What a Blunder it was - Page 2

Originally posted by: redbia

I was just waiting for your opinion di.... i am fine ALHAMDULILLAH....How is your cuty pie baba....i think all the children were given the same situation. then it should not be the excuse. ok if we consider it then the children who got higher marks are also kids and they gave their best only then they got the good grades. now will it be fair if any of the other especially vaishaly tanmy and aamir get eliminated this week???? I just want to say that they are judging the children on weekly performances then how can they do that???will they give the same chance to other???

Sorry bia ,meant to reply to this much earlier,but didn't find time,😊

I tthink the decision of non elimination was good coz the children weren't given time to prepare.They were given a few hrs...In such a situation luck will play a major role...As we all know the kids don't get to chose their songs,the songs are either alloted randomly or maybe(in this case),the younger ones were given the first pick.In such a case,it is very much possible,that one kid got a song which he knows very well and another got a song which he has never heard before.....The same situation may happen at other times too,but in other days they are given 2-3 days to prepare.In 2-3 days ,a reasonably talented kid can learn a song(which is not extremely diffclt)......But only a genius can master a song which he has not heard in 4-5 hrs...In 4-5 hrs,one can get the basic tune,but wht abt harkats & murkis which are aplenty in Ashaji's songs.No one can master them in a few hrs.

The kids who got the top 3 positions were all probably,very familiar with their songs already(heard them many times)...This was certainly unfair to other kids.Even Lataji and Ashaji used to practise their songs for at least 24 hrs before the take.How can a kid learn the song in a few hrs..Remember Ashaji told Vibhore thatthey practised Aaja Aaja numerous times before the rehearsal....

Thsi is my POV😊

Originally posted by: rock&roll

Sorry bia ,meant to reply to this much earlier,but didn't find time,😊

I tthink the decision of non elimination was good coz the children weren't given time to prepare.They were given a few hrs...In such a situation luck will play a major role...As we all know the kids don't get to chose their songs,the songs are either alloted randomly or maybe(in this case),the younger ones were given the first pick.In such a case,it is very much possible,that one kid got a song which he knows very well and another got a song which he has never heard before.....The same situation may happen at other times too,but in other days they are given 2-3 days to prepare.In 2-3 days ,a reasonably talented kid can learn a song(which is not extremely diffclt)......But only a genius can master a song which he has not heard in 4-5 hrs...In 4-5 hrs,one can get the basic tune,but wht abt harkats & murkis which are aplenty in Ashaji's songs.No one can master them in a few hrs.

The kids who got the top 3 positions were all probably,very familiar with their songs already(heard them many times)...This was certainly unfair to other kids.Even Lataji and Ashaji used to practise their songs for at least 24 hrs before the take.How can a kid learn the song in a few hrs..Remember Ashaji told Vibhore thatthey practised Aaja Aaja numerous times before the rehearsal....

Thsi is my POV😊

HI where was it mentioned the kids had couple hours to prepare? I would like to hear that. Also here is the thing. The kids prepared Karishma Kapoors songs am i right?? So whats the big deal if Karishma or Kareena didnt come?? the kids could have still sung the Kapoor sisters songs. If Asha ji's songs are so hard then Zee has mature older people organizing the show they should know the kids potential and the hazards it would cause before hand. I would rather have the kids sing good prepared songs rather than hear unprepared songs to suit the needs of any celebrity that decides to show up or not. Zee needs to step up and take responsibitly thats the MAIN POINT i am driving from the past week. Take the blame themselves or put the blame on the main culprit in this case the Kapoor sisters. Stop giving the audiences LAME excuses. Period.

Sorry Anu Di......I know you know all the things better than me.......It was just my point of view and now see result was same today........those three did not give their best today aswell.....so i think all the other children are working harder than them. I think it was the only reason for which they were in bottom three...And as for the judges......I think they wanted to just save Loria....