Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.8k

Users

10

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

munnihyderabad thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

there is not a single instance .. where people are happy with the replacement .. yeah some accept the change and move on .. but there will be a section of people .. who cannot take any replacement in a positive way..

be it a cricket captain replaced or be it a company CEO replaced or be it a new Prime Minister being elected.. there is always a chunk of population who would not want to accept the change...

they would have got used to Dev for 2 years... and when the other actor comes .. she would have faced what Dev is facing right now..

and there are some like me .. who accept and move on.. if dev was replaced with the other actor.. i would have accepted the other actor with equal reverence with which i now accepted Dev...
ruddymole thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Gia did a great work to bring charm to the character gopi.Even SP,PH knew it very well and their ego doesn't let them to accept it.Now we are seeing only the changed version of saathiya and not real saathiya...
Giafan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: munnihyderabad


there is not a single instance .. where people are happy with the replacement .. yeah some accept the change and move on .. but there will be a section of people .. who cannot take any replacement in a positive way..

be it a cricket captain replaced or be it a company CEO replaced or be it a new Prime Minister being elected.. there is always a chunk of population who would not want to accept the change...

they would have got used to Dev for 2 years... and when the other actor comes .. she would have faced what Dev is facing right now..

and there are some like me .. who accept and move on.. if dev was replaced with the other actor.. i would have accepted the other actor with equal reverence with which i now accepted Dev...

Yes. Munni. you are a very practical person. You accept anything in your life. But, we can't accept each and everyone. Even, if we fall in love with someone, we will make sure, that particular person is worth our love. if we love some one, we will stick with them, no matter what., And about Dev, got replaced, ppl, will fight for her, When her show preeto abruptly ended in imagine TV, who fought for her? was there any protest for Dev? sorry, i couldn't recollect. And you said ppl. will accept dev, if they see her, for 2 years, they protest for her, well that is your opinion.,your fallacy. we can't do anything for that.
munnihyderabad thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Giafan

Yes. Munni. you are a very practical person. You accept anything in your life. But, we can't accept each and everyone. Even, if we fall in love with someone, we will make sure, that particular person is worth our love. if we love some one, we will stick with them, no matter what., And about Dev, got replaced, ppl, will fight for her, When her show preeto abruptly ended in imagine TV, who fought for her? was there any protest for Dev? sorry, i couldn't recollect. And you said ppl. will accept dev, if they see her, for 2 years, they protest for her, well that is your opinion.,your fallacy. we can't do anything for that.



ok i didn;t want to give any explanations to any one... but since u have quoted and highlighted... i have 2 points to say...

@red - this is not my life.. and no one here, No ONE, knows what i am like in my life and how i deal with my personal issues..this is precisely with respect to a TV show in my life for which i definitely don't want to be emotional and be crying over spilled milk, like a teenage kid ,,,

@blue... I replied to the topic maker's POV where it is a hypothetical situation .. had Dev been gopi from the beginning and replaced by someone else..
so please do not try to dilute and deviate the topic and i do not wish to comment on imagine or preeto or Dev's last show... my reply is strictly to the topic makers question...
Giafan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

I think, U were the one who said, THERE ARE SOME LIKE ME, WHO ACCEPT AND MOVE ON, so that , i brought that subject. Who said, we are talking about some body's personal life? did I say? In my previous post, I said some one, that some one is our GIAA. we loved her, we stuck with her. Here again,You are the one, deviating the topic. The TM, asked what will happen, when Dev happens to be the original GOPI, for that only ,we are all answering. I think you are the one talked about MOVING ON in your previous post. We are discussing about Giaa and Dev. i don't know, where is your MOVING ON thing, fits here. pls. here i am not talking about anybody's personal life. Now, you have promoted us, from TODDLERS THROWING TANTRUMS to TEENAGE KID who are crying over the spilled milk, and emotional. Thanx for that PROMOTION.

YOU ,be a practical person, you accepted the change and moved on. We are not like that!!!!!. We want, what we want. I don't think, WE, BEING EMOTIONAL, the world will turn upside down. We always stick with our views. NO COMPROMISE. srry.
ShaunSA thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: roseylinda

If Newbie is the first Gopi of SNS, how the soap will be. Will it get the success what it acheived for 2 years.What about Trp 7...Any guess.


In life nothing is impossible 😊
Saathfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: SNS_fan101

I agree Viji , for a serial to be popular, i think the characters/ actors play a big role.. also, especially for a lead role, newbie does not suit it either way (acting or apperance).. I think if SNS started with newbie, then it would have the highest TRP of maybe 3.5.. and it would end within 4-6 months.
and also, if SNS started with newbie, I wouldnt even watch the show in the first place 😆


It would have failed first week. New girl is way average in looks and frankly I dislike her nose immensely. Gia had a confidence that gave her a huge screen presence. In any scene new girl can be a piece of set furniture an no one will notice. Gia was full of life even when crying her heart out this new girl looks depressed and as no charisma. Gia spoke fluent Hindi and had the Gujarati touch. New girl does not have Gujarati features or dialect she is a misfit. I don't think I will personally watch any show that she is lead actress in. She fits the role of a rajpal nagar neighbor or Mithi.
Edited by Saathfan - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".