ismail darbar - Page 2

Originally posted by: sweetmusic

I think being honest does not necessarily means being rude. he could have said the same things in a nice way. I think Hariharan is good about his comments. Ismail has always been rude and demoralising. He could have said the good things about the song too.

Ismailji was the most encouraging man in c2005, but was also a very strict teacher, trying to take the best out of each and everybody. He looks to be rude, but is very honest in his opinion. He has seen UA and BS from one year, from the time of c2005 audition. Probably still he think them to be his student, correct the things whatever he felt like. "Tum log ne mere gaane ka to band baja diya" seems to be a bit rude, please remember he was the same person who told Debu "Mein pehle soch raha tha ki mein ghora par sawar kar raha hoon, par tum log sab to Gadha nikle" Debu was very humble and he replied "Sir mein isbaar ghora banke dikhaunga", now it depends on how people takes his comments, if positive way, they will improve. If the contestants think themselves star, and just ignore them, then it will be their mistake. I feel Ismail ji is a tough taskmaster, emotional, perfectionalist.

Originally posted by: lalit1

😆

Originally posted by: rongmon

Ismailji was the most encouraging man in c2005, but was also a very strict teacher, trying to take the best out of each and everybody. He looks to be rude, but is very honest in his opinion. He has seen UA and BS from one year, from the time of c2005 audition. Probably still he think them to be his student, correct the things whatever he felt like. "Tum log ne mere gaane ka to band baja diya" seems to be a bit rude, please remember he was the same person who told Debu "Mein pehle soch raha tha ki mein ghora par sawar kar raha hoon, par tum log sab to Gadha nikle" Debu was very humble and he replied "Sir mein isbaar ghora banke dikhaunga", now it depends on how people takes his comments, if positive way, they will improve. If the contestants think themselves star, and just ignore them, then it will be their mistake. I feel Ismail ji is a tough taskmaster, emotional, perfectionalist.

Maye so. But he is not a guru in the sense of it for all participants and Guru does not neccesarilly means being rude. I dont know about Ismail being a perfectionalist.n Its not like every movie of his is a hit and he is the most outstanding MD. He was the one who thought ARR's music is not that great either in one of his interviews. So much for his arrogance.So I dont think he should be put on a pedestal up there.

Originally posted by: lalit1

😆

CB and Lalit: Negotiating 101 - Wild display of emotion, walking away from the deal, Creating Deadlock are tricks of the trade...... I think he is being himself but these are good negotiating traits!!

Now coming to your other point about shooting the finger and your Dharm dialogue, I will say this:

I would rather get "Pissed Off" than "Pissed On" so I see nothing wrong in that "reet" either !! Just my "street smarts" opinion.....😆

Originally posted by: Awww

All of the mentors in SRGMP Contest projected themselves unprofessionally. Be it Jatin/Lalit, Himesh, Aadesh or Ismail Darbar. None of these people are saints. The trio situation during the SRGMP Contest was an example of poor role modeling from these mentors. Each mentor contributed their negativity towards these contestants.

The guest of honours also were rude at times. I remember Jagjit Singh's remarks towards one of the contestants. Delar Mehdi was rude too. 🤢

I agree with you completely. I dont like Many of these musical maestros when it comes to personality. However, because others are poor in behavior does not change my perspective towards him. And since this post was about ID , I expressed my feelings regarding him.

Originally posted by: reachmaryam007

i really hate ismail darbar.he is so rudely behaved.i know whtever he said 2 d contestants was right but d manner in which he gave his opinion was extremely rude.

Isn't hate a very strong word??? He has given his critical comments,accept them for their worth and improve accordingly.He is pretty strict and he doesn't just pass comments for the heck of it.