what the heck is goin on???!

heyy all...i dont mean to be rude but dont u all think that suresh is soooo damn bias? i mean when smita said that she had tonsels(i have experience,very diff to even TALK,forget singing!) then suresh yelled and scolded her,saying that sickness is not a reason to not sing well...then yesterday,suresh told vaishali that she was sick and that she should take care of herself and dint say ANYTHING abt her bad singing not being reason! what the **** is goin on?! they are supposed to be fair and if u realise..smita was bein showered with praises until she was sick 2 times...what the **** IS THAT SUPPOSED TO MEAN?! i knoe that they are proffesionals and alll..but if u realise..even if the others are not singing that well...they dont bash them up like they bash up smita!..i dont wanna insult anyone..i dont want to insult suresh or sonu..but i just wanna say that PLS STOP BEING SOOO DARN BIAS! aamir for eg..is completely under the bias stream..showered by praises and that is showing the effect on the voting..if they reely think that smita is bad,y did they sing her praises in the 1st place? and aamir was not even that popular until sonu anounced about his truth...since then aamir has gotten EVERYONES attention and votes! IMP NOTE: I AM NOT TRYING TO INSULT OR OFFEND ANYONE AT ALL...PLS DONT GET ME WRONG..i just want to point out that biasness is getting on mi nerves..and i wanted to stop it..cuz of this bias thing, the most deserving candidates are getting out...pls..if u agree with me..do reply...thank you

*peace 4 all*

Ash

**Post edited - Do not use abusive words.. Writing two letters and then putting stars is also considered against the rule... So, please do not use such words**

i totally agree with you...especially after watching the UK show tonight, where i think smita sang sooo well compared to the likes of vaishali and vasundhra. Smita got really slated and my whole family who were watching were thinking what the hell? is there anyway in which we can convey our thoughts to the saregama judges. I think by giving false criticism they are realy demoralising the kids which actually have the talent.

Vaishali was realy sick and you could hear it form her voice but Smita..... her "sickness" did nothing to her VOICE but she didnt SING well... theres a differance b/w sum1s voice and how they sing!

how ironic. you use offensive words and keep saying that you don't want to offend anyone. 😕 why use them in the first place?

ok first of all it wasn't sureshji, it was sonuji who had yelled at smita. and why did he yell at smita? because he said she used the wrong excuse. she sang WELL the day she had talked about the tonsel thingy. sureshji pointed out a mistake in her accuracy and she talked about sickness which has nothing to do with accuracy. vaishali's case was a bit different though. her voice sounded so strained and she was having so much trouble, it was clearly visible even if she didnt say so. i do agree that A was a bit too much for her performance but what happened in smita's case was not wrong. as far as amir is concerned, he completely deserves the votes he gets.

Have you ever even had tonselitist! Your thoart hurts so bad that not only is it difficult to talk or sing, sometimes the person can't even breath properly. Even with Tonselitist, Smita sung way way way better than Vashali! Vashali is just a little chatter box who talks more than sings. Maybe if she concentrated on her singing she could sing better. She is the only contestant in who I have not seen a improvement since the starting of the show.
Vashali should be eliminated next week.

well,i would like to tell you shezaadi that PLS RE-READ WAD I WORTE AGAIN!those words were not meant for the ppl they were meant for all the things that is happening on SRGMP...and secondly,i think that u should get a dictionary to find out what is accurate..accuracy refers to the sur of the song..which is DIRECTLY refers to the voice..thus im sure you are smart enuf 2 noe that her tonsels will definately affect her accuracy!!strain,like you said is there if u hav a sore throat but it is not visible if u hav tonselitist,it just HURTS LIKE ANYTHING and as smiley mentioned it is difficult to even BREATH at times,so please,before u say that again,ask someone with tonsels how it feels ok? i did not say that aamir should get lesser votes, but i said that the praises and comments he is getting is overboard..he is NOT at all being compared to others! i mean he is being praised for himself while others are bein compared to each other..he sings well, but compared to others,he isnt as good as they say..! i just want this bias situation to stop..thats all! im not saying that aamir is bad or anything, its just that suresh and sonu sing praises to those they like and dont really do the same to the others! and kpatel 123, yes there is a way to tell this to the zee tv ppl, u hav 2 write to them go to the website and u can write..

I see where you're coming from, and I agree that Vaishali should definitely have been eliminated. However, I also think that you're not taking a few other things into consideration. I think that the judges' comments are also based upon the child's age and maturity level, and therefore they criticized Smita for giving excuses. You also have to understand that the judges don't have any personal grudges against these kids, so what they say is for their own good. And Sonu Nigam clearly said that Vaishali deserved a C+ for her singing on today's show, that being said, if the public has even the slightest sense, they'll vote her off next week.

As far as what you said about Aamir, I don't agree with you at all. I do not think that Aamir is showered with praise, in fact, I think that he has set the standard so high for himself, that he has trouble reaching that level of excellence, and therefore only receives criticism from the judges. As far as his "story" is considered, like it or not, its a fact. And you can criticize the production house for using it in a negative fashion, but to criticize the kids for something they're not responsible for is ludicrous.

if they are soooo darn concerened abt the age grps, they should make the contest for only one age grp..like only for 10yr olds or sumthing! hw can they say that they wont criticize sum 1 cuz he/she is too young? this is a COMPETITION,all of them are the same here, only their VOICE and SINGING matters! NOT their age or maturity level! everyone is supposed to be treated as an equal,insuling one and not insulting the other because of age isnt fair!! if this competition was abt age, obviously the younger ones will be at an advantage cuz the judges wont b strict with them!!this is already proved in the case of vaishali and smita!

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

I see where you're coming from, and I agree that Vaishali should definitely have been eliminated. However, I also think that you're not taking a few other things into consideration. I think that the judges' comments are also based upon the child's age and maturity level, and therefore they criticized Smita for giving excuses. You also have to understand that the judges don't have any personal grudges against these kids, so what they say is for their own good. And Sonu Nigam clearly said that Vaishali deserved a C+ for her singing on today's show, that being said, if the public has even the slightest sense, they'll vote her off next week.

As far as what you said about Aamir, I don't agree with you at all. I do not think that Aamir is showered with praise, in fact, I think that he has set the standard so high for himself, that he has trouble reaching that level of excellence, and therefore only receives criticism from the judges. As far as his "story" is considered, like it or not, its a fact. And you can criticize the production house for using it in a negative fashion, but to criticize the kids for something they're not responsible for is ludicrous.

AMAZING!!! 110% with you Woh Ajnabee. Perfect response! 👏. As for your second point and paragraph regarding Aamir. Aamir sang "Saaware" on his second episode on SRGMP!!! Which even now is being deemed one of the finest performances on SRGMP this season. Also Just like Rohit's Dard - E - Disco It made HUGE impact right in the first couple weeks of the show on TV and all over the internet. So much so that when Vishal and Shekkar came as guests they mentioned recieving phonecalls and text msgs from friends and people to check out those performances.. So about the part of setting the excellence which had again been achieved by him a lot since then but not all the time is very true. He certainyl deserves every vote he is getting and many more. 😆

comments are too long... smita sang horribly... vaishali sang horribly... but vaishali's voice was noticeably bad whereas smitas was just bad