my views on SRGMP talent

I really lost my heart when last night I saw Mauli crying when the mentors were agianst her choice of song, I wonder why didn't bappi da (her guru mentor) corrected her abt the song when he also commented on her wrong choice of song, I mean it was strange that he was commenting on her final performance and not when he would be practicing with her all the week.

Anyways to me the talented singers in the show are Junaid, Harpreet, Musarrat and Mauli.

I like Harpreet becoz he is very shaant and cool person and I don't like Poonam bcoz she's very arrogant, when Ismail jee requested the Hit-It squad to give her chance of playback singing, she did not at all thank anybody, neither Ismail jee nor Hit-It squad and not even audience...

I think talent is not everything, attitude also matters...

Are behenji singing ke saath arrogant or cool ka kya rishta? i don't understand....******

Moderator's Note: No personal attacks please.. There is already a warning note given for members not to make personal attacks.. Please see to it you dont repeat it

Poonam is Arrogant .. how in the world did u get that.. from Ur TV.. u dont even knwo the gurl .. DOnt forget that this show is Shot in india and they cut out alot of scenes ..
Damn i cant believe how Weird some ppl are ..
from a TV screen u can tell someone is Arrogant . .

i think u need to Fix ur TV..
cuz all the fuzz is confusing u .. making u think that Poonam is arrogant.. She is there for singing not to be Judged on her personality...

DO u know her personally...
I think u are getting tooo invovled with this show ..and calling Poonam Arrogant ..
why.. how is she...

The only thing u should be getting out of this show is WHO is talented .. and if u think Mauli DAve is talent.... i feel sorry for u ..
Cuz even ID and V&S everyone has said the poonam is the most talented in the girls..
and mauli has been GIVING the WEAKEST performance..
Her attitude will get her no where..Cause once u are behind the MIc in a recording studio .. all that matters is ur voice.. and Right now she is not ready .. too many flaws...

oh my goodness i never meant to hurt anybody feelings but u all are so arrogant too, i just said what i felt, it wasnt abusing someone...but did u see ur comments, one said gals are brainless and the second comments are ufff...i cant digest...what is this, is this the way to treat someone who just shared his/her views and even i mentioned the reason y i said so...nobody commented on anything else on the whole topic except one sentence, im amazed is this the way to treat ur fellows here on this forum

oh my goodness i never meant to hurt anybody feelings but u all are so arrogant too, i just said what i felt, it wasnt abusing someone...but did u see ur comments, one said gals are brainless and the second comments are ufff...i cant digest...what is this, is this the way to treat someone who just shared his/her views and even i mentioned the reason y i said so...nobody commented on anything else on the whole topic except one sentence, im amazed is this the way to treat ur fellows here on this forum, y u ppl took this so serious and the second person who commented on my topic said that im taking it serious...i just said a word and u r telling me that im getting very serious abt this show and u wrote the whole para...what u hv to say abt urself now...

p.s the show i watch here is almost of 2 hrs or 90 min...i watch the whole show and nothing is edited here...but the way how do u know that the show is edited, do u edit it? maybe the show u watch in UK or US is edited that y u don't know that how a singer is and how they sound...plz grab the full show and then comment

Khushalay,
I do not think Mauli Dave is talented! She is terrific in item numbers (but NOT all of them) and not in other genres. I DO NOT call that TALENTED.
THIS IS MY VIEW (No offence to you or other Mauli fans).
However, if you like Mauli, you're free to do that 😃 . But I don't think anyone can deny that her recent performances weren't good coz this is a FACT! No one is against you having Mauli as a FAVOURITE, I'm sure! 😊
As for attitude, it matters, but I don't think it matters in SRGMP. It is a MUSICAL reality show, and a person is supposed to be judged on SINGING and Performance only, right 😊 ?
Yeah, if a person is TOO arrogant, it's not acceptable. But no one is that arrogant on SRGMP, I think! I can't really say that Poonam is arrogant nor can I say that she is NOT arrogant coz I have no clue about her as a person .

Originally posted by: Khushalay

oh my goodness i never meant to hurt anybody feelings but u all are so arrogant too, i just said what i felt, it wasnt abusing someone...but did u see ur comments, one said gals are brainless and the second comments are ufff...i cant digest...what is this, is this the way to treat someone who just shared his/her views and even i mentioned the reason y i said so...nobody commented on anything else on the whole topic except one sentence, im amazed is this the way to treat ur fellows here on this forum, y u ppl took this so serious and the second person who commented on my topic said that im taking it serious...i just said a word and u r telling me that im getting very serious abt this show and u wrote the whole para...what u hv to say abt urself now...

All i can say is that.. this is a singin competition.. And if mauli is a horrible singer then yes she should be out.. She does not deserve to be on the show singin like that.. Junaid was in the bottom 3 .. why cuz many ppl are voting for bad singers..

but u are coming off topic and saying that u think poonam is arrogant .. what is that all about .. i did not say anything personal about mauli .. We are here to Judge the singer are their ability to sing not their personality..

I know that in Brooklyn we have edited version of the show.. thanks for the info... but still the whole show is not shot in 90 mins or 2 hrs.. the show is shot monday and then is send to editors so the show can fit the 2 hr or 90 mins time ... SO MAYbe she said thanks to V&S , ID and the junta but we dont know .. no one will know that.. alot of thing s happen on that stage that is aired.. to india or where u are from.... so it is up to the editors what we see and what we cant... so next time.. just keep that in mind before making comments like that..on someone u dont even know..

And so what if i wrote a paragraph...

.. about mauli and bappi da . U asked why he did not say anything.. If u remember a while bak .. Bappi da told mauli .. think 10 times before picking a song and next time. Listen to your guru..

it is not up to bappi da to pick the song..he only Helps her with sur, taal and tells her how to improve.. But the contestants already pick the song ..practice and then go to their gurus for advise. ..The most he can do is help her.. But from comment that bappi da made a while bak i think Bappi da is trying to help her..

excuse me when did i say that mauli is my most favourite, i only said that her tears melt my heart, just that and being a human being it is natural and among favourites i also said that junaid, harpreet and musarrat...

Do you know what Poonam went through in life? Her life was soo hard. She isn't arrogant...