Harman's Big Fat Lie to Soumya ..Right or Wrong? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2k

Users

6

Likes

45

Frequent Posters

jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: Pani.Puri



Finally I had a Shakti marathon from last week's Friday episode till yesterday's episode ... Gosh ... After ages I'm seeing this show and this whole weeks episodes dint dissapoint me ... Probably this is what I always wanted to see since last september , BUT dont know why CV's were so stupid ... But now that I have watched this week's episode , I have again started to like this show and I'm looking forward to watch the next week's episodes ... I hope you wont mind if I mix up my thoughts from last week's Friday episode ... Ohk so I'm confused a lot ... Who killed that TG ??? Is there any possibility that in future we might get to know that person ?? I appalaud that TG's acting .. It was a heart touching scene when Harman calls that person with respect and the answer that came from that TG's mouth was so emotional ... Respect for them ... I felt bad when the crowd bashed that TG and Harman came to that person's rescue followed by gun shot and the way that TG blessed Harman .. My eyes became moist with that whole scene of the market ... There do exist such kinds of demons in this world ... I just cant beleive this that Varbhi marriage and SR was so short ... Was he the same editor tor who is editing Shakti or the PH borrowed from another show ???? Well whatever it is , I'm happy that they dint stretched the unnecessary family drama ... Oh man ... I just loved this intense HaYa hug ... This hug held lots of emotions from love to fear or loosing to posessivenss to care to concern ... This has to be the second best hug of HaYa and the first longest hug ... Awww Harman , I can understand his fear and situation ... I couldnt comprehend Saumya's expression when Harman all of a sudden changed his stance to acting ... Did she catch his lie and just to sooth him she smiled or is she actually unaware and came into Harman's lie of director and acting ???? I want the first one to be correct but then looking at the other episodes she seems to have believed Harman's lie of director asking him to act ... Varun in his whole life did 2 best things and so god will fogive all his sins ... The first one is to marry Surbhi and the second one is to leave Singh house ... Preeto's look made me laug when Varun turned the tables on her by getting out of the house ... Finally a relief ... Oh heavens !! All are psycho in Singh house kya ??? Wasnt Shanno Raavi enoug that now Balwinder is also added in the list ?? More than positive characters this show has all negative things ... And now I'm actually tired of Shanno Ravi's taunting session .. Why dont they just stop their bloody mouth when they know that everytime they get insulted ... Actually , RaNno's taunt and insulting session is getting too repetitve and boring that now they should just cut this crap ...

Ishu I m so happy that finally u caught up with the episodes .. I knew u will love it😃 .. yes this is what we all HaYa fans were waiting for ... a track which focusses fully on HaYa .. and finally we get it .. Harman's fear was quite justified after he saw that horrific incident in market and whats bothering him more is that he could not save the kinner despite his presense there , so now his fear is tomorrow if Soumya's truth is out and he fails to save her from the mob , then what ? .. no wonder he wants to go and settle down in abroad with her because outside the country noone will bother even if everyone comes to know that Soumya is a kinner but in Gurdaspur or for that matter any place in India , it will b a big issue if people find out Harman's wife is a kinner .. Earlier it never bothered Harman and he himself wanted to tell all about her identity but now the scare of loosing her is bothering him and he wants to hide the truth ..


Agree about the hug .. finally the editor got drunk mayb and dint edit that long HaYa hug .. small mercy on us 😆😳 .. I feel Soumya believed Harman's lie about the director as we can see in next episodes .. so she thought he was just teasing her as usual .. And yes Varun did something finally .. first marrying Surbhi and then taking her away from Singh house 😆.. Raavi Shanno taunts r indeed getting repitative ..hope CVs stop it fully

Now finally coming to all Harman , Saumya and Haya scene's .. Now this is what Shakti is all about .. Its ONLY about their journey and their struggle ... I feel all these things indicates that very soon society vs Haya track will come bcz things are going quite good now and it makes sense if all this is just a build up for society vs HaYa track ... Harman's dilema , fear of loosing his life Gulabo , posessiveness is understood bcz what he has witnessed actually makes person insane ... He always wanted to get justice for that TG but then whatever that policeman said about media is also true ... Media can cook up a story just for their profit and in our country media still plays a pivotal role in deciding or judging about a person ... Till date Harman never feared about Saumya's identity but what he saw in the market + the hatred reaction he got from the crowd for a TG has made him thoughtfull and fearfull for his Gulabo ... He has now understood this fact that whatsoever , this society wont accept or love or like TG community .. This society has looked on TG with hatred and will continue doing so and the society can accuse TG ppl even for a crime they have not done and then lynching them etc etc ... So now Harman understand's not only Nimmi's fear but also the repurcursion that will arise once Saumya's truth is known to the world ... And so his fear , posessivness makes sense .. The talk he had with his innerself was good to see .. Both are right at their own places (what Harman thinks and what his innerslef said) , but when reality has to be faced then that time decisions has to be taken in such a manner that it wont ruin things and in such situations choices have to be made ... He was right that he is not an activist who can get justice for that TG bcz for him , his world gulabo matters ... Even if he gets justice for that TG then he would loose his Saumya forever ... Well that reminds me that what if Harman takes help from an activist or an NGO working for TG's ??? He can take their help to get that TG justice ??? I actually want a balance here ... In future they can show that Harman either takes NGO or any activists help or maybe if in future a character turns positive then he can take their help to get them justice (but I dont think so that it will happen) ... I actually want both the things - justice and Saumya's truth not getting revealed ... Coming to yesterday's episode - who the hell is intrested in VarBhi ka family planning ??? I want that now Preeto should be given less footage bcz this lady is getting on my nerves ... Her acting and irritating scenes just makes me pissed off ... Why cant she be in peace ??? Like ssly ... Calling his so called spy agent for spying ... If in future they want to show Mu b/w HaYa then only they both should be the reason and not any 3rd person ... What does Preeto want ??? Isnt she happy seeing his son infront of him that again she has started her spying and planning and making his son go away from him ???? Some one plz tweet CVs to cut Preeto's drama and her work of interfering in others life ... Harman is not a kid anymore that he wont know what is right or wrong ... And someone plz tell me that who all are goi rd ?? I dont want VarBhi or Preeto Harakh going abroad with Haya and spoling our mood ...

As per new promo it seems Preeto will play with Soumya's mind and brainwash her that Harman only loves her beauty and not identity , thats why embarassed to reveal her identity to the world .. And when she asks Harman if its true , he remains silent .. So it seems Preeto will take advantage of Harman's fear .. Harman will b quiet to protect Soumya from the society as revealing her identity will bring danger to her life which Soumya is unaware of .. But Soumya will assume he is quiet because he feels embarassed with her identity 😭 .. So I think lack of communication and hidden truth will result in the MU .. Plus Harman also lied Soumya about Adi matter which could b last nail in coffin ... But I m sure Harman will also do the damage control and clear Soumya's doubts because we hv seen the extreme to which he loves her and can do anything for her

I feel only HaYa will go abroad but separately .. mayb Soumya will go first thinking Harman is embarassed with her identity , so better to leave the country because Harman too wanted her to leave country and thats why lied about Adi .. Harman will then chase her all the way to bring her back and also might tell her the truth behind his behaviour and also about that horrific kinner incident in market .. I feel this mini separation will lead to Soumya's confession too as she will realise the depth of Harman's love for her and it will also result in Harman overoming his fears ...





Ishu do make a separate post for VarBhi marriage celebrations come AT 😆 .. after all we waitied for this moment for long 😉😆 ..

My replies in blue ..
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: anitarani

Super se upar wala post...you have again done a great

job in explaining well Harman's fear...the reason...for his
resorting to lying to his precious Gulabo...and all...You
seem to really be a part of CVs team giving us their
detailed version...which i really appreciate...Agree with
all...Especially with your afterthought...true...for
Harman...his family don't matter at all...he respects
them to an extent that is required of him...nothing
more...he has seen the extent of their deceit...and
he knows they are capable of more and worst...and
the only one who is most faithful to him right now is
gulabo...and she is the only one who will come
foremost in his life...separation or no separation...



Anita I really wish I was part of CV team .. would hv shown HaYa only for full 20 mins 😆😆

Agree that Harman respects his family and will fulfill all his duties as a son .. but thats it .. his family hv lost that special place in his heart now ... Its only Gulabo who has that place in his heart .. Well his family deserve it .. I still cant believe Harak and Preeto just stood there like statues and dint come to save Harman when he was held on gun point
jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Flora15

Dear Ishu saying adored your awsome post isn't enough ...you really neeed big claps 👏 and hats off sweety you nailed it ..Where are you my dear?Forum need wise persons like you plzzz don't stop watching the show again eaven if there is ups and downs in it.Shakti need reflective persons like you who can catch and understand meanings &moral dimensions of every single scene .Ishu you nailed it &i adored you deeply analisis.I have nothing to add and i share with you your POV...I say yes everything is fair in war &love...It's very tough &hearting for Harman to lie his Gulabo using her weakness as his strengh to leave with her the hell forever.Harman who never lied his gulabo and he never tough that one day he will lie her ;find himself commiting a big lie risking his relation with SaumYa ...Harman is lieing for godness to take his gulabo in a safety place...All he know that he's gulabo lover and for that love he's up to do anything .Hate lieing but i take Harman side here bcz he have no choice he can't live in his city with fear of loosing her at any moment.He can't take Justice for that TG murder if he do they'll point him in question and Saumya identity can be revealed...He can't talk with Saumya directly that he want live with her so far away in an other country safety and in peace...Saumya will automatcally refuse that's he used Aditya fake news to quit the country risking with his relation ...He know that it will be a great misunderstood between him &Saumya when she descovers that but he 's thinking for Saumya safety first...Sure Preeto drama can't end and she'll fool Saumya brain against Harman (the promo shared by rashmi Sharma today show that)

I'll say both Harman & Saumya are facing a new phase in their journey &this phase is very important for their life as a couple ..'We have see Harman with his innerself battle ..I think the first battle is with yourself first to get strengh to face the world (Harman is really in battle with himself)...SaumYa will too do that battle with herself to get that strengh if you concentrate in the promo of first july you'll find Saumya in front of mirrors and in two avatars :first Saumya and second the identity(TG) She will fight with her identity and i think she 'll be winner .I have usually positive thinking& can't be negative...Both Saumya and Harman will live great battle,missunderstoods ,storm of obstacles but their love story is more stronger and their soulmates are connected forever...When two soulmates are one nothing can separate them and love is winner.



Flora dont worry .. Ishu is quite loyal to HaYa .. she stops watching every now and then when track goes a bit off but then returns back again after getting our updates 😆

And yes HaYa hv enterted a very interesting phase of their life .. till now Harman never really gave a thought that what would happen if Soumya's truth comes out .. he was quite sure that he will handle it but after the market incident , he sort of lost that confidence in himself as he could not save that kinner .. and this is what triggered the fear in his mind about Soumya ... he now wants to protect her identity from the world at any cost ...

But this is what might create Misunderstanding in Soumya's mind as she will think till now he never really showed any worry or fear about her identity .. so then why now all of a sudden he does not want to let out the truth .. Is he embarassed with my idenity ? .. These doubts and confusions will cast a shadow in their relation ..

But all this will also make their relationship stronger than before .. When Soumya will know the full reason behind his fear , she will start respecting and loving her Harmanji more 😳 ..And Harman's love we can already see in these episodes .. the extreme to which he can go for his Gulabo even if it means leaving the country ..

I wrote about my take on the promo in your post .. plss do read it .. 😳


Pani.Puri thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: anitarani

Ishu...i simply loved your post...and your hilarious comments

...especially:

Varun in his whole life did 2 best things and so god will fogive all his sins ... The first one is to marry Surbhi and the second one is to leave Singh house ... Preeto's look made me laug when Varun turned the tables on her by getting out of the house ... Finally a relief ...


Thanks Anita 😳😳😳

I want him to do the 3rd best thing of getting babies and then get lost with his wife forever 🤣🤣
Pani.Puri thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Flora15

Dear Ishu saying adored your awsome post isn't enough ...you really neeed big claps 👏 and hats off sweety you nailed it ..Where are you my dear?Forum need wise persons like you plzzz don't stop watching the show again eaven if there is ups and downs in it. Ummm ... I'm allergic to so much of praises and appreciations for myself 😳😳 The show was getting boring so dint watch it .. But then on twitter Bhawna , Susmita and Jyoti told me to watch this weeks episode and on their saying I watched it and I really enjoyed watching it .. Now I will try to be regular , BUT on the condition that CV's keep this kind of episodes everyday , else I will puncture their cars/bikes tyres 🤣🤣

Shakti need reflective persons like you who can catch and understand meanings &moral dimensions of every single scene . Jyoti is master in this ... I always like her deeep dimension and thought process + analysis of every scene 😳😳😳


Ishu you nailed it &i adored you deeply analisis.I have nothing to add and i share with you your POV...I say yes everything is fair in war &love... I will agree with this saying on love and war ... And I will choose love over war anytime , especially if the love story is of HaYa 😈😈


It's very tough &hearting for Harman to lie his Gulabo using her weakness as his strengh to leave with her the hell forever.Harman who never lied his gulabo and he never tough that one day he will lie her ;find himself commiting a big lie risking his relation with SaumYa ...Harman is lieing for godness to take his gulabo in a safety place...All he know that he's gulabo lover and for that love he's up to do anything .Hate lieing but i take Harman side here bcz he have no choice he can't live in his city with fear of loosing her at any moment.He can't take Justice for that TG murder if he do they'll point him in question and Saumya identity can be revealed...He can't talk with Saumya directly that he want live with her so far away in an other country safety and in peace...Saumya will automatcally refuse that's he used Aditya fake news to quit the country risking with his relation ...He know that it will be a great misunderstood between him &Saumya when she descovers that but he 's thinking for Saumya safety first... After thinking a lot , I will go with Harman's love for Saumya .. I mean we are humans and its psychology , that humans top priority is always there near and dear ones whom they adore and love ... And humans can go to any extent to protect and safeguard their loved one's , even if it means doing the impossible thing ... And Harman is no robot or god who will be different ... And so just like other humans , even he chose his priority rather than justice ... Thinking practically then every person chooses their loved one's over other things ... So its quite natural of what Harman did .. He is not a saint or a magician who could do everything ...



Sure Preeto drama can't end and she'll fool Saumya brain against Harman (the promo shared by rashmi Sharma today show that) And this is the only thing I dont want ... I just cant stand this lady's tricks and games .. Why she always do something like that and pushes away his son from herself , and then later cry and beg for his son 😆😆😆


I'll say both Harman & Saumya are facing a new phase in their journey &this phase is very important for their life as a couple ..'We have see Harman with his innerself battle ..I think the first battle is with yourself first to get strengh to face the world (Harman is really in battle with himself)...SaumYa will too do that battle with herself to get that strengh if you concentrate in the promo of first july you'll find Saumya in front of mirrors and in two avatars :first Saumya and second the identity(TG) She will fight with her identity and i think she 'll be winner .I have usually positive thinking& can't be negative...Both Saumya and Harman will live great battle,missunderstoods ,storm of obstacles but their love story is more stronger and their soulmates are connected forever...When two soulmates are one nothing can separate them and love is winner. Haya have seen ugliest of things in their relationship - from kidnapping to all ... So I think even this separation will just make their bond more stronger and more determined .. It will increase their love towards each other to another level and that is what Haya is all about



I liked your thinking about Haya ... You're always positive about their lovestory 😳😳


Pani.Puri thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: jyoti06


Ishu I m so happy that finally u caught up with the episodes .. I knew u will love it😃 .. yes this is what we all HaYa fans were waiting for ... a track which focusses fully on HaYa .. and finally we get it .. Harman's fear was quite justified after he saw that horrific incident in market and whats bothering him more is that he could not save the kinner despite his presense there , so now his fear is tomorrow if Soumya's truth is out and he fails to save her from the mob , then what ? .. no wonder he wants to go and settle down in abroad with her because outside the country noone will bother even if everyone comes to know that Soumya is a kinner but in Gurdaspur or for that matter any place in India , it will b a big issue if people find out Harman's wife is a kinner .. Earlier it never bothered Harman and he himself wanted to tell all about her identity but now the scare of loosing her is bothering him and he wants to hide the truth .. True ... Had it been anyother country then there would have been no fear ... But in India so many things are considered as taboo so Harman's fear are quite justified ...


Agree about the hug .. finally the editor got drunk mayb and dint edit that long HaYa hug .. small mercy on us 😆😳 .. I feel Soumya believed Harman's lie about the director as we can see in next episodes .. so she thought he was just teasing her as usual .. And yes Varun did something finally .. first marrying Surbhi and then taking her away from Singh house 😆.. Raavi Shanno taunts r indeed getting repitative ..hope CVs stop it fully I wanted Saumya to not to believe Harman's lie about the director but it seems that it was needed for separation ... Next time we should go for RaNno trending to chop of their taunting session 🤣



As per new promo it seems Preeto will play with Soumya's mind and brainwash her that Harman only loves her beauty and not identity , thats why embarassed to reveal her identity to the world .. And when she asks Harman if its true , he remains silent .. So it seems Preeto will take advantage of Harman's fear .. Harman will b quiet to protect Soumya from the society as revealing her identity will bring danger to her life which Soumya is unaware of .. But Soumya will assume he is quiet because he feels embarassed with her identity 😭 .. So I think lack of communication and hidden truth will result in the MU .. Plus Harman also lied Soumya about Adi matter which could b last nail in coffin ... But I m sure Harman will also do the damage control and clear Soumya's doubts because we hv seen the extreme to which he loves her and can do anything for her That is why I am not that angry with Preeto bcz I know Harman can go to any extent to protect his love and keep her with him (aisi deewangi dekhi nahi kahin 😆) ... Maybe in abroad they will show Haya's patchup 😳😳 But whatever it is I hope CV's dont mess up with this awesome track bcz this track is the turning point + it is needed not only to move the story further , but also it will strengthen their relationship 😳😳😳

I feel only HaYa will go abroad but separately .. This is what I want 🤣🤣 Other than HaYa no other star cast should go to abroad and spoil the Haya scenes 😆😆😆

mayb Soumya will go first thinking Harman is embarassed with her identity , so better to leave the country because Harman too wanted her to leave country and thats why lied about Adi .. Harman will then chase her all the way to bring her back and also might tell her the truth behind his behaviour and also about that horrific kinner incident in market .. I feel this mini separation will lead to Soumya's confession too as she will realise the depth of Harman's love for her and it will also result in Harman overoming his fears ... Arey isi ka toh humey intezar hai ki Saumya kab ILU bolegi 😆😆 I hope this is what even CVs are planning as a separation track




Ishu do make a separate post for VarBhi marriage celebrations come AT 😆 .. after all we waitied for this moment for long 😉😆 .. Yeah will make in sometime 😆😆

My replies in blue ..
Pani.Puri thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: jyoti06



Flora dont worry .. Ishu is quite loyal to HaYa .. she stops watching every now and then when track goes a bit off but then returns back again after getting our updates 😆 Yeah ... That is why I have to ask you all constantly that how is the show going so that I can start watching it 😆😆😆

And yes HaYa hv enterted a very interesting phase of their life .. till now Harman never really gave a thought that what would happen if Soumya's truth comes out .. he was quite sure that he will handle it but after the market incident , he sort of lost that confidence in himself as he could not save that kinner .. and this is what triggered the fear in his mind about Soumya ... he now wants to protect her identity from the world at any cost ...

But this is what might create Misunderstanding in Soumya's mind as she will think till now he never really showed any worry or fear about her identity .. so then why now all of a sudden he does not want to let out the truth .. Is he embarassed with my idenity ? .. These doubts and confusions will cast a shadow in their relation ..

But all this will also make their relationship stronger than before .. When Soumya will know the full reason behind his fear , she will start respecting and loving her Harmanji more 😳 ..And Harman's love we can already see in these episodes .. the extreme to which he can go for his Gulabo even if it means leaving the country ..

I wrote about my take on the promo in your post .. plss do read it .. 😳 I am just waiting for this intense passionate scenes bcz right now this is what is needed b/w Haya ... Enough of their lovey dovey moments and cooking sessions 😆😆😆


jyoti06 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Master Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#18
@Ishu : PH cannot afford to take entire cast aborad .. so only HaYa 😆 .. they cant even afford new clothes for the male lead .. how can they afford entire cast tickets to abroad 😆 .. so dont worry its only HaYa ..

I really hope they dont mess up the abroad track .. it should b just HaYa focussed and intense 😳
Flora15 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: jyoti06



Flora dont worry .. Ishu is quite loyal to HaYa .. she stops watching every now and then when track goes a bit off but then returns back again after getting our updates 😆

And yes HaYa hv enterted a very interesting phase of their life .. till now Harman never really gave a thought that what would happen if Soumya's truth comes out .. he was quite sure that he will handle it but after the market incident , he sort of lost that confidence in himself as he could not save that kinner .. and this is what triggered the fear in his mind about Soumya ... he now wants to protect her identity from the world at any cost ...

But this is what might create Misunderstanding in Soumya's mind as she will think till now he never really showed any worry or fear about her identity .. so then why now all of a sudden he does not want to let out the truth .. Is he embarassed with my idenity ? .. These doubts and confusions will cast a shadow in their relation ..

But all this will also make their relationship stronger than before .. When Soumya will know the full reason behind his fear , she will start respecting and loving her Harmanji more 😳 ..And Harman's love we can already see in these episodes .. the extreme to which he can go for his Gulabo even if it means leaving the country ..

I wrote about my take on the promo in your post .. plss do read it .. 😳


Yes my dear you're totally right and read yours POV in my promo post ..I enjoyed reading your takes &Ishu takes there and sorry for answering you too late bcz i'm busy with tweeter and pms. ..Be sue that i enjoy all post in forum specially yours &Ishu post ..They are very reflective posts..God bless all forums members who are doing great job in forum.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".