Himesh was trying to make a valid point - Page 2

okie so every song does not suit her voice.. but that does not mean .. she has to go OFF pitch .. look at mussarat, poonam , saberi , Look at all the contestants.. they have a genre they are good at .. and anita did too .. but .. she has to sing different genres...that is rules of the game,.. they are looking for a voice that will be on a international level.. do u really want a "mayya mayya one hit wonder whoz last 4 performance . were average and even some Below average. this is the battle of sur.. not mayya mayya.. or one genre.. she has not proven herself.. And yes she has a different type of voice.. so what.. should we give her a medal for that.. okie fine.. we will give her a medal .. but why deny someone else.. the right to a competiton becuz ppl cant get over Mauli the one hit wonder... Anita was a better singer .. and she performed.. very well yesterday and did good okie.. well mauli .. did average.. and today .. pityful..

Himesh hai hi itna emotional fellow - in C2005 it was Maa, here it is Maiyya 😉

u cant just sing just one song.
there needs to be versatility.

Indian Idol has more talented singers because the singers there show versatility, they experiment.

Rehaan in II only sang the same type of songs and was criticised and was out next episode, so people should sing all types of songs and that is why this year, we have singers like Emon, Chang, Prashant and Parleen who experiment and do well.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Himesh hai hi itna emotional fellow - in C2005 it was Maa, here it is Maiyya 😉

😆 Maa was more Debojit factor 😉

But if she is going to sing badly in whole contest she will nto be saved just because she sang maiya maiya well..
why doesnt she simply sing mayya mayya in every episode because it seems that is the only peformance to her credit.
Its unfair to other contestants who work hard to do well in all episodes who will loose to a contestant who can sing mayya mayya well.. she maybe a good singer but in the contest performance in that episode should count..

Himesh just wants to dominate every one..

a winner of such a big contest needs to be ble to sing all kinds of songs. they cant just win by singing one kind of song or even one song.

if she wins this contest, what is she going to do after?

u cant survive in the music industry singing just one type of songs.

Sunidhi Chauhan is a prefect example of someone who is so versatile.
She can sing any song, just look at the difference in Dekho Na to Dhoom Machale.

It was ok even if she sang one "type" of songs.. but here she wants to survive just on mayya mayya which is ridiculous..

Originally posted by: .:Aphrodite:.

Himesh was being so manipulative. Mauli was horrible and she didn't just get a chance to sing one or two lines, SHE SANG THE WHOLE SONG

How can they give special preference to Mouli? I felt really bad for anita, it was so obvious her so called mentor didn't even have any feelings towards her. Even in his gharana, he has favorites where he would fight for one contestant then treat another like they don't matter.

Vishal made really good points. The whole situation made me sick to the stomach.

thts what i said as blaming himesh for anything on ur starry tantrum thread😉

yeah Himesh was definately having a point..though wasnt able to c it....
😉

Originally posted by: .:Aphrodite:.

yeah someone must have put a gun on Himesh's head to actually allow Mouli to sing again so it can't be poor bhola bhala sweet innocent Himesh's fault.

yeah and even Vishal and Shekhar told Mussarat to sing other genre song to prove point that he can be versatile......

HR told her to sing another song to prove that she cant be versatile.........

Your problem is u dont like HR..... but I am sick of reading ur HR is manipulative for Mauli comment on every thread....

everyone knows i dont make any personal comments but i m sick of seeing that comment on every thread now🤢