Vineet vs. Raja Who sang better

Page

Poll

Vineet or Raja Who sang better Aake Seedhi Lagi?

nehamadan1222

@nehamadan1222

Beginner

Posted: 18 years ago

WHo do you think sang Aake Seedhi Lagi from the movie half ticket better Raja or vineet? and why? In all fairness since Raja's performance is new and in everybody's mind I will give the link to vineet's performance http://youtube.com/watch?v=O0-WGSE2iwA. So please if you can view both performances and then vote. (hint: you can watch Raja's performance in one of the forum updates). I personally like Raja's performance b/c i loved the presentation and the overall performance. You have to understand in a concert when singers have to dance they most likely end up lip sinking so they can have an entertaining show with singing and dancing. However Raja had 2 major dress props a female and male costume. Do you know in acting your physical appearance sometimes can distract you from acting, and raja completely ignored that and concentrated on his singing. Hats off raja you sang with half lipstick and half mustache (which would be the most distracting thing around the mouth and can make a person conscious while singing,) you did a great job. :)

Edited by nehamadan1222 - 18 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

tindrum

@tindrum

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Raja's performance was livelier as he could capture the mood of the song and he carried it so well with such a strange getup..something no one would dare to do 👏 ..Vineet's performance although good looks a little thandi... feel of the song was missing...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

ranjusweet

@ranjusweet

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

I just heard Vineet singing the song from the this link.Vineet made a mess of the song.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O0-WGSE2iwA

Raja was awesome and he is still not the winner but has already sung a big number for Shankaar Ehsaan Loy. I think this has never happened for any Saregamapa contestents till now.

So we should agree he is the best.

Quote

joyce

@joypaul

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Although, we are not allowed to compare, I must mention that it was Abhaas who did full justice to this song.

Quote

chewingums

@chewingums

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

Not really a fair comparison.

Vinit was allowed to dance around in the performance. Raja was forced to stand still thanks to the two strategically placed cameras. That took away from a bit from Raja's performance. (Not singing)

Raja's costume was "interesting". That could make Vinit's performance a bit pale.

Raja is a 26 year old with a voice that can power a city. Vinit was a teen, with his voice yet to match Raja's. Raja does score here. The voice difference between the two genders contrasted a lot more with Raja than either Vinit or Abhaas.

Quote

Fatima

@Qnz_diva

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

OmG...I just heard vinit and I have to he was bad compared to raja. Raja was reallllli good. 👏

Quote

maha

@*-Surroor-*

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

I really liked Raja's performance 👏

Quote

Lee Min Ho

@gujunpyo

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

THIS ISNT A SONG TO COMPARE VINEET N RAJA...RAJAS VOICE IS STRONG DATS WHY HE CAN HOLD A GIRLS VOICE..UNLIKE VINIT...BUT STILL VINEET IS D BEST!

Quote

nehamadan1222

@nehamadan1222

Beginner

Posted: 18 years ago

It may be true that vinnet has a differnet voice quality b/c he is a teen, however he was 17 I dont think is voice quality is going to be impacted that much. That is why i think raja is better. I still have the same voice from till now (25. Raja performed better.

Quote

Vineet vs. Raja Who sang better

Poll

Related Topics

Explore Topics