Shrimad Ramayan ~ Daily Episode Discussion Thread 26.12.24 - Page 9

Originally posted by: Nikvi29

Yes even in valmiki ramayan version it says Shri Ram would not do anything or sleep without Lakshman since thry were little kids. He even shared same plate with Lakshman.

They were inseparable from birth

That is why if even they said when he banished Lakshman as per Yamdevta deal. He followed immediately left Ayodhya and entered Saryu river immediately without any thought.

Exactly said,,,in baalkand itself,,we get verses which states how inseparable Ram Lakshman are frm beginning childhood itself,,and same for Bharat Shatrughna.

Originally posted by: Nikvi29

I did not know that.

But according to valmiki version

Mandvi is older.

Sita and urmila are daughters of Janak

And mandvi and shrutakirti are daughters of kushadwaj

Yes,, acording to VR,,,Sita urmila daughters of Janak.

Mandvi Shrutkirti daughters of Kushadhwaj,,

Baki Sita is eldest Shrutkirti is youngest,,

Mandvi is elder than urmila,,or vice Versa,,aisa specific mention nahi hai Shayad,,,but mostly it's like this,mandvi is elder to Urmila,,

yeh jo maine share Kiya,,Yeh novels mein diya hai aisa to muje Nahi pata as I haven't read them all,,,,yeh hai kuch East & South india ke ramayan versions mein,,like rangnath ramayan(telugu)and all,,unme thoda jyada details milte hai Sita sisters ke,,,baki VR mein,,yes u r right,,there is nothing much written abt sisters,,they r just mentioned in marriage time in baalkaand,,baki jyada nahi milta unke baare mein😊...

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Arre Haan isi ramayan mein dikhaya tha shayad. Isn't it

Naa yeh exactly to nahi dikhaya tha pura,,but thoda hint type tha as u said,,,starting mein ek scene tha remember where Ram Laxman ke cradles saath mein kaushalya me ke room mein rakhe the,,then one maid came saying that Sumitra ma sent her to bring laxman so as to feed him,,so kaushalya said I will myself take him to Sumitra...then she left,,and Kaakbhushundi ji aaye the and Ramji fed him ladoo,, kaushalya returned & got Narayan darshan frm Ram,, aayi her past janm story & she asked for removing memory of this event,,bcs she just wants to mother,,,not bhakt,,aisa scene tha,,,that was really good scene.....pehle SR gold tha,,,ab it's🤦😵‍💫....

Originally posted by: chatterbox

No I doubt

Lord Shiva would have done that yday only

Sabko statue nahi banate

No one wants to interfere in valmiki work

That's why my vote is for valmiki only

Valmiki ji hi kare truth reveal to acha hai,,

But my main irritation is...yeh bhardwaj muni se jhooth bulwate hai....makers ne thoda bhi nahi socha,,, Bharadwaj muni now saying saugandh ka maan and all and this vachan is supporting lie and hiding truth....none other than an accomplished rishi will say this,,,ki kids ke decision ko hide karne ka jhooth jaari rakho,and aisa vachan bhi de diya kids ko,,,this is😵‍💫😡🙃...

Originally posted by: RamAayenge

Valmiki ji hi kare truth reveal to acha hai,,

But my main irritation is...yeh bhardwaj muni se jhooth bulwate hai....makers ne thoda bhi nahi socha,,, Bharadwaj muni now saying saugandh ka maan and all and this vachan is supporting lie and hiding truth....none other than an accomplished rishi will say this,,,ki kids ke decision ko hide karne ka jhooth jaari rakho,and aisa vachan bhi de diya kids ko,,,this is😵‍💫😡🙃...

Ya wahi sabka character bigaad Diya hai

Tabhi itna drag feel ho raha hai

Sasta ki nautanki ek taraf baaki sab drag hai

Ramji se yudhh hona hi nahi tha

First baan se pehle stop karna tha

But yeh Somu kuch reveal karta hai ya usko bhi mute kar denge again

Originally posted by: chatterbox

Ya wahi sabka character bigaad Diya hai

Tabhi itna drag feel ho raha hai

Sasta ki nautanki ek taraf baaki sab drag hai

Ramji se yudhh hona hi nahi tha

First baan se pehle stop karna tha

But yeh Somu kuch reveal karta hai ya usko bhi mute kar denge again

Ramayan ke saare imp. characters ek taraf,,& swastik ke cretive liberty se aaye characters ek taraf(SwastikAyan),,actual characters ko jitna screen space nahi mila hai,,utna creative liberty wale characters like somkaran,,prasuta,,upguru,,sasta ravan,,shurpi,,ghagra etc etc sabhi ko mil raha hai🤧...

Originally posted by: chatterbox

No I doubt

Lord Shiva would have done that yday only

Sabko statue nahi banate

No one wants to interfere in valmiki work

That's why my vote is for valmiki only

Yeah Now That's Correct

Rishi Valmiki Is The Creator Of Ramayan

So He Will Save Luv Kush

in that novel lakshmila - the eternal love story

sita and urmila had exact nine months of age difference

urmila and mandavi are born on the same day just hours apart

shrutakirti was exactly a year younger than the cousins

now coming to

what have you mentioned about the cousins

in my opinion

in that era letters reach take time of few days

considering

a baby is born after that they will give the news to the family through letter

it might take few days

then

another baby is born

so in that also

there is slight age difference between the two babies

might be few days

mandavi was elder than urmila

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

in that novel lakshmila - the eternal love story

sita and urmila had exact nine months of age difference

urmila and mandavi are born on the same day just hours apart

shrutakirti was exactly a year younger than the cousins

now coming to

what have you mentioned about the cousins

in my opinion

in that era letters reach take time of few days

considering

a baby is born after that they will give the news to the family through letter

it might take few days

then

another baby is born

so in that also

there is slight age difference between the two babies

might be few days

mandavi was elder than urmila

Wow That's Interesting Information

Originally posted by: cuteamanboy

in that novel lakshmila - the eternal love story

sita and urmila had exact nine months of age difference

urmila and mandavi are born on the same day just hours apart

shrutakirti was exactly a year younger than the cousins

now coming to

what have you mentioned about the cousins

in my opinion

in that era letters reach take time of few days

considering

a baby is born after that they will give the news to the family through letter

it might take few days

then

another baby is born

so in that also

there is slight age difference between the two babies

might be few days

mandavi was elder than urmila

Yes,,I also feel same,,, confusion is there bcz nothing is given abt their birth order actually in VR,and just given in later retellings in different versions,,and there r some other stories in eastern versions too abt sisters,,so just shared it here...many has that mandvi is elder,,many has that both same ages,,many has that no clarity as urmila was born but revived later,,and mandvi born & msg given to janak,, Kushadhwaj didn't had separate kingdom i guess,,he was in mithila only that time,,sandesh here means just informing may be by maids or sevaks,,,ki birth hua hai,,dusre rajya se letter aaya aisa wala nahi may be,,,pata nahi exactly to....that's why in series also u find sometimes even urmi calls mandvi by name and not didi,,and mandvi mostly calls her by name,,par kabhi kabhi she says didi....ab yeh sisters ko dikhate hi bahut kam hai,, isliye pattern observation is also difficult 😂😅...

Baki mein bhi mainly yahi believe karti hu ki mandvi is elder than urmila....yeh to interesting tha isliye share Kiya😊...

Even u know such thing is there between Sumitra & Kaikeyi,,,VR sometimes say Kaikey is youngest,,Dashrath ne bhi paayas distribution ke time second no. Par Sumitra ko diya tha,,,fir Kaikeyi ko,,so thoda bahut unclear rehta hai,,order of elder to younger is very clearly written only for Ram & brothers,,Ram Bharat Lakshman Shatrughna....😊✨