The significance of Kailash Kher?

I have watched most seasons of Indian Idol but never, i mean never have i seen so much inconsistency with a judge! I mean, if they're paying Kailash Kher for this show then i would be hugely surprised. Its like he turns up when he feels like it! Its pathetic and unprofessional from where i see it. Take this week for example, he failed to turn up for the gala and then turns up and the results show and doesnt even say a word the whole episode?! What they hell is his significance on the show? They should simply get rid of him coz even when he does offer his opinion on anything then its usually something utterly stupid. I know all the other judges are crap as well. Even the respected Jaaved Akhtar gets influenced by the annoying Anu Malik. And Sonali knows nothing about music.

India is the only country you can get away with such nonsence on TV, and this is only one aspect of the show that annoys me. Overall the whole show is pointless and a waste of money and time. We know one of the shit singers [like Remo or Bhanu] are gonna win it so might as well just give up now.

I ask, do any one of you guys vote? If you do - dont waste you money on shite like this. Its not worth it.

There is still a long way to go for Indian Television before it reaches the stage of professionalism.

GOOD ONE. Boycotting (Not sending votes) the show is the only way we would get something better the next season. I have absolutely no interest in the show now.....not seeing it from the last week. Only reading forums to catch updates.

Originally posted by: sumanforums

GOOD ONE. Boycotting (Not sending votes) the show is the only way we would get something better the next season. I have absolutely no interest in the show now.....not seeing it from the last week. Only reading forums to catch updates.

Kailash Kher says nothing,

Anu Malik follows his favourites,

Javed Aktar follows Anu

and Sonali does not know what to follow

Used to be my favorite show......i hated SRGM and VOI since the beginning and always fought with anyone saying II was the best. I would not be able to do so this year...it is an embarrasment this season. I am sad to say that and i hold the judges responsible for choosing such singers and Sony for promoting the cat fights on TV. I always thought it was only the VOI director's game plan (forgot his name..the Antakshari guy).

sonali follows the stuck record which says "vote for women"

Kailash is playing with his position...he may be having other commitments or live shows....but his comments are crucial and maysave an ideal singer....he should be penalised whenever he is absent...now that gives us a task as to what should be his punishment😉

It should not matter if he has other commitments. If he had other commitments then he should not have signed up to do the show. And NONE of the judges comments are crutial anymore. They're a joke. Nobody takes them seriously cos they are actually incompetent to judge singing. I could do a better job than them! Its disgusting.

Yea and the cat fights. Why would a show like this promote arugments in the group???

I wish that they would broadcast a show like 'The X Factor' [UK] in India so people can appreciate the differences and how a show like this should be made.

And the format is so flawed its unbelievable. I think that the JUDGES should have the right to choose who is elimated from the bottom two. But then again, that would end is disaster as well cos in India they wouldnt leave with a choice between good and bad. It'll be good vs good.

Originally posted by: Pyari Pari

It should not matter if he has other commitments. If he had other commitments then he should not have signed up to do the show. And NONE of the judges comments are crutial anymore. They're a joke. Nobody takes them seriously cos they are actually incompetent to judge singing. I could do a better job than them! Its disgusting.

Yea and the cat fights. Why would a show like this promote arugments in the group???

I wish that they would broadcast a show like 'The X Factor' [UK] in India so people can appreciate the differences and how a show like this should be made.

And the format is so flawed its unbelievable. I think that the JUDGES should have the right to choose who is elimated from the bottom two. But then again, that would end is disaster as well cos in India they wouldnt leave with a choice between good and bad. It'll be good vs good.

dat iz just sooo true...

but who will boycott II totally??? for sure any of da judges dont matter...and i dont think X Factor would make a difference...ppl still dont tend to understand stuff...after 4 weeks of bad eliminations...how much more do u expect?

the king completely agrees wid u. he is abesnt 4 galas n in elimiations he is a mute spectatot. wonder why he evers comes in elimination rounds. maybe juzz 2 collect his pay.

*king*

Originally posted by: *king*

the king completely agrees wid u. he is abesnt 4 galas n in elimiations he is a mute spectatot. wonder why he evers comes in elimination rounds. maybe juzz 2 collect his pay.

*king*

Originally posted by: salmaankhan86

gajendra singh

Originally posted by: shabari

salamkhan86 it took me 2 mins to figure out ur signature,sorry😕😆...who is that? sallu bahiyya...?

LOOLLL .. why did it take you 2 mins to figure it out! it's not that hard lol .. yuppp im an ardent fan of bhai but thats me and not him! and my name is salmaan nazir and not khan lol .. dont ask why .. its been my email address since i was 12! 😆