Amanat Scolded by ID

Ismail Darbar yelled at Amanat Ali after he sang that song from Saawariyan! I personally liked his song! So i don't know WHY Ismail Darbar got so mad..
then it hit me..

Saawariyan is a SANJAY LEELA BANSALI movie! For his previous movies except for black he had Ismail Darbar do the music (Devdas and Hum Dil Dey Chuke Sanaam) then for this movie it isn't Ismail Darbar but Monty Sharma!

That's why Ismail Darbar said "AMANAT YOU COULDN'T EVEN SING SUCH A SIMPLE SONG?!"

I think someone was pissed.. 😆😳

WHO AGREES?

^^ I was thinking the same thing and I also heard Ismail was sposed to do the music for Sawaariyah firts but SLB changed his mind! 😕 But Amanat did mess up a lil but it wasnt as bad as he said! 😭

yepp! i agree it wasn't his BEST but come on it wasn't THAT bad as much as he said it was!! i would give him an 9/10!

Amanat's rendition was bad. He was getting out of breath and straining his voice a bit too much. One thing I have noticed about him is his breathing technique. He tends to take heavy breaths right into the mike. Well about ID's comment...I would like to believe that he has a bit more integrity than that to pounce on Amanat for his own vested reasons. He is after all his guru and he knew before hand which song he was going to sing. If he had a problem I think has every authority to make him change it.

i dont know much about singing but at least know that swarriya was not a easy song to sing
i like both amanat and ID but i didnot understand what ID was trying to prove that day
may be he had some problem with the director of swarriya or music dorector or the singer

i think its more of a ego rather than simplicity of the song

Originally posted by: diyaali

i dont know much about singing but at least know that swarriya was not a easy song to sing
i like both amanat and ID but i didnot understand what ID was trying to prove that day
may be he had some problem with the director of swarriya or music dorector or the singer

i think its more of a ego rather than simplicity of the song

I don't think the song per say in terms pitching was difficult. It needs a little attitude. I guess this was a wrong selection on his part.

itz true! he waznt good!

aneek is da best! 😃