Smita's Soniye - Page 3

well the way you're asking people to vote for her it seems like you are her fan. and the way you speak of sonuji and sureshji shows that you know nothing about their musical capabilities.

all my point is that these judges are allowed to make musically accurate comments and express their opinions. thats why they are there in the show! and just because you dont agree with their opinion, does not mean you have to disrespect them like that.

Originally posted by: shehzaadi91

well the way you're asking people to vote for her it seems like you are her fan. and the way you speak of sonuji and sureshji shows that you know nothing about their musical capabilities.

all my point is that these judges are allowed to make musically accurate comments and express their opinions. thats why they are there in the show! and just because you dont agree with their opinion, does not mean you have to disrespect them like that.

well they can comment ofcourse... but they could have say it in a other way NICER...!!! I mean she did her best sooo... they could have say positive things tooo...!!!!

And the disrepecting thing...., pleaseeee!!!!!!!! 😕

Originally posted by: Raj*

She was soooo goood!!! Really i don;t know what's with those judges!!! ARROGANT my god i won;t even say here what i think about sonu and suresh... if i was there naaa they would have known... those ******!!!!! 😡 😡 Now please vote for Smita becuz she is very GOOD 😳 😃

is that not disrespectful?

maybe sonuji wasnt nice but sureshji said it in a pretty nice way. then why are you blaming him also?

sonu was a bit too harsh to her 😕

Originally posted by: Asseel

in the original song Sunidhi sang this song with the same high note
so i think smita was just tried to reach Sunidhi's level in singing and i think it's very well tried
but i'm really annoyed with the judges comment because the ppl who votes listen to the judges comments first to know who sang well and they vote for him and if smita eliminated next week ....!!! 😡

I know..I totally hate that😡 I just reall hope Smita isnt elminated next week😭

Originally posted by: Raj*

i guess ur a smita fan😛

OF COURSE 😳

Anamika & Smita are the best 👏

Originally posted by: Manik_mia

If this was a recording studio, the MD will ask the singer try again with half note lower and the song could have been mind blowing.

That's right. But this is not a recording studio , it is a contest and the performance of that week should essentially decide a participants future. She is a good singer but if she fared the worst of the lot that week, then ideally speaking she should be the one to get eliminated. Past performances, future performances don't matter when there are so many talented kids. Its the performance of that very week that should dictate the voting of the public.

Otherwise voting results can never be bias free.

Originally posted by: Asseel

in the original song Sunidhi sang this song with the same high note
so i think smita was just tried to reach Sunidhi's level in singing and i think it's very well tried
but i'm really annoyed with the judges comment because the ppl who votes listen to the judges comments first to know who sang well and they vote for him and if smita eliminated next week ....!!! 😡

If she is eliminated next week, then I should say public voted correctly. This week her perfromances of both days clubbed together stand out as the weakest.

She should not try imitating someone. She should hit the right notes as per her capability.If her experimentation costs her "elimination", then its just bad luck and bad performance that will be responsible for that, not judges comments. The comments could have been a bit more sugar coated, but they were bang on target.

i think sonuji and sureshji dont like himesh composed songs, otherwise smita sang very well and the song is also very likeble. no idea why they dont like that. sorry. few weeks back sonuji said the same to himesh song i dont extly who was singing but that was himesh song and sonuji said i dont like this song.