First time felt bad for new Gopi - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

3.8k

Users

11

Likes

70

Frequent Posters

megustajalebi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11
.

Originally posted by: -Vanshikaa-

I agree with all you have said but I will like to add ;
🤣 To sum it all, person basically said 2 main things;
1) her frame does not suit the role, its hard to digest her as a pregnant woman
2) In the image of Gopi vau, her expressions are not upto par

I believe you are giving constructive criticism a name of bashing over here which is wrong. I know she can't change her "natural looks" but that is WHAT GOT HER the role. It's all about acceptance which takes time. If you expect people to sit on IF and sing aartis and bhaajans for characters/actors 24/7..its really silly. This is India-Forums not India-Fansite. We are here to discuss. By accusing every poster who makes such posts a "basher" you guys are taking advantage of the system over here.



Maybe it's not taken as seriously. The Balika Vadhu forum takes the comparasions and body bashing seriously, so maybe I've been spoiled 😆

To the green:
She's like 2-3 months pregnant. Not 8 months dude. I don't know how her frame does not suit a pregnant woman in her early stages

To the blue:
I didn't comment on the expressions part because I didn't see a problem regarding the body snarking. So I don't why you even brought that up. I specifically was talking about the body structure comment.

Um, I'm not part of the group that is into praying for the show 😆 . Nothing I said indicated that. I just don't think it's right to make negative comments about an actress's looks. But like I said, since I comment more on Balika Vadhu, and they take this stuff more seriously, I may have excessively high expectations

Mohabbateinn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#12
Chalo choro lol, nothing is consistent over IF..thats the problem. Well, hopefully this is a matter of concern that mods will look into over time.. just thought you should check this out :P


tc,
Vanshi :)
megustajalebi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: -Vanshikaa-

Chalo choro lol, nothing is consistent over IF..thats the problem. Well, hopefully this is a matter of concern that mods will look into over time.. just thought you should check this out :P



tc,
Vanshi :)


Good topic. Was this posted on the Saathiya forum? I really like this sentence because it's extremely needed in this forum at this point:

I think MODS need to send out a global message to IFians about STOPPING this worshipping of CHARACTERS and TYING THIS INTO THE REAL ACTORS life becuz then the issue of targetting one another can be dealt with

Appropriate for the "Gopi = Gia" comments that sometimes pop up 😛
Mohabbateinn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#14
thanks dear :) no i havent but if u like u can share it ..im sure its a much needed wake up call for many over here...which is why im not a regular on the SNS forum because of all the patronising that goes on here.. lmao
megustajalebi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: -Vanshikaa-

thanks dear :) no i havent but if u like u can share it ..im sure its a much needed wake up call for many over here...which is why im not a regular on the SNS forum because of all the patronising that goes on here.. lmao


Oh believe me, I can understand. I'm usually on IF to comment on Balika Vadhu and prior to this fiasco, I rarely posted on SNS (which is why one user thought I was affiliated with SP and was swaying people haha).

I'll think about sharing it with this forum. The environment was so tense for the past few days and it's calm right now so I don't want to start a spark (and the thread gets shut down b/c it's from another forum). Nonetheless, a very good topic 😊
jolin_CM thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#16
I too felt the same. It is too early for her to portray as pregnant lady...Moreover she is a new face and now the viewers accept it so soon...
All the scenes from 7th on ways she is having the same expressions in face and there is no modification in it according to the situations...
She looks same in all the scenes , near KoKila, Rashi...last Ahemmm.
megustajalebi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: jolin_CM

I too felt the same. It is too early for her to portray as pregnant lady...Moreover she is a new face and now the viewers accept it so soon...

All the scenes from 7th on ways she is having the same expressions in face and there is no modification in it according to the situations...
She looks same in all the scenes , near KoKila, Rashi...last Ahemmm.


Gia had the same problem, she always had a confused look on her face when she was around people.
It makes me think that it's the director's fault, like he tells her to do this. It's one thing if one actress does this, but now two actresses have done this. It can't be a coincidence
gauri72 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: jolin_CM

I too felt the same. It is too early for her to portray as pregnant lady...Moreover she is a new face and now the viewers accept it so soon...

All the scenes from 7th on ways she is having the same expressions in face and there is no modification in it according to the situations...
She looks same in all the scenes , near KoKila, Rashi...last Ahemmm.


Most of us are going to compare them for the expressions point of view.This is genuine discussion because this is saathiya, here fans are used to listen dialogues by Jina's eyes. They both dont speak too much like Akshara and Naitik of Ye rishta... So no one can tell this is bashing If u tell it bashing, then tell me we were not critisizing/ bashing characters, actors and CVs before Giaa left.

We enjoyed it a lot. Now also it should be enjoyed without accusing of bashing.This is not a praising club.Here u can tell dirty jokes also write tooo much inti🤬mate scene also. then why not criticism.If u talk about healthy critisism and not bashing than why all jokes and intimate scenes are not sensored.As school students also read such posts.
No offence to any one.This was not my negativity.
Mohabbateinn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: gauri72


Most of us are going to compare them for the expressions point of view.This is genuine discussion because this is saathiya, here fans are used to listen dialogues by Jina's eyes. They both dont speak too much like Akshara and Naitik of Ye rishta... So no one can tell this is bashing If u tell it bashing, then tell me we were not critisizing/ bashing characters, actors and CVs before Giaa left.

We enjoyed it a lot. Now also it should be enjoyed without accusing of bashing.This is not a praising club.Here u can tell dirty jokes also write tooo much inti🤬mate scene also. then why not criticism.If u talk about healthy critisism and not bashing than why all jokes and intimate scenes are not sensored.As school students also read such posts.
No offence to any one.This was not my negativity.


🤗👏 well said, much respect for u dear! u said it best 👍🏼
megustajalebi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: gauri72


Most of us are going to compare them for the expressions point of view.This is genuine discussion because this is saathiya, here fans are used to listen dialogues by Jina's eyes. They both dont speak too much like Akshara and Naitik of Ye rishta... So no one can tell this is bashing If u tell it bashing, then tell me we were not critisizing/ bashing characters, actors and CVs before Giaa left.

I haven't seen many Gopi criticisms when Gia was still in the show though. A lot of people have been using the "free to criticize acting" card in response to say bad things about the new Gopi because they are unhappy with the change (a thread goes from something like "She needs to be expressive" to "She's just ugly and we need Gia now").
I'm not saying that is definitely the case here (the TM may have very well wanted to discuss genuine criticisms). But regarding people who have seen so many "anti new Gopi" threads and "anti Devo" threads lately, I'm sure you can understand why someone would've thought this was something similar to some past threads.

We enjoyed it a lot. Now also it should be enjoyed without accusing of bashing.This is not a praising club.Here u can tell dirty jokes also write tooo much inti🤬mate scene also. then why not criticism.If u talk about healthy critisism and not bashing than why all jokes and intimate scenes are not sensored.As school students also read such posts.
No offence to any one.This was not my negativity.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".