The best top5 - Page 2

Interesting to see 1 vote for II2 😆 ..tHEN iS Anuj,Sandeep,Anatara better than top5 SRGMP contestants(According to me even Ujjaini and Twinkle were better than Antara)

Originally posted by: madhavir108

What farah khan sees in them god knows..they arejust plain awful

Farah Khan as a judge in a musical show


😆

You could have included V Super Singer also.
Naresh Iyer and Ravindra are from that competition. Dont remember the names of other contestants.
Adnan Sami, ARR were the judges.

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Actually, to a well trained ear, many of them in SRGMP also went besura quite a lot of times, but the difference was at the microtonal or the semitonal level.
The only people who were in sur for the most part were Nihira, Himani, Hema and Sharib.

and vinit also acoording to me

vinit wasnt out of sur anytime(but sounded like shotuing in high pitches)

what kind of poll is this 😕

sab sur se bahaar jaate hai live singin mein!

my rankings are ::
1) INDIAN IDOL 1
2) SRGMP
3) INDIAN IDOL 2
for me FG is not applicable!

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Actually, to a well trained ear, many of them in SRGMP also went besura quite a lot of times, but the difference was at the microtonal or the semitonal level.
The only people who were in sur for the most part were Nihira, Himani, Hema and Sharib.

I meant in the top 5 only. I thought Vinit's sur was the lesser of his issues. What are your thoughts on Debo, then?

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Vinit has serious issues with singing 'apshruti'

Interesting how you rated them...

'Apshruti'? Explain please.

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Apshruti means, not singing true to the shruti. In English, you say - Off Key.

Very difficult for an untrained ear to catch such slip ups.

Is there a difference between Apshruthi and being besura? I have certainly caught many a singer go off-key, it's pretty obvious (but I thought that was being besura).

No wait...

I think I know what you're saying. Do you mean when they start a song on a different scale? If that's what you mean, I agree, it is harder to catch if the variation is not great.