who n why??? - Page 2

Originally posted by: abhijit shukla

Vinit's voice is not matured yet - I reserve my opinion for 2-3 years on him.
Hemu sings well but I never felt emotions in his singing.
I will not say anything about Himech till he quits snging thrrough his nose. May be he sounds great without nasal twang.
Shaan has great voice and control and expressions but where is his classical base?
Vishvaas - the only time he impressed me so far was yesterday whn I heard 'Ni main samajh gayaa'.
Ujjaini has good voice for a sultry siren type songs but I have yet to hear a melodious song from her.

That leaves Sharib, Nihira and Himani.
Himani has great controll, classical base and phenomenal voice quality but when she sings out side a genere, I will call her the best.
Sharib is too obsessed with impressing people to sing a song and giving it a soul.
Nihira has everything - classical base, quality of voice, versatility, range and ability to bring emptions - although in that last quality Himani has an edge over her.
Its Unnis-Bees; between the two; or rather pauneBees-Bees. Two months ago I likes Himani more, today I like Nihira more, if I hear 2-3 versatile songs form Himani, it might be himani again.

thanx for replying but if u never felt any emotions in hemu's voice.........so it's ur problem bcoz ever1 knows dat hemu sings with great feel...(no offence mean 2 u).....n can i plz know whom u voted 4?????

Originally posted by: abhijit shukla

I like to think it as opinion rather than problem - and everyone is entitled to his opinion. Then again opinions are like belly buttons - everyone has one.
I voted for Nihira; could have voted for Himani though - its just that in later part of C05 I did not see too manyvatietied in her singing. I would have to listen to her singing 10-15 Lata songs before I could vote for her.

BTW you did not oppose my views on others so may I take it that you did not think of rest of my viesws as problems?

it isn't like dat...............wut u said abt vinit was true.....i also agree wid u on that point n i dun care abt himesh n debo..........u didn't say any bad stuff abt nihira sharib n himani............so i dun't think i needed 2 comment on dat. I also think vishwas n ujjaini r not very gud singers.

As far as i know hemu is a flawless singer so i wrote wut i thought was right and as u said every1 has a right 2 give his or her opinion so i did.

Why is Ishta not on the list

My favorites are : hemachandra, nihira, debojit, shaan, ujjaini

Nihira and Vinit because they both are verrry versitile!

can't say anything . i think vinit, shaan hemachandra& himesh are excellent

the one and only Shaan!!!

and why is Himesh's name in best singer category? 😆 😆 😆 but glad to see that nobody voted for him.

Shaan!
Shaan!
Shaan!
Shaan!
Shaan!

I enjoy the singing of the top 5 of C2005 and HR but nobody comes close to Shaan!

good to see Shaan leading the poll as he deserves to be called best from the list

I voted for Hemachandra because of his versatility.