HR did the right thing...

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

zunaira

@zunaira

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: Munni*

Read him between-the-lines,
1) he is not a straight-forward person to say everything & every word

2)Raja is the biggest threat to Aneek, his second love( first one being himself)

3) he was trying to break down Raja, and his fan-following.

if you still believe he was supporting Mussarat??

1) did he ever let him finish speaking?

2) shouldn't he made his exit a little more pleasant for everyone specailly for Mussarat to remember?

3) Shouldn't he stand closer to him, & pat him even once?

4) he only tried to break-down raja as much as he could.

5) Mussarat was a good singer, but Himesh himself planned his exit, his only fav was/is Aneek.

6) he is trying his best to lower down Raja & his fans, so that Aneek doesn't have to compete with Raja in the finals.

i am surprised if HR still has any fans ...

very important thing to notice also is -

who won C2005? - debojit Saha , a bengali from Assam.

Whom did Himesh picked this year? - Joy Chakraborthy, a bengali from Assam

Aneek Dhar - another bengali

because Himesh realised that bengali's have great fan-following and support for their community.

well said👏👏👏 i totally agree wid u!

Quote

vishupriya1

@vishupriya1

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#12

[well said..........HR is frustated personQUOTE=gopalbhai]He has overdone it. What he has ultimately said is votting public was foolish!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

@ragamthalam0

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#13

Munni said it rite nothing more to say

Quote

anjalibc

@anjalibc

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: zunaira

well said👏👏👏 i totally agree wid u!

First of all Deboijit is from Assam. There were some more bengali's from Kolkata and other states also with Debojit and they lost.

Secondly yes, every Bengali house in Kolkata you will find trained and talented singers. So they really have a good ears for music for sure. They simply do not vote for Bengali. Then why was Smita out in II3 though she was good singer. Why last II3 Antara did not get to top. Why was Prantik and Prantika in VOI out ? and finally Joy who is also from Assam is gone. I have not observed SRGMP from beginning if any other Bengali went out.

SO THIS PROVES. Debojit is definately a good singer with a good voice. SO IS ANEEK . HE CAN SING ANY TYPE OF SONG. THAT IS WHY THE JUDGES SAYING HE SHOULD NOT BE HERE FOR THE COMPETITION AND DIRECTLY IN RECORDING STUDIO, HE IS SO GOOD. EVEN VS SAID SO.

If only they sing good then only they vote not just bec bengali as there may be very good singers in Kolkata who may not be contesting for the SRGMP OR VOI OR II3. This regional thing is ceated by other states like Assam, Darjeeling, Shilong and not Kolkata

Quote

293418

Suspended

Posted: 18 years ago

#15

Don't get me wrong here. But if Mussarat is good at certain types of songs, why is not the same thing said to Aneek? He almost always sings Sonu Nigam songs and apes him a lot. No doubt he is talented, but it hard for me to support him when he keeps on singing one person's songs and is not called out on it when the person he is singing like just happens to be a mainstream playback singer.

Quote

sid

@siddh_v

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: bhatta_sam
HR told the right thing on friday....mussi was better than raja last week...so based on last week performance raja shud go......i saw people did complain that HR is not supporting mussi....now on friday he supported mussi and still people r having problem......the only thing i want to say that HR shud have said that more politely....but he is never a politically correct person...

HR told the right thing???? What are u talking about????

How was it Raja's fault if your Mussi got out???

Why should Raja have a guilt for the rest of his life ???

They voted 10 out of 10 for everybody today so if somebody goes out tommorrow then thats not fair??? How dose that work???

Mussi picked a sufi song to sing in a comedy special episode and what did Himmy do??? Nothing let him sing it.

When has HR supported Mussi since ANeek came to his gharana. Never.

Quote

sid

@siddh_v

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: anjalibc

Yes, right. I absolutely agree. Mussarat is better singer than Raja. He is a class singer but bit shy like. Raja is over hyped like. Now he will go just see bec public definately voting for good singing unless and until like Darjeeling for II3 regional votings go crazy. He was already in bottom this time. Yesterday also he did not sing so good. HR is right.

But how is it Raja's fault if he gets the vote. Why should he feel guilty for the rest of his life. Raja is not and was never overhyped. Mind u Raja already got out once and Raja came back as a wild card entry if u remember and then after coming back he struck with a bang. He has been in bottom and he has been critisisezed when he was wrong. Mussarat was a good singer but u cant say he was better than Raja and if he was better than Raja then he was better than Aneek too.

Quote

sid

@siddh_v

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: anjalibc

First of all Deboijit is from Assam. There were some more bengali's from Kolkata and other states also with Debojit and they lost.

Secondly yes, every Bengali house in Kolkata you will find trained and talented singers. So they really have a good ears for music for sure. They simply do not vote for Bengali. Then why was Smita out in II3 though she was good singer. Why last II3 Antara did not get to top. Why was Prantik and Prantika in VOI out ? and finally Joy who is also from Assam is gone. I have not observed SRGMP from beginning if any other Bengali went out.

SO THIS PROVES. Debojit is definately a good singer with a good voice. SO IS ANEEK . HE CAN SING ANY TYPE OF SONG. THAT IS WHY THE JUDGES SAYING HE SHOULD NOT BE HERE FOR THE COMPETITION AND DIRECTLY IN RECORDING STUDIO, HE IS SO GOOD. EVEN VS SAID SO.

If only they sing good then only they vote not just bec bengali as there may be very good singers in Kolkata who may not be contesting for the SRGMP OR VOI OR II3. This regional thing is ceated by other states like Assam, Darjeeling, Shilong and not Kolkata

Now i dont get one thing. In one place u are saying Mussarat is a better singer than Raja and he should have stayed and in the other place u are saying Deebojit was good. So do u mean to say Deebojit was better than Vineet and Hemachandra????

Deebojit winning is a totally diffrent story. We all know he did not win because of his singing abilitied. He won because of absolute regionalism and HR drama. HR treated Debo like crap and people felt sympathetic for him and voted for him , thats why they sacrifcied vinit and I think thats what is going to happen with Aneek too because people are getting tired of HR drama and they want to get rid of him. Thats why they will be willing to sacrifice Aneek. Which would be a shame because Aneek is an excellent singer.

Smitha in II3 was an excellent singer but she looked like a 40 year old pimpled aunty thats why she went out. Yes that sucks but sorry thats the mentality.