi sure i know trp is going down ... never said the show  hit on the right spot only that i don't have to c accident happening before it happens ...i.e i choose to c the silver lining instead of  darkness......u have right of ur opinions right ... but v don't have  right to b positive ??/

 @   complain post was also made  regarding Mayur  track ...

@ we countered that post and made the +ve view post .... nothing to do with future thread ...........however it got such a good response that it ended up countering the Jack Pot future thread itself ...

 

Edited by mashaal - 15 years ago

sorry double posts....

Edited by mashaal - 15 years ago