AR Rehman & Javed Akhtar in Jodhaa-Akbar - Page 2

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Well that is clearly your opinion. I have mine, and I don't feel Shreya suits Ash as much as Alka would now (and ARR seems to have the same view).

and I am not surprised 😆😆 .. Enjoy the songs. 😊

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Well that is clearly your opinion. I have mine, and I don't feel Shreya suits Ash as much as Alka would now (and ARR seems to have the same view).

Everyone had their own opinions and learn to respect to them, and also it's in the rules too. If one person like Alka then respect that if one person like Shreya then respect that also. 😊

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

and I am not surprised 😆😆 .. Enjoy the songs. 😊

Oh, so you feel ARR is not qualified enough to judge that? Interesting. Well, then I'm not suprised at your preference either. It's more believable now 😊.

Originally posted by: Jersey_Chickxox

Everyone had their own opinions and learn to respect to them, and also it's in the rules too. If one person like Alka then respect that if one person like Shreya then respect that also. 😊

Precisely the point I have made in the post you quoted. You simply repeated it. She has her opinion, I have mine. 😊

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Precisely the point I have made in the post you quoted. You simply repeated it. She has her opinion, I have mine. 😊

I know.. 😆 It wasn't just to you, it was for her too, I just took your quote as an example.

Originally posted by: mermaid_QT

Something also tells me that people will ferociously defend an 80 year old nightingale singing for 18 old Kajol.. so why the double standards even we were to believe the judgment of shreya being too young and ash being too old? 😛

Just noticed this addition. I can only speak for myself - I have never been in favor of Lata singing for actresses of my generation. Yes, she does sound too old for an 18 year old. Again, that is my opinion, and I respect yours - if you really feel that she really would suit an 18 year old Kajol. Just wanted to clarify that I have no double standards.

i think they are all good singer .. alka .sherya . But my Personal Favor.. is KAVITA... Kavita is just perfect she can sing for anyone..

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Just noticed this addition. I can only speak for myself - I have never been in favor of Lata singing for actresses of my generation. Yes, she does sound too old for an 18 year old. Again, that is my opinion, and I respect yours - if you really feel that she really would suit an 18 year old Kajol. Just wanted to clarify that I have no double standards.

well, this time around, we share the opinion. It bothers me when ppl display double standards and I am sure you have seen it around..