Thayumanavan 21-25 Oct Discussions

Page

Next Last

hopper_ocean

@hopper_ocean

Alumni

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

today best scene and expressions was janani with maha 👏

I can feel how uncomfortable it has become for both Bharathy Maha.. they had always talked like a friend and definitely its not going to be easy to change that to this relationship. Though i feel Maha sort of accepted him already.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Jayanthi

@hemanthkrishna

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

Thanks for the update sister.
Will comment after catch up with the episode.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

kalki

@kalki2007

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: hopper_ocean
today best scene and expressions was janani with maha 👏

I can feel how uncomfortable it has become for both Bharathy Maha.. they had always talked like a friend and definitely its not going to be easy to change that to this relationship. Though i feel Maha sort of accepted him already.

Maha didn't any lover or any expectations about her husband - so she can adapt easily - she takes with open arms - Bharathy made mistake of marrying her then siding away not right - he knew Janani and Maha sisters living in the same house - i feel for Maha - not for Bharathy - he should have told Mathy truth - he ruined his, janani and Maha's life

Quote

krithika

@Wonderfullife

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: kalki2007

Maha didn't any lover or any expectations about her husband - so she can adapt easily - she takes with open arms - Bharathy made mistake of marrying her then siding away not right - he knew Janani and Maha sisters living in the same house - i feel for Maha - not for Bharathy - he should have told Mathy truth - he ruined his, janani and Maha's life

I completely go with your view Kalki akka..Now I feel pity for Maha only.. 😭

Quote

migan

@migan

Cool Viewbie

Posted: 11 years ago

Thanks Ratna for the update.

I really cannot digest this serial after last week.

I do feel pavam Maha on top of every one else.

Quote

migan

@migan

Cool Viewbie

Posted: 11 years ago

Mathi Alagan the actor who acts as Mathi in the serial posted this in his FB page. it is a response to a fan's letter...

It summarizes all of our cry and anger.

After reading I feel he tries to cover up but you know he is just an actor I do not believe he will be able to change it. It is the directors and creatives screwed up thinking it is twist etc. Very bad one.

Mathi Alagan

October 18

My conversation with a concerned Thayumanavan fan:

Kalpana Sundaralingam:

Hi Mathi sir, I just wanted to let you know that I was very disappointed with the last Thaiyumanavan episode with Bharathi marrying Maha! I never followed any Indian TV serial, having been brought up in Australia, most of the serials are unrealistic! Thaiyumanavan was the exception, I have been watching it religiously, I stay up 11pm at night to watch! But after this episode I will not be watching it anymore, it has become like every other TV serial!! I am sure that I am not the only fan who will be switching off! Please pass this feedback onto Vijay TV!! The character you play, must be the worst father figure - out of his 5 daughters, 3 are now unhappy and miserable! So much for a drama about the relationship of father and his daughters! All the best for the future!

Me:

Hi Kalpana, thank for your support.

Firstly, this is a story, a serial...it is totally your choice of following this program or not, whatever the reason may be...some viewers might like a twist in the story, and some might not.

In life we are faced with certain situations...some we like some we don't...we just handle it the way we think its right at the moment of time...on hindsight we might want to take a totally opposite choice.

As a parent, I can say that I want to do the best for my children...but my love, protection, care and concern for them might turn out to be an obstacle in their path...I have to balance this with detachment, giving them independence and sometime letting them handle their own screwups.

I guess this is the realism the writers of this serial are trying to employ...I might not agree with the track the story is travelling in, I might not agree with the decisions of my character...but this is a story n it is trying to reflect life as real as possible which is unpredictability...some will like what you do, and some might not, thinking u doing good for a loved one u might do something exactly opposite...isn't that just what life is like.

The most unrealistic of story lines would be one which only shows happiness and all viewers agrees with decisions made by the characters...

I do not go to this length in all my mails...but I sense a feeling of disappointment in your mail...it could be due to many personal reasons...that is why this mail.

Thanks for your comments.

Kalpana Sundaralingam:

Thank you Mathi sir for writing back! Honestly I am so impressed with your acting and that your co-stars, it has brought a new dimension in my opinion to Indian TV serials and hats off to you all for that! I actually fell in love with the show and it's characters, so much so that I feel for them as if they were real! I guess over the last few weeks the blossoming love of Janani and Bharathi, and the hope that Maha would marry Viknesh kept me hopelessly addicted! I agree with a lot of what you say in your comments, but I am one of five children and really only one of us has gone through experiences like that Subha, Janani, Bharathi or Maha! Namely the extreme cruelness, unfairness or injustice of life! For most of us it is the simple issues in life that consume us in both happiness and sadness! What I liked about Thaiyumanavan was that it had a great mix of happiness and sadness! Now for a while it is going to be dominated by sadness, guilt and a sense of hopelessness! The sense of hopelessness is the worst feeling to see in life or in a TV serial! When Bharathi tied the knot that's what I felt! I guess life nowadays has more sadness than happiness so it was nice to have a TV serial with a good balance! But now four of the characters are unhappy! Thank you so much for writing! Sir, you are a brilliant actor, and have a wonderful screen presence! My mother likens you to Denzel Washington! The show has a great ensemble cast! Wishing you all nothing but success! Kalpana

Me:

Thanks again Kalpana for your support and most importantly for your level of involvement...we understand to type of people this serial touches and accept the responsibility that comes with it...at the same time we are bound by the need to create a twist or a wow factor to sustain the interest of the audience...whatever might happen to the characters you love, you can be assured that there will be an underlying message that comes with the storyline...It's and honour for all the people involved that the audience feels for each and every character...

its true that by just this one act the future seems gloomy for the whole family...lets see how the characters mature and how the support one another during this period...Bharathi and Janani have put the family's happiness before their own...it might look stupid but nevertheless it is a selfless act...I am sure it will bring the family closer together...and reveal the goodness in others as well..

Thank you for your conversation...and special thanks to your mum...and I can only dream of performing like Denzel...cheers.

Edited by migan - 11 years ago

Quote

hopper_ocean

@hopper_ocean

Alumni

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: kalki2007

Maha didn't any lover or any expectations about her husband - so she can adapt easily - she takes with open arms - Bharathy made mistake of marrying her then siding away not right - he knew Janani and Maha sisters living in the same house - i feel for Maha - not for Bharathy - he should have told Mathy truth - he ruined his, janani and Maha's life

i have to agree here that Maha never had any expectations .. thus it was so much easy for her to accept him ... and yeah it was wrong of Bharathy to walk away but maybe his feeling guilty or not knowing how to handle this situation. Mathi 😡 always says he gives importance for his daughters but he does not .. I don't think he actually had ask Maha if she is okay with this marriage ..

Quote

hopper_ocean

@hopper_ocean

Alumni

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

akka.. thanks for sharing the letter.. brb to comment later ..

Quote

..Jessie..

@..Jessie..

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

The whole fault lies in the script, Maha's marriage stopped instead of heading away forced or compulsion marriage which is risk they could have stopped the marriage and showed how stronger can Maha grow even though she was not much out going. Suba's decision was wrong , Maha's life a question mark , bold Jannani is facing love failure is this way of moving a story?

claiming to be unique it is only still running behind sogam and unnecessary drama.

Atlest Bharathi can now talk to Maha saying how is not ready to accept the marriage but will soon try adapt to it , instead wandering away and starring away , i agree it is difficult for bharathi but instead of indirect confusion bharathy can atleast ask Maha to bee normal and make her understand its hard for both of them to accept this relationship and move on.

no body in the family is trying to understand barathi was forced for the marriage, everybody treating bharathi as new mappilai as if everything suddenly changed and he and maha will be normal .

as for the promo i guess Maha just asks the question of bharathi's love and suba will find out but will ask Jannani about it and dragging continues🥱

Edited by ..Jessie.. - 11 years ago

Quote

Jayanthi

@hemanthkrishna

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#10

Thayumanavan Tuesday update.

Episode starts with Mathi comes to restraurant asks what they did for cylinder? Waiter said cylinder arrived. Mathi asks how? He said Bharathi brought it from home. Mathi asks where is he? Bharathi came out. Mathi asks him what he doing here nu? Bharathi says that he had no work in home and simply sitting that's y came here nu. Mathi says to him that yesterday only he got married what maha thinks about him. She feels for him nu. Mathi says to bharathi that he ask him not to come to restraurant for 10days. Mathi says him that he is always like him when he was young. Mathi asks him take to some for him. thinks about what he likes and dislikes else. Bharathi sgsin in mind voice thinks now what is left for him to become happy nu. Mathi feels for maha. Bharathi in mind voice thinks that now also he thinks only for maha he is thinking about him what he feels nu. Mathi asks him y he looks so dull today what happens nu. Bharathi says nothing he is fine. Mathi asks him saptiya nu. He says yes. Mathi asks him where he ate, he can asks maha whether he had lunch r not? Bharathi remains silent. Mathi asks him to go home and take some rest. Mathi asusual calls him vada poda nu. He asks Bharathi that he calls him like that way r he call him as Mapillai. Bharathi asks he y talks like that nu he calls him as usual nu.

Scene shift to Mathi's home. Bsnl Ramachandran came there. Maha gave him a angry look. He apologise for what happen to her nu. He feels sad for her. He also came here to apologise to Mathi. As per his investigation he heared only good thing about Prabhu. Now only he knows that its all is plan. He is happy that she got married to Bharathi. He is a nice person that he is sure that he will make her happy. All these bad things are happened in her marriage bcoz god has decided that she will got married to Bharathi only. He said that her father had searched his mapillai from everywhere that had from own. He leaves Maha asks him coffee sapdringala nu. He said no. he is happy with that she asked. He Blesses her and leaves.

Maha thinks about something and waiting for Bharathi. Indra came there and kalachufying her that y she is alone where is Bharathi nu. she said he is not here. Indra asks he doesn't informs her ah nu. Maha said no. Indra said he is in restraurant only. Maha says appa came home. Indra says if he is there he came with appa. indra call Bharathi he doesn't pick up. indra said she has to tell this to Janani she only handles him well. She calls her and informs her about Bharathi and ask her to call him. Indra said to maha that Bharathi will come in few minutes that Janani gave him a call nu. Indra asks maha that she had dinner r not? Maha said that she is not hungry. she waits Till Bharathi come. Indra kalachufies her and ask to take dinner.

Bharathi crying😭😭😭 to his friend about his marriage. His friend scolds him for that. Bharathi said that he did this only for mama nu. His friend says he did this for mama bt how he lives with maha. He knows that how he loves Janani Then how he did marriage with another girl nu. Its ok that he marry anyother girl bt how its possible to live with her lovers sister. How he face her daily in same home nu. Bharathi says that he doesn't know what to do. He asks Bharathi to tell all this to his mama about he loves only Janani and not ready to live with maha nu. Bharathi said that it all waste how he tell all this to mama he hurts so much. His friend ask him to live happily with Maha nu and y he is crying now nw. He hurts all saying his mama name nu. Janani calls him. Bharathi attends the call. She asks him where is he? Saptiya? Y he is not coming to home nu? Maha is waiting for him. Bharathi says that he is not coming there he stays here only. Janani asks him whether he talks about today only r life long? Bharthi says that he stay here nu. Janani ask him to understand the reality and said that he did all this bcoz of his mama. Then now if he knows that u r not happy in this marriage he feels so much. Bharathi says that she easily said all this. She said its all become easy and he forgots everything in few days. She asks him don't hurt all for her. She is only her wife sister and we have the relationship around only her. She ask him to come home and cuts the phone.

Maha waiting for Bharathi. He came and stands in outside. Maha opens the door. Bharathi asks her she didn't sleep ah nu? She said no. He asks her sorry. She asks him y he stands outside? He said for cooling air he stands here and she knows that he came nu? She said that she hears his bike sound. Both enters the house. Maha said sapadu iruku nu. He said ate and asks her sorry that he has to inform her. He asks her saptiya nu? She said no. He said her not to wait for him and ask her to eat and sleep before him. She feels sad. He asks her sorry. She said how many times he said this. He ask her to eat. she said she is not hungry. He said ok and go to sleep. Maha asks him whther he sleep here ah? He said he is comfortable here. She said not to mistake her that she knows that he is disturbed with this marriage. He said nothing like that. She wants to talk to him about this. Bt if he sleeps here it disturbs all. Appa asked 2, 3 times whether u came r not? If he see here sleeps means its hurts him so much. We did this marriage only for him. Appa feels for her more that she doesn't want to hurt him again. Bharathi asks her what to do? She said that don't think that she compel him she had no other choice and ask him to go inside and sleep. She asks him sorry that he tortures in the name of appa. Bharathi took pillow and bedsheets and laid down. Maha feels sad. Soga geetham in background. Bharathi asks her thoongalaya nu. She said thonganum. Both of them crying😭😭😭😭😭😭 facing opposite each other. Screen freezes with Maha.

Edited by hemanthkrishna - 11 years ago

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Thayumanavan 21-25 Oct Discussions

Related Topics

Explore Topics