Hi there,
I understood that you didn't meant their emotions as funny but your post may create misunderstanding to others.The song related to emotions and it really touches the heart.The song might look simple but it need emotions to express the song and I repsect Vishal emotions who was not able to express his feelings after listening to that song.It's not easy to touch viewers or mentors heart but Aneek has done that several times.His heart was fully into the song and it really touches everybodys heart.
Maybe Himesh has given Aneek the same song as has been sang by Vinit in 2005 but today after listening the same song , I and friends able to see the voice and singing difference in both of these singers.Himesh has not potray Aneek as Vinit and there a lot differences in them.Aneek is not related to any love story or Topiwala image as Vinit.As for my opinion Himesh made Aneek sang the same song because he wants the viewers to judge that Aneek and Vinit has their own individuality and voice quality.
It doesn't matter if Aneek sings the same song as sang by Vinit but we should see that Aneek able to carry the song in his own style.Vinit is a great singer and we should not compare any of them.Both of them has great talent.I am not judging Aneek through who is his Guru or which gharana he is attached to.I and my friends from Malaysia are just amazed by Aneek versatility and excellent singing.
i dont mean to be mean or anything, but when vishal was like sorta crying after aneek's performance, the camera kept going back and fourth to vishals face, then to aneeks face, for like 5 times, and it was so funny.
did u also notice that because aneek has some similarties to vinit from the past season, the himesh is kinda trating him as vinit? cause in challenge 2005, i disticktly remeber vinit singing this song...and making jackie sherrof cry...!!