Technical perfection vs dil ki perfection - Page 2

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

both are utmost essential and hence amanat stands out even in top 3 crowd 😊

I have started liking his perfections recently..he seems to have both...Has been impressed with Raja's perfections for long time though

Originally posted by: punjini

I would go for brain ka perfection. 😆

😆😆😆ye kabhi nahin hone wala in saregamapa..😃

Originally posted by: rehman23

Dil ke perfection is must.

If the singer can sing from heart and is a trained singer little technical flaws can be removed easily.

If a singer is technically perfect but cannot sing from heart its of no use.

To be successful the singing must touch ur heart.

Very true👏

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Technical perfection is something that should be present in each contestant, and in the SRGMP Top 3 it is. Dil ki perfection is an X-factor that wins hearts. So technical perfection is already understood and has already been excelled, now the winner will be the one that possesses the "dil ki perfection".

Absolutely👏IMO They all have dil ki perfection to varying degrees

I remember Qazi Tauqeer is only from dil ki perfection and now he is no where so please try to make balance and vote to Amanat because he is perfect like Aamir Khan.

Originally posted by: ptangelmom

amanat is perfect technically and in his heart.

Amanat definitely knows his stuff..

A technically perfect singer who does not touch the heart is like a shiny, gift-wrapped, bow-tied box without the gift.

Well i would like to quote here Harpreet's statement about his choice of a winner and he said;

His heart says Raja should win,
His Mind says Amanat should win, and
Both his heart & mind say Aneek should win

So i will go with Harpreet's choice.

Now coming to the matter of technical perfection it includes perfection of soul as well, there can be no two perfections of a single event. So dil ki perfection is part of the whole, that is technical perfection of a song rendition.

Hence when a song is technically perfect it has to be dil ki perfect as well, meaning all the techniques are in place like sur, taal, laya, bhava, rasa, uchharan etc etc.

Harpreet said that..? 😕

I'd say Amanat is technically perfect AND has "dil ki perfection."

There are more than 700 films made a year and considering 5 song per film there are 3500 song a year sang by singers
And all song are made technically perfect according to MD who made them
But out of 3500 song only about 15 makes in top as most popular

So, technically perfect, dil se perfection plus lots more needed