One of the Best Mother-Son Confrontation Scene Ever - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

1.7k

Users

10

Likes

51

Frequent Posters

Flora15 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#11
Take a bow dearest Gago for this amazing long retake written wonderfully 👏Usually appreciate your big efforts in writing reviews. The epsisode is a blockbuster episode ;I cried my heart watching it especially in the scene Harman begging neck from his mom. MON V Son Confrontation is the bestest confrontation watched between Harman and Preeto in Shakti. This scene of Harman Singh ;the descendent of an amir family turning dhole, drumming drums and begging neck from his mom will be curved in my memory forever. I never thought that I'll cry for Preeto ;I was waiting to enjoy the moment but the impact of mon/son confrontation was big and my heart was shattered in pieces. I Cried for Preeto as a mon and my be the skilling performance of kamya Punjabi and VD with their big professionalism in transmitting the feelings of that outburst, helpless and defeated mother V the indifferent and heartbroken son drumming dhols and begging neck from his mom to feed his wife turned me very emotional😭💔😭 Vivian and kamya make us feel that confrontation as real both portrayed their chareters perfectly and their chemistry as a mon son resulted hilarious. That's why the impact of the episode was great. When cried for Preeto cried for the sight of the mon in Preeto and this don't mean that I can forget her devilness and her crimes.Me who never considered Preeto as a mon still have the same point of view of her considering her heartless, devil and criminal so makers mustn't think that we sympathize with Preeto, we only get sympathy for a mon sight loosing her own son due to her deeds. She's devil but she's the wom who gave birth to Harman and it's due to her we have this iconic man named Harman Singh. Preeto is receiving the fruits of her own deeds. This is Preeto's bad day and her karma till her redumption and change.
I'm still waiting like all the day when Preeto get exposed with her deeds and her crimes in front of her son. Gago you have done a very detailed retake and I adooored reading it. Tatally agree with what you and I was panicked what to add. I'll reinterpret all point as I 'm telling a story summarizing everything and adding an 11th point about Saumya " the telepathy .. She'll remain my mon"
Ballu runned inside house telling whole family that Harman is playing dol with kinar and is coming house. Whole family get shocked as it's a storm who is coming toward them and they must stop it. Harak Singh furiously shouted on ballu ordering him not to look him and move saying Darvaza bankar and he repeat that.. But as no one can stop a storm bullu failed in his mission ;kinars joining hands push the door and have done their entry. Preeto asked why you come here and Kareena answered sarcastically to beg neck. Ravina rejoicing the moment said to herself today we will enjoy making fan of you. Preeto shouts on kinars ordering them to leave. But Kinar called Harman and Harman showed himself standing on their door. Kareena said aaj Harman will play dhol for us, we will dance and he'll beg neck from you. Ravina added since Harman Ji is playing with us drums we're earning more money and told Harman to show his parents and family his talent. Harman is up to play and Harak Singh screamed "oyeee Harman" Harman kept his hands freezed in between and listens to his dad. Harak warmed him saying you played the dhol for that Kinar but you mustn't do as you know how bad I'm and is up to do his 'Kasam but Harman precipitated him doing a separated drumbeats.. If I remember they're are three.. It's was like the opening of the curtain in theatre. Harman after that make all his power and his soul drumming dhols doing his entry straight holding his head up. All his body is vibing with that rapid and powerful drumbeats.It's a souful and emotional melody...Kinar dancing, neighbors gathered watching and family stabbed with shock. Harman keep putting all his power drumming confidently , fierce and with no guilt . In same time he was stepping toward his mother looking at her eyes without any movement ;Harman didn't do anything wrong, he was right, honest and frank with her;he was innocent and pure but this mom was wrong with him and her son is coming here looking at her eyes and drumming for Kinars to make her live the same pains lived by him and his wife. Still remember this caring and lovely son when he said her after Bangkok track when she gave money to Saumya to free herself and failed in her mission ;she wanted burn the money with rage and Harman trapped her saying burn everything but don't tray to burn my relation with Saumya she's my life.. Preeto didn't listened him and this is the result her relation with her son is burning in front of her eyes. Harman eye lock and drumming with every drumbeat is recalling her how much she hurted him and ruined his life. This mom keep looking at her son to intimidate him but his honesty, purity and righteous of his killing eye lock blackmailed her.
HS wanted finishing everything giving them neck and shouts on them to leave. Kinars have gone, neighbors left and some of them kept waiting beside the door.
HS shouts on Harman saying you played drums and you ruined our honor and respect leave...How can he stops Harak Singh Ji it's the moment of the hisaab. Harman stopped drums and laughed sarcastically with a bitter taste "(Stole your written dialogue 😆)
"This is called Time Preeto .. At one point of time you forced your Bahu to dance with kinners at your doorstep (Hinting about Saumya's 1st kidnap when Preeto plotted with Maninder & Saya to send her with kinners in Harman's absense) , and today your Son is standing in front of you as Dholi of Kinner Group .. What u Sow,so shall your reap , If u plant a babul tree , u wont get mangoes out of it na .. today u r getting the fruits of your own deeds Preeto " 👏👏👏
Preeto is collecting the fruits of her owns deeds. It's her who played with fire. Her ego and selfishness made her heartless .It's who her the cause of what is happening ;she have done all her efforts and sent her babu profiting her husband absence to kinars community turning her Tarana. That time her son still didn't developed love for Saumya as he descovered she's kinars.. Her insecurities and her devils plots made Harman falling madly in Sauumya's love.. Pretoria for her selfish desires didn't respect her son's love and kept planning till she ruined his relation with his wife. Harman is saying her this your Karma and as you played with destiny destiny is giving you your fruits..Your son is now living with kinars He's living their lives and he's drumming dhol begging neck.Open your eyes it's behind your son destiny.You though kicking his wife kinars you will get your son but the great is punishing you for playing with destiny.You have done everything possible even depriving him from your wealth and he's now beggar playing dhol to feed his wife .You kicked his wife from you world ; he have gone to her world and as her world live only begging neck he 's now a dhole ...Harak Singh ka beta turned in Harman ka dhole man.Preeto shocked and and desbelief can't see more her son condition and give him her back but his voice stabbed her heart like a knife When he said her if you don't give me neck tum Harambe beta Will not get food;gurumas said me if you don't give me neck they deprive Saumya from food and she'll sleep starving and you know me if my love don't get food forget about food I'll never take it and even not drink a bit of water. Till now i'm only heartbrocken for Harman and didn't felt anything for Preeto but When Harman begins begging like a real beggar and whom ;his own mon who breaks down m'y heart was pierced and i was Crying loudly with non stp 😭😭😭Here Harman dialogue begging:
"mujhe mera neck dede..Sona Preeto..He maa neck dede(Preeto shaken and outburst answered Ha)dedee neck dede (Preeto crying)dede (Harman his turning his head crying and Preeto heartbrocken in tears turned toward Harak Singh begging money)dede mujhe ...Preeto ..mera neck dedee mujhe "😭😭😭
OMG I was stabbed with Harman the beggar heartbroken in tears ,he
shocked me and my heart was in my mounth as tears muted all words that I can say about ..The ha of preeto after first sentence resulted
shivering with pains like an ill person who is getting fever..Every
beg from Harman is piercing Preeto's heart making her bleeding pains
and in same time is piercing our hearts as viewers..Preeto cries her
heart loudly hearing Harman's begs for neck and Harman is burning her
more😭She Turned to Harak Singh crying begging him money and it was
very difficult for her stepping toward her son giving him the neck and
even Harman is broken in tears and he turned his face when his mom is
putting neck in his hands😭💔😭...Why Harman begged Preeto this way?Harman
can only take the neck when he said her your son will not have food
and talked her about gurumas conditions ..Preeto can't see her son
starving.Harman is giving his mom the same pains and tears he watched them in his wife eyes of loosing someone dear to you.Harman is giving his mom a big lesson by making her collecting the fruits of her
deeds.To make Preeto change he must bear pains and giving her
pains.Preeto should think about change herself for real if she wants
her son back.But like you said we're in daily soap and Preeto will
keep plotting;we have yet their new plan to blast kinar house.
Preeto gave Harman neck and Harman took blessing with making them on his dhol but Preeto took his Hand and it Preeto Promise V Harman
promise.Preeto felt she lost her son and want took the opportunity
making him promising her.Preeto said him I know you're living with
them and now your blessings are powerful like them. I know that god
listen to their blessings.Promise me that you'll keep my son till my
last breath.Preeto was very helpless and weak and want Harman promise
as proof but Harman present intelligence in top of his pains is
remarkable and replied with his teary modulated voice full of sadness
and pains my prayers aren't powerful and if they're ;we will never be in
this situation ..if you want I can make them pray for you 😭Raniwas touched emotionally to mom /son confrontation stepped toward Preeto blessing her in name of all kinars community praying a long live for her relation with her son "I pray in name of kinar samaj that
your relation with your son hamisha salamat rahege"

Harman consoled his mom with a heart touchful dialogue that she's a
good mom and he'll pray to be burn in every other life from her own
womb(khok).This mean that Preeto has lost her son due to her deads.

Harman left and kept his mom who lost him ;Preeto as Harman said she
lost him in this birth so if she want her son back she have to change
as her son himself confessed she's a best mom.I have no issues with
Harman confession as it's his mom and Harman confession is natural;that mom too gave him a good upbringing and if without her we will never watch this Harman .A mom usually have a bestest place in her children hearts even if they're bad ..Harman too didn't know his
mother crime ...May be if Harman have idea about her deadful crimes
he'll will crucify his relation with her.
After Harman leaving Preeto loud screams the way she's crying her
heart on ground shattered my heart in pieces and made me cry😭
kamya here was phenomenal and felt I'm in front of a real mom who lost her son .Preeto was agonizing with pains and uncontrollable;She
entered in an hysteric phase of a trauma of a mom who lost newly her
son forever 😭
In kinar house Saumya give a check to saya and others gurumas :
:"Today I'm silent but tomorrow Harman ji will fullfil all your
conditions and you'll turn silent forver...so You Can Put all the
difficult conditions that you want and we'll make all our efforts to
make you trust in our love (se nods her Head politely)..bas...there
is another thing i'm neither angry like before about what you're doing
nor I'm hurted..Even if you don't give me to eat.. till I'm alive and
till my last breath; I can support starving for Harman ji..But I know
that Harman ji can't see me hungry that's why today I didn't stopped
him"👏

Saumya was phenomenal and make saya and others gurumas that her
silence is for her Harman ji transmitting them that she can starve for
him till her last breath but she knows her love can't watch her paining that's why she didn't. Stopped him as she know s his stubbornness and determination.Saumya after this big humiliation for her husband said them that you can make all difficult conditions and I'll not object or being hurted this means that Saumya turned more strong and rebel taking strength from her husband love to make their love winner and all kinar shut their mouths for ever.Saumya gives the check politely and with respect ;she was fierce,determinant and confident .Really she was phenomenal in her expressions and in the way she delivered her fabulous dialogue and gone leaving saya and gurumas shocked and speechless.
Coming to kareena check ,in kinar house kareena took fan of Preeto
saying shed'habitude done big drama andlaughter about the promis. Harman gets angry and said her she has no right to make fun of his mom.One guruma said to kareena a heartbroken dialogue😭
"we're giving our blessings to moms because we can't be moms ,how
You take fun of a mom pains"😭

Saya furiously asked Kareena to apologize to Harman in an authoritical
mood and Kareena apologized. Here come the telepathy"she'll remain my mom"Saumya heared kinars and kareena making fan of her mam in law ;she felt his pains and the situation he passed and he's love for his mom.Saumya said I know you're angry because of them that's why yougo have gone out .I usually considered your mom as my mom and she'll remaiso same.Saumya herself who was tortured and humiliated by Preeto alike lived in her hesh; she Can't hate her mom in law as she's the mom he her beloved husband;she's the woman who gave birth to her iconhusband husband how can she hate her.
Chota recharge back in his mission and happy watching hum again.Harman isn't only a good and caring husband but is same asson good and caring son.sa said to himself I'm getting food due to your neche ;he was melted and he can't eat as the think about his heartbroken parents so he phonchit chintu and gives hthe the mission to feed his parents.Chota recharge mission sur successful.Harman neither can watch his wife starving nor his mom. All he's doing with his parents is due to their deeds but he's Sam same caring son.
about Surbhi really felt it's unnecessary scene ;why adding salt on
wounds;why saying it 's the great punishment watching her son
becoming Beggar and living with kinars,why saying her your bad days
are coming...???Why using the smart chintu in the scene?
First Surbhi scene can't give an add;Harman himself said her it's
her karma for playing with destiny,Preeto bad days are clear and no
need for Surbhi scene .If Surbhi must do something good she must
tell Harman his mother crimes;this can be good.
The telepathy in precap is hilarious and I I'll talk about the scene
in next retake inchallah.
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#12
Thanks for all the replies 🤗

Running short of time , so not getting time to reply all individually .. will reply to all soon 😳
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: chocolate_boy

It was a real filmy style scene.



Yes filmy scene indeed 😃
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: zubeada

awesome analysis jyoti💔


i loved harman preetoo confrontation very much
it was so heartbreaking & touching
for me its the best scene till today in shakti

but thtsnt mean i will frget wht preetoo did & doing
i want her to be exposed infornt of harman & he should know all her crimes




Yes very touching scene but as usual all our praises went to their head and U know what I mean 😆😆
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: sitakshii

Very well said...hats off to vivean and Kamya...their tears looked real...i just love watching such intense scenes...even sudesh beri is just so fab in expressing his pain as Harmans father...hats off to all these superb actors...this weeks ratings shd b the highest...



Yes performance of all actors were top notch in the scene including Sudesh ji 👏
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: anitarani

B E A U T I F U L...How well you write.. 👏

Admire your patience Jyoti for your viewpoint
on each and every scene. You are bang on...
what was the purpose of bokwas Surbhi's
faltu pravachan to Preeto 😕 Saumya giving
it to Saya very nicely the reason for her
silence...Harman not letting Kareena get
away for insulting his mother...all well said.

But of course ... best of all your lines.. 👍🏼
It was a steller performance by both Vivian and Kamya .. I can say it without any second thoughts that this was indeed Vivian and Kamya's best performance till date in the show 👏👏 .. The Poise along with that Pain in his voice yet the conviction with which Vivian performed the entire scene as if he was actually going through every single emotion of Harman is simply terrific and he deserves a standing ovation for this once in a lifetime performance 👏 .. Kamya was equally brilliant in bringing out the pain , helplessness and the defeated look of a mother who just could not control her tears seeing her son literally begging 👏 ... Take a bow both Vivian and Kamya .. U both were exceptional.


Agree totally with @bold...Vivian/Kamya brilliant...truly their best
scene so far.

Totally agree with your dad...his view on Harman...and hatts
off to Vivian not only for accepting this challenging role to
romance a kinnar...but giving it his best shot...and evolving
so much as an actor.



Surbhi scenes r more like CVs just dunno how to place her in the story , so just give her forced scenes without any head or tail 😆

Vivian is really a phenomenon in this show .. really hats off to him for choosing such an unconcentional role and then doing full justice to it 👏
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: LuvRUBI

Awesome analysis for the superb episode... 👏

Vivian n Kamya were phenomenal in the confrontation scene... excellent performance.. 👏

Harman begging for neg was very painful to watch... it was heart-piercing moment...n yeah, even I felt there was no need for that but it seems he was trying to get her mother back by showing her how her misdeeds is punishing both of them...he was expecting her mother to change... but poor him, his every emotional breakdown goes unnoticed by his heartless parents... god knows in which delusional world they are living... When kinners entered singh house, prito was about to slap them but after giving neg, she didn't forget to ask for blessing.. 😆 ... So harman smartly rejected prito.. wowww thnx for pointing this out coz I didn't noticed it.. 😆 .. N I am ok with harman declaring prito is the best mother...afterall no matter how wrong anyone's mother is, nobody wants to change his mother n for every child, his mother is the best in the world...

Harman took a stand for his mother's respect when kareena was mocking on her, he asked chintu to feed harpreet... it shows how much he loves his parents but still people blame him for giving pain to his parents for his ladylove... coz obviously it's not like they are concerned for harpreet but they have problem with his ladylove.. 😆 ... Alongwith haters, even harpreet need to realise this... actually no... coz I think they know harman loves them so much... but yeah, they need to get the point loud n clear that he can't leave his wife for them... so they should now stop dreaming for something which is impossible to get...

When in last episode, saumya was feeling so bad on learning that harman is going in his colony n she was thinking those flashback scenes, I thought she will go to yell on saaya n company... but she was so polite.. n I realised saumya n yelling...just impossible... but I loved her giving reality-check to them in her mild tone...

Did you heard surbhi's dialogue that she was thinking prito will cut her call seeing her number coz she might have no guts to face her.. 😆 ... At this, I really wanted to ask her what she think of herself... 😆 ... she is just too much... N I don't understand why prito listens her... writers need to think something else to give her scenes.. this unnecessary n forced face-off with prito doesn't make sense at all n it just irritates... why don't they maker her find a job again n just get busy in that...n for god's sake, stop poking nose in haya matters... when haya are worshipping prito as a mother then who the hell is this surbhi to taunt her?... I wish the way harman make kareena shut her mouth, the same way he give some doses to surbhi also...she is thinking so high of herself...she need to bring down on her level...



I agree , only reason why today Harman is not with his parents is because they r always asking him to make a choice between them and his wife .. its just not possible .. what if tomorrow someone ask Preeto or Harak to choose either their lifepartner or their son .. is it possible .. Saumya never asked him to make such a choice whereas his parents r asking him to choose any one .. this is the reason why he is with Saumya and not with his parents .. the day his parents realise this , his dream of eating all together might just come true but that day might b the last episode of this show as well 😆😆

Surbhi is delusional and her scenes look forced too .. what was the need to call Preeto and put salt on her wounds ..its like further instigating Preeto against Saumya by scaring her that her son will forever go away from him .. whats the need ?


jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: thala

👏 post

Before preeto could digest the fact that harman is approaching their house, he was there in front of her with dhol. Despite harak objecting harman to play dhol, the moment he says not to play harman plays it which clearly proves that harman is not gonna act according to the whims and fancies of his parents, they can neither emotionally blackmail him nor can harak threaten him in the name of preeto.

secondly the mother son scenes
a very well written screeplay and crisp dialogues... no bhashan and lambi chaudi dialogues.

when harman says At one point of time you forced your Bahu to dance with kinners at your doorstep ... i started crying, he has the hisab kitab from the beginning .

directly or indirectly preeto is the reason for harman to fall for saumya. everytime she made saumya helpless he had to protect her which eventually turned into love harman made good use of the situation and gave her a fitting reply to all her insecurities. the best part was him saying he cant see saumya in hunger. he starts from saumya and ends it with saumya herself which was evident that she fills his heart completely and there is no place for others and if at all preeto needs her son's love its not possible in this birth.He indirectly says that if you hadnt played havoc in our lives you wouldnt have to beg for your son's love. harman is not yours anymore and he is only saumya's harman.

everything just fell in place
screeplay, dialogues, and not forget vivian's subtle cry maa de de was heartwrenching. be it love or pain he easily does it with his eyes.

one of the memorable episodes of shakti
the quality of the episodes have increased, no filler episodes so far, though we couldnt get proper haya scenes this track is one of the best because of bringing out the depth in every character

we got to see...

1 how far harman can go for his gulabo
2 saumya's deewani avatar
3 a helpless preeto
4 not much of chachi and co nautanki
5 surbhi reduced to a filler
6 last but not the least haya's longing with passion






Very well said ,, I m also glad that Harman remembers everything from the beginning and so smartly he reminds Preeto about bad time comes for everyone .. all will hv to pay their deeds at one point of time ..

And yes indirectly Preeto is the reason why Harman actually fell for Saumya .. Saumya would hv gone back to her mother after 14-15 days as per the condition Nimmi kept with Saya .. Harman wuld hv married again and Preeto wolud hv got her waaris too .. But Preeto told Saya to kidnap Saumya after which Harman went on a mission to save her as part of his responsibility and this is where things went upside down for Preeto .. Preeto's own deeds only r the reason why her son is with Saumya today and not her ..

I agree with all these pointers .. thats why I m loving this track but these CVs r hell bent on spoiling it by bringing this Mohini track now which is so not needed 😡
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: sairitu

Brilliant, yet again a spectacular post from you jyothi. It is just WOW.

👏👏.

I am back to forum with a brief break bec of diwali festival and your bang post welcomed me. Coming to the one of the block buster's episodes ( as i still feel the most emotional ,blockbuster episode was HAYA conversation when harman confessed his love after her truth was out, the way he banged her door to come out, neighbors insisting him to say ILU, that ILU from harman, soumya's reluctance to go with him, his helplessness ,that back ground music, that was the brilliant episode for me),i was awestruck by the great execution of total scene.

I couldn't control my tears when harman literally started begging his mom.it was one of the best emotional, heart breaking scenes that i have ever witnessed on Tv.

Words fell short to appreciate the mind blowing performances of Vivian and Kamya .Vivian was outstanding in bringing those emotions through his suffocated voice and tearful eyes. I haven't seen any male actor portraying such kind of emotional breakdown with that conviction .He was so natural .Kamya was equally good .i always knew she is a brilliant actress thats why we hate her character so much😆.

But i share slightly different POV when it comes to preeto character as good mother. I never felt bad for preeto in the whole scene as she is not a good mother for me. It purely my opinion, anyone can disagree with me. I am not here to hurt anybody's feelings, Hope all understand that.

God created mother as he can't be with us every time. Mother is the only one who loves her kids unconditionally.

A good mother is the one , who disciplines her kids when they are wrong.

A good mother is the one , who equally treats all her kids.

A good mother is the one, who understands her kids when they are in pain.

A good mother is the one, who guides her kids when they are wrong.

A good mother is the one, who wishes only happiness of her kids despite of her pain and sufferings.

A good mother is the one, who will try to find a solution when her kids have a problem.

Preeto is nowhere near to these qualities .A good mother is not the one who over pampers her kids and encourage them to be uneducated. She is always biased towards Harman than raavi. This is basic good quality of a good mother who doesn't see any gender difference. She doesn't even have that. Her love has been always conditional, she is more worried about waris than harman's pain .She left no stone unturned to give pain to Harman through soumya on the name of love. Initially, I can understand her insecurities and concerns as no mother wanted her son to be with a kinnar wife. When she completely understood that harman's love for soumya ,she started reacting more violently towards HAYA. In so many occasions, Harman poured his heart out to preeto saying that he can't survive without soumya and requested her stop ruining their relationship. The way she smiled when Harman was going mad and burning all her things after soumya left him. How could a mother stay calm by seeing her son's pain? I can never forget how she provoked soumya to burn her hands and waited her to scream in pain. even now, she is instigating harak to give soumya's death as her kurwachuth gift.

If Harman had known about this, he would never forgive his parents. They crossed all their limits as parents and human beings too.

So many times we discussed here in this forum that harpreet couldn't be biological parents of Harman as he is a great person .I am still stick to this opinion. yes, Harman can't be a son of those criminal ,inhuman parents. Raavi has got more of their qualities but not Harman.

I can't give credit to harpreet upbringing for harman's good nature, humanity and kind heart.

On one side, harak dances on his wife tunes and does support her in all her criminal activities and other side he taunts his son's undying love for his wife. And now,he planned to kill his bahu and so many innocent lives without a second thought.What kind of parents are they?

I really hope ,one day Harpreet will have change of heart and accept soumya as their bahu,before that i want them to be exposed fully in front of harman and get punished for their criminal deeds .



I agree with all your pointers about the definition of a good mother and yes from that angle we can say Preeto mayb a failure as a mother but thats our perspective and we r not biologically related to Preeto 😆 ... If u see from Harman's perspective who is her son , its obvious for him his mother will always b the best .. its true in case of every son and daughter ..

When he sees Preeto begging for a promise from him that he will always remain his son in this birth , he knew that he cannot give her this promise as it will mean leaving Saumya .. so to console her from crying further , he just said u will remain the best mother and May I take birth from your womb in every birth .. So if u see the scene carefully he dint give her the promise she wanted but instead he said those words to her just to stop her from crying as its painful for every son to see his mother beg for a promise which he cannot fulfill ..

And yes Harman still does not know many things about Preeto which is another reason too .. but even then he cannot really beat his mother in the name of punishment .. Max he can do is leave her which he already did ..




jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 7 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: Estadra

thanks for the amazing post

that scene was amazing. I enjoyed it. but the truth is that I do not agree with some things.

I felt from this scene that the creators made the Preeto a victim. Jyoti are right, Harman probably said she was the best mother because she cared for he all Harman life with love.

but after what Preeto found out that Souma is a kinnar, what she did has nothing to do with love for her son. because every mother wants the happiness of her son. Harman said a million times that if something Souma will be, wrong, he will not be able to live. Preeto is interested only in her ego, grandchildren, and reputation. nothing else. and therefore I, I could not sympathize with the Preto in this scene.

the scene when Harman came into the house was amazing. Harak Singh wanted to scream something about "casam", but Harman started playing the drum, so no Kasam . smart. I liked the determination in Harman's eyes on Preto. at one point his eyes were cold on Preeto . as if he were standing outside a stranger. Harman told Preto the truth, she pushed Souma into the kinnar of the world to dance and ask for neg, and now she is there as well.

I almost broke my heart when Harman begged Preeto to neg as he set his hand. I regretted Harman. but not Preeto. it's all her fault.

The Preeto wanted an oath that Harman would be her son in her last breath, and here Harman was smart, he promised to pray that her son would be the next birth. Here perhaps the creators suggest that Harman one day will find the truth (if that happens) Harman will have a broken heart, and maybe the relationship mother and son will not be the same.

Harman left, and Preeto was broken. but she deserves it. Harman is a jewel, not only defending his mother in front of Kinnar, but calling Chinto to feed Preto.

I had a problem. at one moment the Preeto was hysterical about the loss of her son, and in the second moment she had a hateful look. I feel her problem is not a son's loss, her problem is that kinnar wins, and Preeto loses. again, ego.

on twitter, an actor played by Virna, gave a video where KC is celebrated in singh house, it's luxurious. beautiful decoration, beautiful clothes. I do not know what's going to happen, I hope something good happens.

precap: I'm happy that Harman is there too. but I do not think Souma tells Harman the truth. but Harman is smart, he should figure it out for himself.



I agree that in this episode CVs did try to glorify Preeto as a victim which she is clearly not .. yes I did feel bad for the mother here but the truth is Preeto the human being is not a victim from any angle , so CVs should not forget that viewers r still waiting for her to b exposed fully .. such epis might make us emotional for one day but it cannot really make us forget Preeto's evil deeds ..

About the promise , I hv this feeling too that this dialogue will hv a future connection once Preeto is fully exposed .. mayb then Harman will regret for wanting such a mother in every birth and might tell her the opposite dialogue .. lets see ..

And yes her main problem is loosing her son to a kinner .,. its more of her ego issue which sort of overshadows the pain of a mother ..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".