MauHaan/IshaaLi AT#2: Tum Dena Saath Mera O Humnava (DT Note pg. 96) - Page 46

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

34.7k

Users

25

Likes

3k

Frequent Posters

Silpa20 thumbnail
IPL 2023 Match Winner Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ritzbitz786



The lust and attraction part, as obvious as it was when Nandini was dancing in the rain, was soon turned into divine love.

An EMA, is just that. An EMA. The marriages that do work out post EMA are ones where the husband feels guilty, there is remorse, etc. Most importantly an EMA is temporary.

This show went from EMA, to defending divinity and saying it's not lust but love, to a full blown love story, which resulted in a marriage.
That's not an EMA anymore. When you cross the lines from temporary (EMA) to permanent (divorce from wife and subsequent marriage to the mistress), then there is little that can be done, besides forgiving the person (in this case Kunal) and moving on (with Ishaan).

And agreed, MauHaan ending has more logic behind it.

Maunal reunion never had any logic. Even people saying that his dialogue of "If I get lost, find me. Well Mauli did try to find Kunal, especially after she got pregnant, but still he did not come back. The only reason he's back now is because if amnesia. If Kunal wanted to be found, if he felt guilty that he had gone down the wrong path of EMA, if Mauli usko dhoond ke wapis le aye apne Ore, he would have made the marriage work.

Even the CD which Nandini made didn't have any logic. Nandini didn't think ke 6 years baad shayad Mauli has a husband and family of her own? Nandini knew that Mauli is single and will be able to reunite with Kunal and forgive him and raise Pari? Isn't this the same Nandini that said Kunal are mera pyar atoot hai. So if Nandini herself believed that her and Kunal had an unbreakable love, than why because she was dying of cancer, did she want a Maunal reunion? When she knew that Kunal loves her? She wanted Mauli in a loveless marriage solely for her daughter?

So Maunal reunion has always lacked any logic what so ever.

kunal went too far.He left his wife and family.Married the other woman has a daughter with her.They would be a happy family if nandini was not dead.So it will be like nandini is gone so he is back to mauli.So any situation maunal seem impossible.
Indira1211 thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ritzbitz786



The lust and attraction part, as obvious as it was when Nandini was dancing in the rain, was soon turned into divine love.

An EMA, is just that. An EMA. The marriages that do work out post EMA are ones where the husband feels guilty, there is remorse, etc. Most importantly an EMA is temporary.

This show went from EMA, to defending divinity and saying it's not lust but love, to a full blown love story, which resulted in a marriage.
That's not an EMA anymore. When you cross the lines from temporary (EMA) to permanent (divorce from wife and subsequent marriage to the mistress), then there is little that can be done, besides forgiving the person (in this case Kunal) and moving on (with Ishaan).

And agreed, MauHaan ending has more logic behind it.

Maunal reunion never had any logic. Even people saying that Kunal's dialogue of "If I get lost, find me." Well Mauli did try to find Kunal, especially after she got pregnant, but still he did not come back. The only reason he's back now is because if amnesia. If Kunal wanted to be found, if he felt guilty that he had gone down the wrong path of EMA, if Mauli usko dhoond ke wapis le athe apne ore, he would have made the marriage work and all of this reunion should have happened pre-leap. Kunal said "If I get lost, then find me" and Mauli "finds" him, manages to remind him of their deep love for one another, and they make the marriage work.

Ab 6 saal baad, solely because he has amnesia, and solely because Nandini is dead, this is not equivalent to Mauli "finding him." It is just that circumstances brought him back to her. Not his love for her, or her love for him.

Secondly, even the CD which Nandini made didn't have any logic. Nandini didn't think ke 6 years baad shayad Mauli has a husband and family of her own?

How and why was Nandini positive that Mauli is single and will be able to reunite with Kunal and forgive him and raise Pari as her own daughter?

And even if Mauli was shown to be single, didn't Nandini once say that say "Kunal are mera pyar atoot hai." So if according to Nandini herself, she believed that her and Kunal had an unbreakable love, a true love, then why did she make the CD? Just because she was dying of cancer, she wanted a Maunal reunion?

She knew that Kunal loves her and their love is divine and atoot/unbreakable, yet still she made the CD? She wanted Mauli in a loveless marriage solely for her daughter, basically?

So Maunal reunion has always lacked any logic what so ever.

if I remember the nAndus cd..she only said be there for pari...she didn't say unite with Kunal..am I right ? And yes it was illogical ..because Kunal could take care of his daughter . So nandu didn't want Mauli to go back to Kunal ,...she just wanted Mauli to be nanny to her daughter ...the height of selfishness ..
ritzbitz786 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Indira1211

if I remember the nAndus cd..she only said be there for pari...she didn't say unite with Kunal..am I right ? And yes it was illogical ..because Kunal could take care of his daughter . So nandu didn't want Mauli to go back to Kunal ,...she just wanted Mauli to be nanny to her daughter ...the height of selfishness ..


Yup! Her CD didn't say to marry Kunal, but it hinted towards it. Because as you said, it said to raise her or give her parwarish. Meaning that Kunal could not somehow do that as a single Dad? So she wanted Mauli there as a nanny? An aunt? A wife?

But that is when the whole Maunal reunion started in Pari's mind and that track was introduced. Pari wanting that Mauli Aunty should be with Buddy, asking Santa unko meri Mama banade.

If the intention of Nandini was not a Maunal reunion, rather just that Mauli be a good "Masi"/aunt to Pari, Kunal would have clarified that to Pari and also to Mauli, that look Nandini just wants you to be her aunt and watch over her. But he never clarified, so at this point, it is safe to assume Nandini wanted another Maunal marriage.
Chumki1968 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
Happy Republic Day
We ha e to wait and watch because the writers are also not sure.
If they show regret of ML they will be denying their concept of divine sign. And they also do not want to go away from their said words mauli has only one love. Also they want to see if the chemistry works again. But if relationship is strained who will like chemistry n romance.
So open ended. I do not want To go by words from horses mouth. Writers may have their belief but practically they have to also accept circumstances. If the writer was so determined about her story then why death not replacement
ritzbitz786 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: Chumki1968

Happy Republic Day
We ha e to wait and watch because the writers are also not sure.
If they show regret of ML they will be denying their concept of divine sign. And they also do not want to go away from their said words mauli has only one love. Also they want to see if the chemistry works again. But if relationship is strained who will like chemistry n romance.
So open ended. I do not want To go by words from horses mouth. Writers may have their belief but practically they have to also accept circumstances. If the writer was so determined about her story then why death not replacement


Happy Republic Day to you and everyone else too!

And yeah, all we can do is wait and watch and hope that the writers sense of right and wrong will prevail. Not just what is right and wrong morally, because I think that is more clear.

But also what is right and wrong for the storyline, like denying the divine signs, etc.
ritzbitz786 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
You know what guys? I wish the actors be it Shakti, Kinshuk or Aditi went live from the set more often.

I know they can't right now cause everything is under wraps and a secret. But it would be fun to see more IG or FB live videos of them interacting with fans from the set.

Any of you guys in Mumbai?!? Anyone on the forum ever visit them on set? I think the set is on Mira Road, no?
vinnas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
MauHaan Vm Ae Dil Hai Mushkil ❤️..
vinnas thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
hello all 😛 happy Republic Day 😛

I'm waiting very eagerly to see the extent of Ishaan unconditional love on Mauli and how he Deal current scenario 😛 Expecting My Ru ❤️ Shades more now ..
Silpa20 thumbnail
IPL 2023 Match Winner Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ritzbitz786

You know what guys? I wish the actors be it Shakti, Kinshuk or Aditi went live from the set more often.

I know they can't right now cause everything is under wraps and a secret. But it would be fun to see more IG or FB live videos of them interacting with fans from the set.

Any of you guys in Mumbai?!? Anyone on the forum ever visit them on set? I think the set is on Mira Road, no?

don't know if there any member from Mumbai.
Silpa20 thumbnail
IPL 2023 Match Winner Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: vinnas

hello all 😛 happy Republic Day 😛

I'm waiting very eagerly to see the extent of Ishaan unconditional love on Mauli and how he Deal current scenario 😛 Expecting My Ru ❤️ Shades more now ..

Happy Republic Day to you too.

Ishaan's love we have seen.I want mauli's confession.I want to see her love for ishaan.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".