Created

Last reply

Replies

24

Views

1.7k

Users

12

Frequent Posters

Nupur9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11
Versatility....is one issue
That was the one you brought up......hence our reply

Fame is another......
which as you know is not directly proportionate to your talent.
Getting lots of offer another.....
That's where intial hyping & contact works.
And getting prasises from these besura mentors is altogether a different ballgame.....
lets not even go to there 10ers.....

All the above maybe co-related but they are not linked!!
Chak de Raja....!!!
tindrum thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: amoghars

Please get the facts right. Here is one of my previous post that I am pasting.

There is an accusation about Raja being the replica of Sukhwinder Singh and Kailash…….and moreover he is not versatile and sings over and over Kailash's and sukhi's songs. Can we analyze the songs sung by Raja and the original singers…….lets start and here is the list

Kacche Dhage By Latadi

Allah Ke Bandeh By Kailash

Zindagi Ek Pyas By Jaspinder Narula

Naina Thag Lenge By RAHAT FATEH ALI KHAN

Hoga Tumse Pyara Kaun By SHAILENDRA SINGH

Maa Tujhe Salam By A R Rehman

Saara Zamana Hasino Ka Deewana By Kishore Kumar

Tu Hi Re By Hariharan

Let the music play By Shamur

Affo Khuda By Rafi Saab

Tare Gin Gin By Sukhbir

Mahiya (old DUS) By Shankar Mahadevan

Awaarapan Banjaarapan By Kay Kay/Kareem MM

Ruth aagiye re Sukhwinder Singh

Still do you think my Raja is not versatile?

Add

Udit Narayan - O ri chori

Nusrat fateh ali khan - Ankhiyan nu chain...

Adnan Sami - Kiss me baby too😊

RonnySingh thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#13
Thanks TINDRUM for so thoughful. Aapki Kya Baat Hai.
Now there is not much to say, you guys have said it all.

Koi Maane Ya Na Maane par Yeh Sach Hai...Ki RAJA is the BEST ALL ROUNDER. The one who doesn't agree just go and watch previous episodes. He has sung from all major lead singers. Now you want him to singh USHA UTHAP style (Rambha Ho Ho Ho Ho Ho)

Choro Yaaro.....Hosh mein Aayo
Alrightokie thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: guhasuparna

I just saw a post stating that Aneek sings only Sonu songs. I don't agree with the post because Aneek sang songs from Metro and Hey Baby which were not sung by Sonu and he also sang a few songs sung by Himesh. Also, Aneek has the perfect playback voice (as Shekhar mentioned quite a few times).

The one person who has not shown much versatility on Saregamapa sets is Raja who sings only Sukhwinder songs and the truth is with his husky voice, he can only sing songs in one genre........

Hey i know what you mean.......😊 Lately i have also noticed that..... And these people are mostly Mussu's fan, if you read carefully all the posts, you will also realise it. I think you happen to target the wrong contestant. I am myself a biggest fan of Aneek but Raja is also a good singer so i have nothing against him. Infact I want Aneek, Raja and Amanat to be there in atleast top three spots. Not all but some of the Mussu's fans are claiming Aneek getting stuck with sonu's song. which is not true at all. Again not all but some of them in this forum enjoy bashing Aneek day and night for all the wrong reasons, and this just my opinion. No offense to anyone but this what i have observed after reading many posts in this forum. So chiill , and lets say it together that Aneek Rocks.👏

Nupur9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#15
The confusion is not if one is versatile or not...
The problem starts when we start targeting particular contestant to prove that the other is better....
Aneek has sung primarliy Sonu songs...can't deny that.
Is he a bad singer.......?
The answer is no.........He has good voice quality.
But does that make him versatile.....?
No.......

We all have our favorites....but our favorites won't shine more if we put another contestant down.....!!
iaminfrankfurt thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#16
Raja is a phenomenon. Amanat may be the most versatile one, Aneek may be the perfect one, Musarrat may be the most accomplished one but nobody comes close to Raja. His voice is divine. You just feel like closing your eyes and listening to his songs over and over again.

'Chinamma-Chilkamma' is perhaps his least appreciated song. But I have been listening to it since yesterday. I don't like the original so much but I am almost addicted to Raja's rendition of the song.
Edited by iaminfrankfurt - 18 years ago
aniline thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Iloveapu

The confusion is not if one is versatile or not...
The problem starts when we start targeting particular contestant to prove that the other is better....
Aneek has sung primarliy Sonu songs...can't deny that.
Is he a bad singer.......?
The answer is no.........He has good voice quality.
But does that make him versatile.....?
No.......

We all have our favorites....but our favorites won't shine more if we put another contestant down.....!!



👏 that's how all of us should think...
Ophelia thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18
It seems Aneek is being compared to Raja and even judges have made Aneek seem inferior by saying he should be more like Raja.

So here is my take on why Aneek is the best.

No offense, but to me Raja's voice is not as well suited for mainstream playback singing, albums for sure. Amanat is great but to me he lacks the enthusiasm and expressive quality Aneek has.
aniline thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Megha25

It seems Aneek is being compared to Raja and even judges have made Aneek seem inferior by saying he should be more like Raja.

So here is my take on why Aneek is the best.

No offense, but to me Raja's voice is not as well suited for mainstream playback singing, albums for sure. Amanat is great but to me he lacks the enthusiasm and expressive quality Aneek has.



No offense taken off course. Not every one likes even Udit, Sonu, Kumar Sanu. Means it is not necessary every one likes his voice. Its ok even with 80% on his side.

And yes Aneek is good no doubt about it. And I think the field of music is like a huge ocean no end of it...Even if there are thousands of songs, we still like a new song or singer if its good..
Ophelia thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: aniline


No offense taken off course. Not every one likes even Udit, Sonu, Kumar Sanu. Means it is not necessary every one likes his voice. Its ok even with 80% on his side.

And yes Aneek is good no doubt about it. And I think the field of music is like a huge ocean no end of it...Even if there are thousands of songs, we still like a new song or singer if its good..




I'd like to shake your hand. Because I would also love to see Raja make a niche for himself in the field of music as Kailashji has. It's true I would like Aneek to win but I would not want Raja to lose. Raja also has the potential to contribute to the diverse music industry that now exists.

I extend the olive branch to all Aneek and Raja fans. We're all friends here and in the end we all appreciate singing at its best.


Edited by Megha25 - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".